Goldman Sachs Cautions on Super Micro Computer (SMCI) After Its Rise as “Best Performing Hardware Stock” Due to “Unfavorable” Risk-Reward Outlook

This article does not provide investment advice. The author holds no shares in any of the companies mentioned herein.

Market Volatility: A Case Study of Super Micro Computer

Financial markets are known for their volatility, often reacting dramatically to both external and internal factors. A prime example of this phenomenon is Super Micro Computer (NASDAQ: SMCI), a provider of advanced server solutions, which has experienced significant fluctuations in its stock price. This year alone, its shares surged approximately 40%, recovering remarkably after an earlier decline of around 30%.

Future Projections Amidst Challenges

Despite the stock’s rollercoaster performance, Super Micro Computer’s long-term outlook remains steadfast. The company projects a robust $40 billion in revenue for the fiscal year 2026, driven largely by an uptick in shipments of its Blackwell-based products. Furthermore, it narrowly avoided a stock delisting in February by submitting overdue financial statements to the SEC, which had been on hold pending an internal review following a critical report from Hindenburg Research in August 2024. However, the company must navigate increased competition and a stringent internal control framework, both of which may adversely affect profit margins.

Analyst Caution: Goldman Sachs Perspective

Goldman Sachs analyst Michael Ng has expressed caution regarding Super Micro’s recent stock rally, indicating a shift in sentiment towards a more bearish perspective. He highlights that with the stock now leading the hardware sector coverage by Goldman, the valuation presents an unfavorable risk-reward scenario:

“SMCI stock is up 38% year-to-date, making it the best performing stock in our Hardware coverage; with the stock trading at 16X F2025E P/E, we view risk-reward as unfavorable given downside risks on valuation, competition, and gross margins.”

Key Factors Influencing Market Sentiment

Ng identifies three critical factors contributing to his negative outlook:

The surge in competition as rival companies increase their research and development investments, leading to a decreased differentiation of products.
Super Micro’s margins are projected to face sustained pressure in FY 2025, 2026, and 2027, stemming from rising competition, the ongoing transition to Blackwell products, and challenges related to the company’s high concentration of customers and suppliers.
He anticipates that Super Micro’s historically high valuation premium of 12X NTM+1 P/E over server OEM peers (like DELL, trading at 9X) will likely decrease due to reduced product differentiation and customer-supplier risks.

Revised Ratings and Predictions

As a result of these factors, Michael Ng has downgraded Super Micro’s stock rating from ‘Neutral’ to ‘Sell, ’ reducing the price target from $40 to $32, which reflects a valuation of 9X NTM+1Y earnings per share.

Further Insights from JP Morgan

Adding to this cautious outlook, JP Morgan analyst Samit Chatterjee reinforced similar concerns, indicating that Super Micro Computer could face margin pressures in FY 2026 compared to FY 2025, potentially hindering earnings per share growth against revenue growth.

Source & Images