Disclaimer Season 1 Episodes 3 & 4 Recap: Catherine’s Involvement in Jonathan’s Death Explained

On October 18, 2024, Apple TV+ premiered episodes 3 and 4 of the highly anticipated first season of Disclaimer, crafted by the talented Alfonso Cuarón. This 7-episode series intricately explores profound themes such as love, guilt, betrayal, sexuality, grief, and vengeance.

By the conclusion of episode 4, it’s revealed that Catherine played a significant role in Jonathan’s demise. Despite witnessing his struggle in deep waters, she opted not to alert the nearby lifeguards. Moreover, she misled the police by claiming to have never met Jonathan.

In addition to this shocking disclosure, the latest episodes delve into Robert’s mental state, Catherine’s husband. Flashbacks effectively illustrate Stephen’s suffering after the tragic losses of Jonathan and Nancy.

Unraveling the Ending of Disclaimer season 1, episodes 3 & 4: Catherine’s Motives

Continuing the premiere’s non-linear storytelling, episodes 3 and 4 feature extensive flashbacks that depict the past relationship between young Catherine and Jonathan in Italy.

Catherine first approached Jonathan while he photographed her, leading to a night of drinks and an intense connection. During their flirtatious exchange, Catherine enticed Jonathan to share his sexual fantasies before inviting him to her room.

While their son Nicholas was sound asleep, Catherine and Jonathan embarked on a passionate encounter, allowing her to fulfill desires that had been unmet in her marriage.

Though Catherine viewed this fling as a temporary escape, Jonathan’s feelings for her deepened, complicating her plans. Alarmed by Jonathan’s desire to follow her to London, Catherine’s anxiety grew, particularly considering her social status. The tension escalated when young Nicholas inadvertently drifted into the sea on his small boat.

In a moment of panic, Catherine jumped into the water, but as Jonathan selflessly rescued Nicholas, he found himself in grave danger. While lifeguards attended to Nicholas, Jonathan struggled in the depths, unnoticed and helpless.

Despite knowing Jonathan was drowning, Catherine chose to disregard his plight, believing his death would keep her affair a secret. This tragic choice sealed her fate.

What Actions Does Robert Take in Episodes 3 & 4?

Following the dramatic premiere, Robert is shown in episode 3 grappling with his emotions after confronting Catherine about the incriminating photos linked to Stephen. He spirals into a drunken rage, driving wildly as Catherine attempts to reach him.

Throughout episodes 3 and 4, Robert reflects on his past decisions, feeling remorseful for prioritizing Catherine over his family. His jealousy intensifies as he reads about their intimate rendezvous, depicted in the book The Perfect Stranger.

Unleashing his frustration, he takes matters into his own hands—first by bringing Nicholas back home against Catherine’s wishes, and then ruthlessly packing her belongings to force her out.

By the end of episode 4, Robert takes the drastic step of expelling Catherine from their home, determined to strengthen his bond with Nicholas—and suspecting that Nicholas may have been aware of his mother’s ongoing affair.

What is Stephen’s Involvement in the Story?

The latest episodes of Disclaimer shed light on Stephen Brigstocke’s struggles after enduring the loss of both Jonathan and Nancy. Previously, viewers learned how he discovered Nancy’s unfinished manuscript, The Perfect Stranger, leading to its publication. In these new episodes, he is shown with plans to pen another book.

Episode 4 reveals that this new narrative revolves around a teenage boy. Stephen aims to create a fictional Facebook profile for this character, possibly attempting to connect with Nicholas. Audiences await the upcoming episodes to see how this subplot unfolds.

The next installment of the series is slated for release on October 25, 2024, exclusively on Apple TV+.

Source