Explaining the Real-Life Legal Controversy Surrounding Max’s The Pitt

Max’s upcoming medical drama series, The Pitt, is the subject of scrutiny that extends beyond typical pre-release buzz. The show has found itself tangled in a legal dispute even before its premiere. Set in the emergency department of PTMC, a fictional trauma hospital in Pittsburgh, The Pitt features a talented ensemble, led by Noah Wyle in the role of Dr. Michael “Robby”Robinavitch, the chief resident at the hospital. Viewers can expect a gripping portrayal of the realities faced by medical professionals during intense shifts.

Fans of the iconic series ER may feel a wave of nostalgia as they witness Wyle don scrubs once more, albeit in a markedly different role as a mentor to medical students. This has led to speculation about whether The Pitt acts as a spin-off of ER, even though the production team has clarified that the two shows are distinctly separate entities. At the core of the ongoing lawsuit against the series lies the question of whether The Pitt is too reminiscent of ER.

Legal Action: The Widow of Michael Crichton vs. The Pitt

Sherri Crichton Claims The Pitt is an Imitation of ER

The lawsuit, initiated in August by Sherri Crichton, widow of ER creator Michael Crichton, centers around allegations that The Pitt is essentially a reboot or a copy of ER. She argues that both she and her late husband’s heirs are entitled to compensation from the series due to its similarities to the original medical drama. In her lawsuit’s statements, she asserts:

“The Pitt is ‘ER.’ It’s not like ‘ER.’ It’s not kind of ‘ER.’ It’s not sort of ‘ER.’ It is ‘ER’ with the exact same executive producer, writer, star, production companies, studio, and network as the planned ‘ER’ reboot.”

“Rather than afford Crichton the ‘created by’ credit he deserved, Defendants would pretend their reboot was not his creation at all, thereby enriching themselves to the tune of millions of dollars — potentially hundreds of millions or several billion dollars in success — and depriving Crichton’s heirs of their rightful share.”

Sherri Crichton claims that back in 2020, she was informed by John Wells, former ER showrunner, about a potential ER reboot. In accordance with the “frozen rights”clause of her husband’s estate, she maintained that her approval was required for any projects involving ER. Initially, she was led to believe that her late husband would receive appropriate credit in any revival.

However, subsequent negotiations unraveled, leading to the abandonment of the original reboot concept. This resulted in the creation of The Pitt, which, according to Sherri Crichton’s lawsuit, still bears enough resemblance to warrant credit for Michael Crichton.

Warner Bros. Pushes Back: Motion to Dismiss the Lawsuit

Warner Bros. Defends Its Position

George Clooney as Doug Ross smiling in ER

In response to the lawsuit, Warner Bros. has firmly maintained that the assertions made by Sherri Crichton lack merit:

The lawsuit filed by the Crichton Estate is baseless, as ‘The Pitt’ is a new and original show. Any suggestion otherwise is false, and Warner Bros. Television intends to vigorously defend against these meritless claims.

In early November, Warner Bros. took further action by filing a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. The studio argues that the legal action is excessive, with claims about The Pitt being a copycat show lacking substantiation. According to their filing:

“The Pitt is a completely different show from ER. Plaintiff cannot use Mr. Crichton’s ER contract as a speech-stifling weapon to prevent Defendants from ever making a show about emergency medicine.”

The studio asserts that the only commonality shared with ER lies in the medical drama genre, which cannot be exclusively claimed by the Crichton estate:

“The Pitt is not a ‘derivative work’ of ER, and it would be absurd to interpret the ER Agreement as prohibiting WBTV from ever again making a medical drama about emergency medicine.”

Interestingly, Warner Bros. referenced the career of George Clooney — a former star of ER who also acted in an earlier medical series titled E/R — to bolster its argument against the lawsuit’s validity.

In the wake of Warner Bros. filing its motion, Sherri Crichton responded publicly, asserting the following through her representative:

“The defendants’ motion is a transparent attempt to dodge discovery and prevent the true facts from coming out. That the defendants filed their meritless motion on the anniversary of Michael Crichton’s death is emblematic of the studio’s callousness and utter disregard for Crichton’s legacy.”

As it stands, confusion lingers over the direction of the lawsuit, with no clear indication of whether a judge will support Warner Bros.’ dismissal request.

Origins: The Pitt’s Initial Concept

Evolution of The Pitt

The Pitt originally emerged from discussions of a possible ER revival or spinoff, with Wyle, Wells, and R. Scott Gemmill exploring the idea influenced by positive feedback from first responders who cited the show as inspirational in their career choices. In 2020, Wyle approached Wells with a vision that focused more narrowly on character-driven narratives rather than the expansive storytelling typical of ensemble medical dramas.

As Wyle explained in an earlier interview, the project faltered during discussions regarding the rights to ER, stating, “We came up with a concept, and it really never got out of the starting gate.”Following unsuccessful negotiations with the Crichton estate, the team pivoted and revamped their approach, producing a new show distinct from any connection to ER.

Distinct Identity: How The Pitt Differs from ER

The Pitt: More Than Just a Medical Drama

Despite the arguments presented by Sherri Crichton, when examining the final product of The Pitt, the assertion that it is merely a derivative rehash of ER appears unfounded. Both series can be categorized as medical dramas, featuring Noah Wyle, yet the shows diverge significantly in their storytelling approach. The Pitt has carved out an independent identity within the genre, presenting a unique concept that sets it apart from its predecessor.

Notably, The Pitt employs a distinctive narrative format that enhances viewer engagement, akin to the real-time structure of 24. Each episode encapsulates a single hour within one ER shift, offering audiences an immersive experience that showcases the urgency of medical emergencies. Additionally, as a streaming series, it has the flexibility to depict grittier scenarios and utilize more explicit language, factors that amplify its realism. Whether this differentiation will be sufficient for the courts remains to be seen.

New episodes of The Pitt are set to air Thursdays at 9 PM on Max.

Source: Deadline

Source & Images