Dexter’s Actions Amplify One of Miami Metro’s Longest-Standing Complaints After 19 Years

WARNING! This article contains significant SPOILERS for Dexter: Original Sin season 1, episode 7! The shocking revelation regarding the killer’s identity in Dexter: Original Sin—a key member of Miami Metro Homicide—intensifies longstanding criticism of the department. Although the prequel series is set 15 years prior to the original, the Miami Metro depicted here mirrors its predecessor in various aspects, from the cultural environment and staff dynamics to a striking level of incompetence. Indeed, it seems that Miami Metro was hiring individuals with Dark Passengers long before the infamous Dexter Morgan appeared on the scene.

As season 1 of Original Sin unfolds, Miami Metro’s investigation into the kidnapping and murder of young Jimmy Powell, the son of a prominent judge, serves as the central plot. Following the tragic death of Powell, Captain Aaron Spencer’s son, Nicky, is subsequently kidnapped, with a severed finger being sent as a disturbing message to the precinct. The impending conclusion of season 1 culminated in episode 7 with the shocking reveal that the masked perpetrator is, astonishingly, Captain Aaron Spencer himself. This twist, long speculated by fans, further deteriorates Miami Metro’s already tarnished reputation.

Captain Aaron Spencer’s Role as a Killer Amplifies Criticism of Miami Metro’s Inefficiency

Miami Metro’s Track Record of Employing Killers

Over the span of the original Dexter series, a frequent point of contention among fans has been the inefficacy of Miami Metro. This criticism is underscored by the discouraging 18% homicide clearance rate presented in Original Sin, a trend that continues into Dexter’s timeline. While this statistic is already troubling, the continued employment of known killers like Aaron Spencer and Dexter himself only exacerbates their failure to effectively solve cases.

While Dexter’s ability to evade capture was somewhat facilitated by the guidelines laid out by his father, Harry, the ultimate irony is that Miami Metro’s own captain is the antagonist they are desperately trying to apprehend. This not only raises serious doubts about the department’s competency but also highlights numerous instances where Dexter, despite obvious mistakes, should have been caught by his supposed colleagues. The apparent oversight by Sergeant James Doakes in the original series now feels even more improbable in light of the Spencer revelation in Original Sin.

Spencer’s Twisted Revelation Confirms a Stark Truth About Miami Metro

Urgent Need for Enhanced Screening Processes at Miami Metro

Captain Aaron Spencer (Patrick Dempsey) in Dexter: Original Sin season 1, episode 7

The revelation surrounding Aaron Spencer, as well as Dexter Morgan’s own role within Dexter: Original Sin, emphasizes the urgent necessity for a more rigorous hiring process at Miami Metro. Beyond Aaron Spencer’s dual identity as a child kidnapper and killer, Dexter is revealed to be the notorious Bay Harbor Butcher. Additionally, other characters, such as Harry Morgan, who facilitates vigilante justice, and Stan Liddy, a corrupt narcotics officer, suggest a troubling trend of criminality among the ranks of law enforcement. This history of deception makes it increasingly difficult to trust anyone within the department.

New episodes of Dexter: Original Sin season 1 premiere every Friday on Paramount+ with Showtime.

Source & Images