Exploring Buck’s 9-1-1 Couch Trend and Its Impact on His Romance with Eddie

9-1-1 has shown a fascinating evolution in the relationship between Eddie (Ryan Guzman) and Buck (Oliver Stark), transitioning from potential adversaries to steadfast friends. Fans of the show, however, continue to speculate that their connection could evolve into something deeper, as suggested by a popular couch theory. Although Buck has been part of the series since its inception, Eddie joined the 118 in its second season, initially sparking jealousy from Buck. Yet, Eddie’s charm quickly won Buck over, and he was embraced as part of the 118 family. In the latest season, these two have solidified their status as best friends, supporting each other through numerous challenges.

Throughout their journey in 9-1-1, Eddie and Buck have faced extreme situations—from tsunamis to bee-nados—and have emerged closer for it. They have developed an unwavering trust in one another, with Buck’s coma dream accurately predicting Eddie’s challenges with his son, Christopher. Despite their strong bond, the duo has maintained the boundaries of friendship, though passionate fans argue that their chemistry hints at a deeper potential.

Exploring the Couch Theory in 9-1-1

Couches: A Symbol of Buck’s Romantic Journey

Ryan Guzman as Eddie Diaz and Oliver Stark as Buck Asleep in 9-1-1

The couch theory associated with 9-1-1 stems from Buck’s tumultuous history with furniture as a reflection of his romantic endeavors. This narrative began post-Connie Britton’s departure when Buck initiated a relationship with local news reporter, Taylor Kelly. The couple’s plans to move in together led to a decision to replace Buck’s couch, but their eventual breakup left him without a new couch once more. As the series progressed, Buck entered and exited several relationships, each time correlating with a new couch.

In an effort to break this cycle, Buck purchased a chair—an act symbolizing his desire for independence and caution regarding his romantic entanglements. However, his parents intervened during a particularly harrowing near-death experience, showcasing their repaired relationship through a couch purchase. Unfortunately, Buck found their choice uncomfortable, leading to a pivotal moment on Eddie’s couch, highlighting Buck’s undeniable comfort in Eddie’s presence.

This theme was captured in season 6, episode 12, titled “Recovery.”As Eddie brought them beers, Buck fell asleep comfortably—demonstrating his ease on Eddie’s couch, which fans perceived as a metaphor for their relationship. This comfort further resonated when Eddie’s son, Christopher, also dozed off beside Buck, reinforcing the notion of a harmonious family dynamic waiting to unfold.

Why Buck and Eddie Make the Perfect Pair in 9-1-1

The Fanatic Following Since Season 2

A blended image of Eddie and Buck on 9-1-1

There exists a considerable overlap in the personalities of Buck and Eddie, which fosters their compatibility as a couple. Both characters exemplify strength, loyalty, and a readiness to prioritize others’ needs over their own, often at the cost of their personal happiness. This sacrifice is particularly noted in light of Eddie’s anticipated short-lived exit in season 8. Their shared recklessness, whether on the job or in everyday situations, further underscores why they would thrive together.

Their mutual understanding of each other’s strengths and weaknesses positions them uniquely to grow as partners. They would likely offer constructive criticism to one another, as they have demonstrated in past episodes, leading to personal development. Their vibrant chemistry is evident in the fun they bring out in each other, suggesting that both relationships—with Bobby and each other—merit further exploration in the ongoing narrative of 9-1-1.

Is a Romance Between Buck & Eddie Feasible in 9-1-1?

Queerbaiting or Genuine Chemistry?

While the couch theory primarily serves as a metaphorical exploration, the implications stretch beyond mere speculation; they evoke genuine intrigue regarding Buck and Eddie’s potential relationship. The question of whether the showrunners are weaving a deeper narrative or merely indulging in queerbaiting is a pressing one. Fans are quick to recall moments from season 2 when Buck and Eddie were live-streamed and viewers suggested they appear as a couple. Such moments reaffirmed that even in casual settings, their connection often invites misconceptions of romantic involvement.

As the series develops, particularly in season 8, there have been instances hinting at jealousy and intrigue surrounding Buck’s relationships, opening doors for the writers to explore his bisexuality and possibly frame earlier interactions as unrecognized crushes. Even though Eddie identifies as straight, Buck’s evolving understanding of his own identity could lead to an unexpected romantic storyline, akin to that of TK and Carlos in 9-1-1: Lone Star. The writers have the opportunity to navigate this narrative carefully and authentically, should they wish to veer into a romantic dynamic between Eddie and Buck.

Catch the return of 9-1-1 on Thursday, March 6, 2025, on ABC.

Source & Images