Exploring the Real Events Behind Hulu’s Candy Series

Hulu has established itself as a powerhouse for limited series inspired by real-life events, with standout productions such as the engaging Candy. Following the success of The Act in 2019, which starred Patricia Arquette and Joey King and chronicled the story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard, and The Girl from Plainville in 2022, featuring Elle Fanning as Michelle Carter, Hulu’s 2022 addition, Candy, created by Robin Veith and Nick Antosca, has arguably reached new heights with its audience reception and critical acclaim.

Candy features Jessica Biel in a captivating role as Candy Montgomery, a Texas woman engulfed in controversy after she murdered her close friend Betty Gore with an axe. This intense series navigates Candy’s life leading up to the murder and the sensational trial that ensued, showcasing a performance from Biel that may define her career. The gripping true story behind Candy Montgomery continues to fascinate, inspiring several adaptations even four decades post-incident.

Uncovering the True Story of Candy Montgomery

The Scandalous Twists in Candy Montgomery’s Life

Promotional Image of Hulu's Candy Series

Candace “Candy”Montgomery was born on November 15, 1949, in Texas and initially led a seemingly idyllic life. Marrying Pat Montgomery young, she had two children and was an active participant in her local church community. However, beneath this veneer of normalcy, Candy experienced an inner turmoil, expressing a desire for excitement beyond her “rather boring”life with Pat (as reported by Texas Monthly).

This craving for adventure manifested in a scandalous affair with Allan Gore, the husband of her close friend, Betty Gore. The affair began innocuously during a church volleyball game in the summer of 1978 when a collide led Candy to notice Allan’s appealing scent. The two proceeded to engage in a year-long secret relationship, repeatedly breaking their own rules about limiting their encounters, as noted by the Dallas Morning News.

Everything changed dramatically one fateful day in June 1980, when Candy visited Betty’s home and was confronted about the affair. Tensions escalated, culminating in a horrific moment where Candy claimed Betty wielded an axe, leading to a frenzy in which Candy delivered 41 fatal blows to her friend.

After washing up at Betty’s house and seemingly resuming normal activities, including picking up her children, Candy quickly became the prime suspect and was arrested for murder. During her trial, she asserted self-defense, with her attorneys arguing that hidden, traumatic memories drove her uncontrollable rage during the incident.

What Hulu’s Candy Series Misses

The Narrative Focus of the Limited Series

Real footage from the Candy Montgomery trial

While Hulu’s Candy adeptly portrays major events—Candy’s affair, the murder, and the aftermath—there are critical aspects that it omits. The series largely centers on the sensational trial, glossing over significant details related to her upbringing and relationships.

Key elements of Candy’s childhood trauma, which played a crucial role in her psychological landscape during the trial, are barely touched upon. Under hypnosis, Candy reportedly uncovered memories of abuse from her mother—issues that her defense suggested contributed to her violent reaction when attacked by Betty.

Furthermore, the show simplifies Candy’s marriage and friendship dynamics. While it implies a stable marriage, the truth was fraught with tension. Likewise, Betty’s character is portrayed more negatively than accounts suggest, where she was well-loved in her community. Candy and Betty’s friendship was complex, often overshadowed by the affair’s guilt but deserving more attention.

After the trial, the narrative fails to address the full impact on Candy’s life post-acquittal. Though acquitted, she faced a tumultuous journey filled with societal backlash and a need to rebuild her identity away from the traumatic events.

Life After the Trial: Candy and the Gore Family

The Unfolding of Your Future Post-Trial

Candy Montgomery leaving the courthouse with her husband Pat Montgomery

After her acquittal, Wylie, Texas, was rocked by public outcry against Candy Montgomery, who became a controversial figure. The media vilified her, leading to protests outside her home. Subsequently, Candy and Pat relocated to Georgia but divorced after a few years. She transitioned to using her maiden name, Wheeler, and found work as a mental health advocate, helping others navigate depression while choosing to remain largely private.

Allan Gore also faced a tumultuous aftermath, remarried twice, and lost custody of his daughters with Betty, who were raised by her family. Many years passed before he reconciled with his daughters, who have since built their careers and lives.

According to Buzzfeed News, the Gore family expressed their discontent regarding the dramatization of Betty’s murder, indicating their reluctance to revisit the trauma they experienced decades ago. Nevertheless, today’s media landscape has capitalized on true-crime stories, perpetuating interest despite the time elapsed since the tragedies.

Max’s Love And Death: Another Take on Candy Montgomery

A Tale of Two Series: Candy Montgomery’s Portrayal

Promotional Image for Love & Death miniseries

The gripping nature of Candy Montgomery’s murder of Betty Gore has prompted a second adaptation, Love & Death, produced for Max. Created by David E. Kelly, noted for Big Little Lies, this series premiered slightly less than a year after Hulu’s Candy. Though both series offer faithful recountings, they diverge in their narrative style and audience engagement.

Candy leans into the psychological thriller genre, emphasizing the trial and its surrounding drama, while Love & Death adopts a lighter tone and character-driven approach. It explores the affair in greater depth and paints Allan Gore as a more charismatic figure compared to his portrayal in the previous series. This framework allows viewers to engage with the emotional nuances of the characters.

There are also stark contrasts in the performances of Jessica Biel and Elizabeth Olsen, each bringing distinct facets to the role of Candy Montgomery. Biel’s portrayal conveys depth, internal struggles, and psychological complexities, while Olsen offers a more relatable and openhearted interpretation, enhancing the emotional layers of Candy’s character.

Overall, both Candy and Love & Death showcase the intriguing complexity of Candy Montgomery’s narrative, highlighting the lasting impact of the events that culminated in Betty Gore’s tragic death.

Source & Images