The initial release of Hogwarts Legacy certainly set a new standard for Harry Potter-themed gaming. Nevertheless, it lacked several elements that fans had eagerly anticipated. In light of this, the upcoming sequel has a significant opportunity to enhance the gaming experience by introducing innovative features and addressing fan requests. By refining existing mechanics and incorporating more immersive aspects, Hogwarts Legacy 2 can surpass its predecessor and deliver a more compelling experience.
Moreover, it’s essential for the sequel to shed some of the less favorable aspects of Hogwarts Legacy to truly flourish and secure a chance at Game of the Year (GOTY) recognition. Despite heavy competition, particularly from highly anticipated titles like GTA 6, Hogwarts Legacy 2 can establish itself as a contender, particularly if it replaces one significant feature from the original game with a more engaging alternative. Fortunately, there is a successful series that can provide inspiration for this transformation.
Rethinking Hogwarts Legacy’s Structure
The Importance of Structure in a School Sim
Hogwarts Legacy struggles as a school simulator for various reasons, primarily its emphasis on an overarching narrative that occurs largely outside the school environment. Players often find that the Hogwarts setting serves merely as a backdrop for completing quests, rather than immersing them in the school experience that fans cherish from the Harry Potter series. The central narrative undermines the potential for a rich school-life simulation.
A key factor indicating why Hogwarts Legacy lacks engaging school simulation features is its open-world structure. Players are encouraged to complete side quests and explore the surrounding areas at will, making it easy to neglect the Hogwarts environment and its academic aspects. The absence of class schedules means that attending lessons feels insignificant, as many are limited to the beginning of the game.
This unrestricted exploration diminishes the authenticity of the school environment. Players can roam the castle at any hour without any repercussions, eliminating the need for evening routines or common room interactions. The game could benefit from adopting a smaller, more guided world to create a unique gameplay experience. A restructuring similar to that of the Persona franchise could be an effective approach.
Taking Cues from Persona 5
Implementing a Daily Routine
A fundamental aspect that Hogwarts Legacy 2 needs to incorporate is a structured gameplay schedule inspired by games like Persona 5. In Persona 5, the gameplay unfolds over several months, with clear deadlines for objectives, allowing players to engage in various activities throughout their days. Classes take up specific slots, and players must strategically manage their time amidst their academic responsibilities.
This structured gameplay offers clear motivation for players, prompting them to consider how best to allocate their time each day, thus creating a richly immersive routine. The worldbuilding in Persona 5 is significantly enhanced by this approach, making the settings feel more dynamic and alive. Fire Emblem: Three Houses employs a similar model, balancing exploration with character interactions and story progression, which could also benefit Hogwarts Legacy.
By adopting a similar structure, Hogwarts Legacy 2 can emphasize school-sim elements while still allowing players the flexibility to explore open-world features. Imagine a gameplay cycle where players attend classes during the day, engage in exploration during the afternoon, and retire to their common rooms at night which would also serve as an avenue for introducing key features like nighttime prefect patrols.
The potential for a structured gameplay experience opens a wealth of possibilities, such as featuring nighttime-exclusive quests and rare creatures appearing only during certain hours. This could significantly enhance elements like stealth gameplay, as players would need to navigate Hogwarts while avoiding vigilant prefects. A revised structure could thus make previously overlooked features feel relevant and exciting.
The Imperative of Focusing on School-Sim Features
Remembering the School Setting
It is essential for Hogwarts Legacy 2 to prioritize school simulation elements, as the school setting is integral to the Harry Potter universe. The absence of these features in the original game has been a letdown for many. While community mods have attempted to fill this gap by introducing additional classes and study options, this highlights a missed opportunity in the original design of the game. Thus, Hogwarts Legacy 2 must strive to integrate and prioritize these educational aspects effectively.
While the action-centric narrative of Hogwarts Legacy has its merits, it is vital that the next installment strikes a balance that does not overshadow the school simulation elements. Games such as Persona 5 and Fire Emblem: Three Houses illustrate that strong narratives can coexist with structured gameplay, enhancing the overall experience. There is no need for Hogwarts Legacy 2 to abandon its predecessor’s narrative depth while shifting the focus toward a more immersive school environment.
By embracing this new approach and integrating structured gameplay, Hogwarts Legacy 2 has the potential to redefine itself as a unique RPG that harmoniously blends school-centric elements with exploratory gameplay and the captivating lore of the Harry Potter universe. This new vision could position the game as a formidable competitor for GOTY accolades.
Source: Lam0rak/YouTube
Leave a Reply