Hu Tao vs Nahida: Which Character Should You Choose in Genshin Impact 5.1’s Second Half?

The second phase of Genshin Impact version 5.1 is approaching, bringing with it the highly anticipated rerun banners for two fan-favorite characters. The 5-Star Pyro character Hu Tao and the 5-Star Dendro Archon Nahida will have their Event Wish banners active starting October 29, 2024. While both units hold unique advantages, players may find themselves limited in Primogems and need to choose wisely who to wish for.

Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of Nahida and Hu Tao is crucial in making this decision. In the following sections, we’ll analyze which character offers superior utility and gameplay convenience to help guide your choice.

Should You Choose Hu Tao or Nahida in Genshin Impact 5.1?

Nahida and Hu Tao each occupy distinct roles in Genshin Impact 5.1, and both are valuable additions to many roster setups. Nonetheless, their differing strengths, weaknesses, and overall utility should be carefully evaluated.

Hu Tao: Strengths and Weaknesses

Hu Tao is a strong DPS unit (Image via HoYoverse)

Hu Tao, a 5-Star Pyro unit who wields a Polearm, is known for delivering substantial damage. She typically serves as a Pyro vape DPS in team setups, showcasing impressive damage potential with her Elemental Burst. Below are her pros and cons:

Strengths:

Exceptional scaling from Elemental Burst
Self-healing capability
Effective against both single-target and AoE foes
HP scaling makes her accessible for beginners

Weaknesses:

Stamina management can be challenging at C0
Optimal damage requires maintaining low HP
Frequent Charged Attack canceling is necessary for maximum damage output

Overall, Hu Tao serves as a robust DPS character, capable of swiftly defeating high-health enemies, especially when paired with effective Hydro support like Xingqiu or Yelan. If you’re prepared to practice Charged Attack canceling to enhance her stamina management (or if you aim for her C1 talent, which alleviates stamina consumption during Charged Attacks), she could be a worthwhile choice.

Nahida: Strengths and Weaknesses

Nahida is a top-tier support character (Image via HoYoverse)

Nahida, the 5-Star Dendro Archon, wields a Catalyst and is celebrated as a powerful support unit in Genshin Impact. As with other Archon characters, Nahida excels in support roles and is integral to numerous Dendro reaction-focused teams. Here are her strengths and weaknesses:

Strengths:

Outstanding Dendro application
Highly adaptable, fitting into various team configurations
Ability to link multiple enemies for simultaneous damage
Useful passive for gathering overworld materials
Constant Elemental Burst uptime with proper play

Weaknesses:

Limited effectiveness for overworld exploration due to her small stature
Relies heavily on high Elemental Mastery, which may require extensive farming

In summary, Nahida shines as an exceptional Dendro support character who not only inflicts solid Dendro damage but also provides invaluable buffs to her allies through her Elemental Burst. She is effective at C0, and players can easily integrate her into free-to-play teams.

If your roster lacks strong Dendro support, Nahida is an excellent character to pursue.

Conclusion: Nahida is the Superior Choice in Genshin Impact 5.1’s Second Half

Nahida is the recommended pull for 5.1 (Image via HoYoverse)

While both Hu Tao and Nahida present unique advantages, Nahida stands out as the stronger choice for pull value and overall utility. Although Hu Tao can unleash significant burst damage, her capabilities can’t quite match Nahida’s exceptional Dendro application and ability to enhance team performance through buffs.

Given that Dendro is currently among the most powerful elements in Genshin Impact, Nahida ranks as one of the top Dendro characters available. If you’re operating on a limited Primogem budget and are uncertain which character to select, choosing Nahida would be your best bet, as Hu Tao may reappear in future banners.

Source