Dexter: New Blood’s Shocking Twist Prepares for the Return of Its Most Anticipated Missing Original Character

WARNING! This article reveals key plot details from Dexter: Original Sin season 1, episode 7.

The climax of this episode unveils the unexpected identity of Nicky Spencer’s kidnapper and sets the stage for the anticipated introduction of Captain Thomas Matthews. Throughout Dexter: Original Sin, viewers have grappled with the sinister mystery of a kidnapper targeting the children of Miami’s influential figures. This arc intensified after the abduction and murder of Jimmy Powell, the son of a prominent judge, leading to the kidnapping of Aaron Spencer’s son, Nicky. Captain Spencer, seeking to deflect blame, attributes these heinous acts to cartel involvement.

Who is the Kidnapper in Dexter: Original Sin?

Episode 7 confirms a startling theory: Captain Aaron Spencer himself is behind these chilling crimes. After eliminating Jimmy Powell, Spencer turned on his ex-wife and then went on to sever his own son’s finger for reasons that remain unclear. Dexter’s investigative instincts kick in when he discovers Spencer’s blood was found on Nicky’s severed digit, leading him to connect the dots.

Setting the Stage for Matthews’ Replacement

With this revelation about Spencer’s guilt, it seems likely he will meet his end at Dexter’s hands by the season finale. Dexter has already made significant observations: the injury on Nicky’s finger directly ties back to Spencer, and Spencer’s presence at Dexter’s workspace earlier in the day raises further suspicions. The evidence is mounting, and soon it will become imperative for Dexter to present concrete proof of Spencer’s guilt, while also grappling with the legacy of his late father.

If Dexter does indeed eliminate Spencer, Miami Metro Homicide will be left with a crucial vacancy at the captaincy. While it might seem fitting for Harry Morgan to ascend to this role, the narrative context suggests otherwise; Harry never officially held the rank of captain in his time on the force. Bobby Watt, also a detective, complicates the hierarchy, as the identity of the season’s lieutenant remains up in the air.

Matthews’ Role in the Series: Introduction Needed Before Finale

Dexter: Original Sin’s timeline must navigate the delicate balance of Captain Spencer’s possible demise, the introduction of Thomas Matthews, and the impending death of Harry Morgan. If Spencer is dispatched in the season finale, Matthews’ introduction could be relegated to an end-credits scene. However, the original series made it clear that Matthews and Harry were longstanding associates, indicating his arrival needs to precede Harry’s death for narrative fidelity.

The Significance of Matthews

In the original series, Matthews is the sole character privy to the truth behind Harry’s tragic end and was entrusted with the protection of both Dexter and Debra following Harry’s demise. To align with established lore, the series could kill Spencer before the season ends, allowing more screen time to explore Matthews’ character development and his relationship with Harry.

Will Miami Metro Uncover Spencer’s Dark Secrets?

Now that the truth about Aaron Spencer being the psychopath is confirmed, it raises the question: will Miami Metro ever learn his secrets? Historically, the department has remained oblivious to Dexter’s clandestine actions, so it’s plausible they remain unaware of Spencer’s crimes. The absence of any mention of a killer within the ranks of former captains also suggests that this grave detail could be conveniently overlooked.

It’s conceivable that Dexter could eliminate Spencer while diverting suspicion onto the cartel, thus preserving his own hidden agenda.

Catch new episodes of Dexter: Original Sin season 1 airing every Friday on Paramount+ with Showtime.

Source & Images