Google Reverses Decision on Nextcloud Files App Block

Google Reverses Decision on Nextcloud Files App Permissions

In a surprising turn of events, Google has decided to restore permissions for the Nextcloud Files application on Android, previously hampered due to the withdrawal of a critical “All files access”permission. This decision came amidst widespread criticism, including allegations of monopolistic practices directed at Google by Nextcloud and other stakeholders.

Background on the Permission Revocation

The revocation of this vital permission, effective from an update in September 2024, was justified by Google on the grounds of “security concerns.”The tech giant recommended that Nextcloud integrate alternatives such as the Storage Access Framework (SAF) or the MediaStore API.

Error message Changes to auto upload from Nextcloud app for Android

Nextcloud’s Response to the Situation

Nextcloud voiced its discontent with Google’s explanations, especially after appealing the permission decision since mid-2024 without a satisfactory dialogue. Recently, the company publicly shared a critical blog post outlining its ongoing challenges with Google.

Allegations of Anti-Competitive Behavior

In the blog post, Nextcloud drew parallels between its situation and the European Commission’s penalties against Apple and Meta, arguing that Google’s actions exhibited anti-competitive tendencies. The post articulated concerns over Big Tech’s preferential treatment, with Nextcloud asserting:

Google, Apple, and Microsoft have been repeatedly fined for abusing their gatekeeper position, hampering competitors like Nextcloud. This is not about security; it is about protecting their own services and advertising revenue. It is a clear example of Big Tech abusing its power to the detriment of users and competition.

Google’s Change of Heart

Shortly after the publication of the blog, Google appeared to backtrack, offering to reinstate the necessary permissions. Andy Schertzinger, Nextcloud’s Director of Engineering, confirmed this development to The Register, stating, “Google has decided to restore the permissions to our Android app so we can bring back the full file syncing functionality.”The Nextcloud team is preparing to release an updated version of the app that restores its complete functionality.

Request for Clarification from Google

Additionally, The Register highlighted its inquiry to Google regarding the original permission removal, questioning whether the revocation was a result of an automated process or a stringent review. As of their reporting time, no clarification had been provided by Google.

Source & Images