DC, Please Avoid the Repeated Mistakes of Batman & Robin That Have Persisted for Years

Warning: Spoilers for Batman and Robin #17 DC is once again treading down the familiar path of conflict between Batman and Robin, raising concerns about the creative direction of one of its most iconic partnerships. Their relationship has historically been a cornerstone of the DC Universe, yet recent story arcs suggest that the characters may be retracing old steps, risking the possibility of another uninspired repetition of prior conflicts.

In Batman and Robin #17, penned by Phillip Kennedy Johnson and illustrated by Javier Fernández and Carmine Di Giandomenico, Bruce and Damian find themselves embroiled in a heated debate about the purpose of Batman’s vigilantism. Damian’s rhetoric raises the troubling question: Is this life truly worth the sacrifices it demands?

Comic book panel: Damian Questions How Useful Batman Is To Gotham City

This confrontation marks a concerning trend, as it echoes previous narratives where Bruce and Damian clashed, such as during the aftermath of Alfred’s death, leading to a prolonged estrangement. Notably, in 2022’s Batman vs. Robin by Mark Waid, father and son faced each other in conflict, a pattern that has become too predictable.

The Repeated Narrative of Batman and Robin’s Discord

Overview of Batman and Robin #17

Comic book panels: Damian Makes An Awful Argument About Batman

Throughout their history, Bruce and Damian have encountered numerous bumps in their relationship. The aftermath of Alfred’s demise saw tensions rise to the point where Damian distanced himself from the Bat-Family, illustrating the volatility of their dynamic. These rising tensions were further explored in alternate realities, such as in DC’s Injustice series.

Part of the discord may stem from Damian’s maturation. As he evolves and seeks his own identity, this development could naturally lead to conflicts with Bruce. However, the repetition of this specific narrative feels exhausting, particularly when both characters can create richer stories when they are united.

Comic runs like Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason’s New 52 adaptation began with a rocky relationship between the duo, ultimately transforming it into a heartfelt exploration of their bond. Similarly, Joshua Williamson’s prior installment in the Dawn of DC initiative presented a considerable shift toward cooperation and mutual understanding, offering audiences a refreshing take on their father-son dynamic.

The Issue with Reverting Back to Conflict

The Evolution of Damian Wayne

Comic book art: 2020s Robin Damian Wayne in front of Batman Rebirth era Damian.

Reintroducing the quarrel between Bruce and Damian ultimately feels like a misstep, particularly when Bruce has recently fostered positive relationships within the Bat-Family. It seems the narrative aims to create conflict where none is genuinely warranted, squandering the momentum gained from previous storylines.

While disagreements are a natural and healthy part of any relationship, and occasional friction can enhance their story, a regression to constant bickering feels detrimental, especially for longtime fans who appreciate their growth. Instead of exploring new dimensions of their relationship, it appears the narrative is hitting reset, creating an artificial conflict lacking justification.

DC’s repetitive approach to Batman and Robin’s tumultuous dynamic is disappointing, especially following Williamson’s successful efforts to unite the duo. With the upcoming cinematic debut of Damian Wayne in DC’s The Brave and the Bold, it is crucial for DC to remember their foundations as a tragic yet powerful duo. This is an opportunity to push past these conflicts and allow Bruce and Damian to evolve their relationship into something truly significant.

Batman and Robin #17 is currently available from DC Comics.

Source & Images