Denis Villeneuve Criticizes Oscars For Disqualifying Hans Zimmer’s Dune 2 Score

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences mandates that for a film’s score to qualify for the Oscars, it must include a minimum of 80% original compositions. Unfortunately, Hans Zimmer’s score for Dune: Part Two, which prominently incorporates elements from the first film, did not meet this requirement. Zimmer had previously achieved Oscar glory in 2022 for his work on Dune: Part One.

In light of this, director Denis Villeneuve voiced his concerns regarding the Academy’s ruling during a recent screening of Dune: Part Two, as reported by Slash Film. He acknowledged that although the sequel’s music borrows heavily from its predecessor, it presents original arrangements and themes. Villeneuve expressed his admiration for Zimmer’s work, stating:

“I am absolutely against the decision of the Academy to exclude Hans, frankly, because I feel like his score is one of the best scores of the year. I don’t use the word genius often, but Hans is one.”

Implications for the Dune Franchise and Awards Season

The Academy’s Rules: Designing Originality at What Cost?

The Academy’s regulations are intended to ensure that the music in sequels remains distinct from that of their predecessors, thereby prioritizing originality. While Dune: Part Two introduces various new musical elements, its incorporation of thematic motifs and instrumentation from the first film reflects Villeneuve’s cohesive vision for the Dune saga. This consistency, however, ultimately led to the score’s disqualification.

Directors and composers often encounter hurdles during awards season, and Villeneuve’s disappointment highlights the unique challenges sequels face. Despite Zimmer’s score significantly enhancing the film’s overall impact, the Academy’s stance underscores its preference for original compositions over thematic continuity. Notably, even with an existing Oscar win, the complexities of franchise recognition within the Academy’s framework remain evident.

This awards season has presented additional challenges for Dune: Part Two. The film’s release was postponed due to the 2023 Writers Guild of America strike, shifting its premiere from November 2023 to March 2024. This delay could potentially hinder its visibility and impact its chances during the 2025 Oscars.

Insights on Villeneuve’s Critique of the Oscars

Hans Zimmer’s Absence at the 2025 Oscars

Paul and Chani embrace in Dune: Part Two

While the Academy’s decision aligns with its regulations, Villeneuve’s frustration surrounding Zimmer’s exclusion is understandable. The composer’s music serves as a crucial element in the Dune franchise, weaving together the narratives of both Dune: Part One and Dune: Part Two. This situation raises broader questions about the suitability of the Academy’s rules concerning sequels and serialized storytelling, especially at a time when cinematic franchises dominate the industry. Notably, other adaptations like Wicked have successfully navigated the eligibility criteria for their respective scores.

For further insights, refer to the article from Slash Film.

Source & Images