Austrian Supreme Court Rules EA Sports FC Loot Boxes and Ultimate Mode Are Not Considered Gambling

Landmark Ruling: Austrian Supreme Court on Loot Boxes in EA Sports FC

In a significant decision that could reverberate through the gaming sector, Austria’s Supreme Court has ruled that the loot boxes in EA Sports FC, particularly within the FC Ultimate Team mode, do not amount to gambling. This ruling has been welcomed by Electronic Arts (EA), marking a pivotal moment in the ongoing debate over loot box mechanics in video games.

Details of the Court’s Ruling

According to a report from GamesMarkt, while the court determined that these loot boxes do not fall under the category of gambling, it acknowledged that elements of gambling are present. The ruling elaborated that although players receive randomly allocated content from packs, they can use their skills to influence gameplay, thus creating a reasonable expectation of success. This nuanced perspective sheds light on the complexities surrounding digital loot boxes.

Reactions from EA and Litigators

In a statement to GamesIndustry. Biz, EA expressed satisfaction with the court’s definitive ruling, emphasizing that it brings much-needed clarity to both players and the industry in Austria. Their spokesperson noted, “We welcome the decision from the Austrian Supreme Court confirming that EA Sports FC and FC Ultimate Team mode do not constitute gambling.”

Conversely, Padronus, the litigation funder representing Austrian gamers in this class-action lawsuit, criticized the ruling as “legally flawed”and indicated potential further legal action, depending on the views of other judges on similar cases pending before the Supreme Court.

The Broader Context of Loot Boxes

The classification of loot boxes as gambling has ignited a fierce debate in the gaming realm for several years. Notably, in 2024, another Austrian court arrived at a similar conclusion that these mechanics do not equate to gambling. In contrast, in Brazil, President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva recently signed legislation that will ban loot boxes, set to take effect in March 2026. This move reflects a growing trend among various nations considering restrictions on loot boxes.

Looking Ahead: Potential Legislative Changes

While this ruling closes the chapter on one specific case, legal expert Leon Xiao informed GamesIndustry. Biz that it may incite Austrian lawmakers to propose stricter regulations around loot boxes. He highlighted the discrepancy that most existing gambling laws do not explicitly address the mechanics of loot boxes, which could necessitate legislative updates.

As the gaming landscape continues to evolve, the implications of this ruling and any future measures taken by Austrian officials remain to be seen. For now, EA holds a significant legal advantage as it navigates potential regulatory challenges in key markets, including the UK.

Source & Images