
Overview
- Showrunner reveals reasons behind Dr. Evelyn Vogel’s absence in the first season of *Dexter: Original Sin*.
- Potential for Dr. Vogel to be retconned or featured in future seasons of the *Dexter* prequel.
- Current storyline suggests Dr. Vogel may not be included in Dexter’s foundational narrative due to established lore.
*Dexter: Original Sin* concluded its debut season last month with thrilling developments, leaving fans eagerly anticipating a possible renewal by Paramount+ with Showtime. This new installment delved into Dexter Morgan’s early life, shedding light on the traumatic circumstances surrounding his mother, Laura Moser’s death, and the origins of his infamous killing spree. Notably absent from this narrative was Dr. Evelyn Vogel, the psychiatrist who played a crucial role in shaping Harry Morgan’s code—a key element in Dexter’s psychology. Recently, *Original Sin*’s showrunner, Clyde Phillips, shared insights on this creative decision.
For context, Dr. Evelyn Vogel, portrayed by Charlotte Rampling in the original *Dexter* series, met a tragic fate at the hands of her own son, Oliver Saxon, known as The Brain Surgeon. Vogel’s prior collaboration with Dexter’s adoptive father, Harry Morgan, to refine Dexter’s impulses adds layers to her character that could enrich the storyline. Despite this, the first season of *Original Sin* did not revisit her narrative arc.
Clyde Phillips Discusses Dr. Evelyn Vogel’s Omission

Key Details about *Dexter: Original Sin* Season 1 |
|
---|---|
Cast |
Patrick Gibson, Christian Slater, Molly Brown, James Martinez, Christina Milian, Alex Shimizu, Reno Wilson, Patrick Dempsey, Joe Pantoliano, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Roby Attal, and Michael C. Hall’s voice. |
Created by |
Clyde Phillips |
Directed by |
Michael Lehmann |
In an interview with ComicBook.com, Phillips candidly explained the rationale behind the lack of representation for Dr. Vogel in *Original Sin*.He emphasized that during the writing process, the focus was primarily on constructing a compelling story with a clear direction. Phillips remarked:
“It actually never came up. When we sit in the writing room, particularly when you’re doing a thriller, you need to know what the ending is. You put that on the wall and put your nose against it and you walk backward. Let’s say you’re in a hotel hallway, and you walk backward and each room you’re passing is an episode until you get over here. Then we also have something which we call NPO, no particular order, scenes we want to see.”
While it is possible that discussions involving Dr. Vogel surfaced during the brainstorming sessions, they ultimately did not align with the narrative’s needs. Phillips’ comments may also suggest a lukewarm sentiment toward the character, considering he was not involved in her introduction during the final season of the original series.
Future Possibilities for Dr. Vogel in *Original Sin*

An array of theories abound regarding the future of Dr. Evelyn Vogel within the *Dexter* universe. Some fan opinions argue that her character diluted the original significance of Harry Morgan’s code, which was meant to be a confidential father-son pact. As a result, it seems likely that *Original Sin* will avoid integrating her character into Dexter’s foundational mythos. However, potential future narrative arcs could include flashbacks or references to Vogel as the show explores the depths of Dexter’s past.
If *Original Sin* receives a green light for more seasons, there could be opportunities to revisit the 1970s or 1990s timelines, capturing interactions between Vogel and Harry Morgan, thereby enriching the narrative tapestry without compromising established lore. Phillips has illustrated a clear understanding of Dexter and Harry’s relationship dynamic, making it evident that introducing Vogel might complicate rather than enhance the storyline.
In conclusion, while *Dexter’s* early years remain ripe for exploration, current creative directions appear to prioritize more pressing narrative objectives over reintroducing Dr. Evelyn Vogel. As the landscape unfolds, fans will eagerly watch to see if Paramount+ decides to continue Dexter’s enthralling saga.
Leave a Reply ▼