Going Dutch Triumphs in One Major Aspect Where Shifting Gears Falls Short

Shifting Gears: A Critique of Tim Allen’s Latest Sitcom

Tim Allen’s new sitcom, Shifting Gears, revolves around the tumultuous relationship between him and his daughter, Riley, played by Kat Dennings. While the show has attracted a sizable audience due to Allen’s long-standing appeal in the sitcom genre, it has not escaped the grip of criticism. Many reviewers argue that the central theme—Matt and Riley’s father-daughter feud—lacks depth and originality. The narrative unfolds after Riley returns home, 15 years after leaving with her now-divorced husband, bringing unresolved issues to the forefront.

Examining the Character Dynamics

Despite its popularity, the first few episodes of Shifting Gears have drawn criticism for their stagnant narrative momentum. Riley’s quest for a renewed sense of purpose conflicts with Matt’s previously content and solitary life. Their constant clashes come off as repetitive and uninspiring, which can make it difficult for viewers to remain engaged. As a result, episodes tend to blur together without unique elements that stand out.

In sharp contrast, another new sitcom, Going Dutch, delves into a more complex father-daughter relationship driven by clear motivations. Here, Colonel Patrick Quinn, portrayed by Denis Leary, finds himself stationed in Stroopsdorf, Netherlands, as a disciplinary action. In this unique setting, he grapples with his daughter, Captain Maggie Quinn, who is deeply committed to her work with the local Dutch community. Their opposing motivations inject new life into their interactions, creating a dynamic that feels fresh and engaging.

Narrative Thrust in Going Dutch

One of the standout features of Going Dutch is the contrasting objectives of its leads. Colonel Quinn is eager to escape Stroopsdorf, whereas Captain Maggie staunchly defends her community and opposes her father’s militaristic views. This ideological clash transforms the show’s episodes into strategic moves on a narrative chessboard. With four episodes released so far, viewers can appreciate the incremental growth in Quinn and Maggie’s relationship, setting the stage for ongoing development.

Supporting Characters Stand Out in Going Dutch

While Shifting Gears introduces a limited array of supporting characters, they often serve merely to support the main storyline rather than enrich it. The mechanics at Matt’s auto shop, for instance, are mostly present for comedic relief, lacking deeper characterization. The notable exception is Brenda Song’s Caitlyn Baker, who provides a glimpse of complexity amidst otherwise flat interactions.

Going Dutch Cast List
Character	Actor	Best Known Role
Colonel Patrick Quinn	Denis Leary	Tommy Gavin in Rescue Me (2004-2011)
Captain Maggie Quinn	Taylor Misiak	Ally in Dave (2020-2023)
Executive Officer Major Abraham Shah	Danny Pudi	Abed Nadir in Community (2009-2015)
Master Sergeant Dana Conway	Laci Mosley	Jayla in Florida Girls (2019)
Corporal Elias Papadakis	Hal Cumpston	Zach Marconi in Nine Perfect Strangers (2021)
Private Anthony Chapman	Dempsey Bryk	Airk Tanthalos in Willow (2022-2023)
Dr. Katja Vanderhoff	Catherine Tate	Donna Noble in Doctor Who (2006, 2008), Nellie Bertram in The Office (2011-2013)

In contrast, Going Dutch subsequently enhances its narrative with vibrant supporting characters that bring richness to the storyline, allowing both Quinn and Riley to engage dynamically with their peers. The presence of seasoned actors, like Danny Pudi and Catherine Tate, adds a tangible sense of humor and depth. Tate’s portrayal of the quirky Dr. Katja Vanderhoff, who mistakenly leads the Colonel to think she operates a brothel when she actually runs an immigration office, further contributes to the comedic fabric of the show.

For viewers looking for engaging sitcom content, Shifting Gears and Going Dutch present contrasting approaches to familial conflicts, character development, and humor. As the former attempts to find its footing with ongoing episodes, the latter excels in creating a compelling narrative interwoven with vibrant characters.

Stay updated on primetime coverage and join the conversation! Sign up for our weekly Network TV newsletter for insights from actors and showrunners about your favorite series.

Source & Images