How Mike Flanagan’s Clayface Movie Can Learn from the 2024 Horror Success

Overview

Mike Flanagan’s interpretation of Clayface merges classic comic origins with influences from the animated series.
His knack for weaving human themes into horror narratives enhances the prospects for the upcoming Clayface film.

Excitement is building for the upcoming DC Universe cinematic lineup, which will debut this summer with James Gunn’s Superman. While the spotlight shines predominantly on the return of beloved DC superheroes in this new narrative framework, another project has piqued the interest of both superhero enthusiasts and horror aficionados alike: a Clayface film penned by Mike Flanagan.

Despite limited information available on the project, recent revelations have offered tantalizing glimpses into Flanagan’s storytelling direction. This iteration of Clayface is set to be a “Hollywood horror story, ”focusing on his most recognized form: a B-movie actor who consumes a serum to retain his youthful appearance, only to face the grim consequences of becoming a formless monster. This premise intriguingly echoes one of 2024’s anticipated horror films, Coralie Fargeat’s Oscar-nominated The Substance, which scrutinizes the frightening realities of aging in the entertainment industry. Flanagan’s vision for Clayface promises to explore the emotional depths within its horror elements without feeling derivative.

Connections Between The Substance and Clayface

The hybrid monster from the climax of The Substance (2024), referred to as

Flanagan appears to draw inspiration for his portrayal of Clayface from both the character’s original and animated series versions. Clayface first emerged in 1940 as Basil Karlo, a B-movie star turned criminal upon discovering that a remake of one of his films would be cast without him. This foundational story highlights the character’s struggle with aging and the subsequent choices he makes, setting the stage for deeper exploration.

Conversely, the Batman: The Animated Series introduced a more nuanced Clayface in the episode “Feat of Clay.”Here, the character named Matt Hagen becomes disfigured and, after receiving a pharmaceutical that initially restores his looks, transforms into the recognizable monster upon overdosing on it. This adaptation enriches the character’s backstory, framing him as both a villain and a tragic figure beset by external circumstance. Flanagan’s narrative seems poised to navigate similar territory, blending horror with poignant storytelling.

Although Clayface predates The Substance, the thematic parallels are palpable. The Substance features Elisabeth Sparkle (Demi Moore), a television fitness icon discarded by her rude boss (Dennis Quaid) due to her age. After a car accident, she is introduced to “The Substance, ”a mysterious elixir promising to recapture her youth. Driven by desperation, Elisabeth’s decision leads to chaotic outcomes.

Both narratives serve as cautionary tales regarding society’s fixation on youth and beauty, while their Hollywood settings anchor these stories in relatable motivations. The Substance managed to distinguish itself in the horror genre with a compelling thematic framework, which Flanagan’s Clayface film could similarly emulate.

The Rationale Behind Choosing Clayface for Flanagan

Clayface from Batman: The Animated Series (1992)

Flanagan’s plate is full with various projects, including adaptations of Stephen King’s Dark Tower and Carrie, along with his upcoming film The Life of Chuck. Although he’s primarily on board as a writer for Clayface rather than as director, his unique vision is likely to permeate the project through his strong character-driven storytelling. Flanagan consistently merges horror with relatable themes such as grief and addiction, which suggests a thoughtful interpretation of Clayface is on the horizon.

While this character may diverge from Flanagan’s usual supernatural storylines, his proven ability to bring depth to horror narratives suggests he will approach Clayface with the same care. As an enthusiast of the genre, Flanagan is already familiar with the striking similarities to The Substance, recognizing how thoughtfully addressing genre norms can elevate a project (he has suggested enjoyment of the film on platforms like Letterboxd).

While Flanagan and the DC team are likely to draw their own inspirations, they would benefit from the successful approach taken by The Substance to create an engaging Clayface movie. If anyone is equipped to harmonize engaging entertainment with a profound human message, it’s undoubtedly Mike Flanagan.

Source & Images