Warning! Spoilers ahead for Better Man. The biographical film Better Man, highlighting the life of Robin Williams, introduces a notable conflict between the beloved comedian and Oasis frontman Liam Gallagher. This intriguing dynamic raises questions about its authenticity, especially as the movie features Williams depicted as a CGI monkey. While Better Man has garnered outstanding critical acclaim, its disappointing box office results beg the question: why is this quality film struggling to attract viewers? The narrative compellingly explores Williams’ complex relationships, but did he truly challenge Gallagher to a fight?
Analyzing the Contentions: Did Williams Truly Challenge Gallagher?
Better Man portrays a vast spectrum of talent throughout Williams’ iconic career, showcasing an impressive cast. A significant plot thread revolves around Williams’ relationship with Nicole Appleton, which is intricately tied to his rivalry with Gallagher. Notably, a climactic scene depicts an altercation between Williams and Gallagher, reflecting the deep-seated tensions that characterized their relationship over the years. Gallagher’s role in the film appears tailored to antagonize Williams, with the fight triggered by a long history of unresolved friction.
The 2000 Awards Show Challenge
After a seemingly amicable encounter during the 1995 Glastonbury Festival, where Williams and Gallagher embraced, the mood shifted dramatically. Gallagher’s dismissive remark referring to Williams as “the fat dancer from Take That”(source: Virgin Radio UK) underscores that their camaraderie was superficial at best. Their relationship deteriorated further during the 2000 Brit Awards, where Williams, upon winning the award for British Single, seized the moment to invite Gallagher into the boxing ring.
In a cheeky tone, Williams proclaimed, “Would anybody like to see me fight Liam? Liam, a hundred grand of your money and a hundred grand of my money. We’ll get in a ring, and we’ll have a fight, and you can all watch it on TV.”
The ambiguity of whether Williams was serious remains up for debate; however, his confident delivery and the audience’s enthusiastic reaction suggest underlying tension amidst the humor. He exited the stage with a casual shrug, amplifying the drama.
Exploring the Evolution of Their Feud
Steps Toward Reconciliation
The hostilities continued, as witnessed at the Q Awards, where Gallagher mirrored Williams by dedicating his win to him during his acceptance speech—evidently echoing the longstanding rivalry. Over the years, their feud evolved into a highly publicized saga within the music scene, featuring verbal jabs and competitive live gigs, particularly the 2013 Manchester event. Williams later revealed that part of his move to Los Angeles was triggered by the antagonism from the Gallagher brothers.
Recently, however, there have been signs of thawing relations. In the summer, Williams extended congratulations to Oasis following their announcement of a 2025 tour, marking a notable goodwill gesture.
In a 2020 Apple Music interview, Williams made candid remarks regarding his past experiences with the Gallagher brothers, labeling them as “f***ing bullies”(source: Yahoo News UK). Although Gallagher has contested this characterization, their tumultuous relationship appears to be on a path towards reconciliation. Williams expressed hope that Gallagher would appreciate the film’s portrayal, indicating a desire to mend fences: “I don’t want him to be upset. I hope he likes it”(source: NME).
In conclusion, Better Man not only captivates with its emotional storytelling but also provides insight into the tumultuous relationship between Robbie Williams and Liam Gallagher, leaving audiences questioning the line between rivalry and camaraderie in the music industry.
Sources:
Virgin Radio UK,
Yahoo News UK,
NME
Leave a Reply