David Fincher’s Squid Game Spinoff Must Happen, Netflix Is Correct

Summary

David Fincher’s upcoming Squid Game spin-off has the potential to extend the universe beyond Season 3.
With Fincher’s distinctive storytelling style, the series could evolve into a critical favorite.
Despite concerns about creative dilution, a spin-off helmed by Fincher could bolster Netflix’s international market presence.

The anticipated English-language spin-off of Squid Game, being directed by David Fincher, may initially seem superfluous. However, as Netflix prepares to conclude the original South Korean sensation with its third and final season in June, this project might fill a vital niche.

Squid Game’s unprecedented success not only highlights the achievements of its creator, Hwang Dong-hyuk, and Netflix but also signals a significant breakthrough for non-English media globally. Such a backdrop makes the idea of a remake or spin-off subject to skepticism, especially when seasoned filmmakers like Fincher are associated with it. Critics might argue that Fincher’s artistry is better reserved for original works rather than conventional remakes.

Could Squid Game Expand Beyond Season 3?

David Fincher’s Spin-Off Could Extend The Universe

As reported by Deadline in October 2024, an English-language series based on Squid Game is under development at Netflix, with David Fincher at the helm. Importantly, this series is not intended as a straightforward remake but rather a spin-off that seeks to enrich the Squid Game universe by incorporating elements and narratives familiar from the original Korean installment. Updates on this endeavor have yet to surface.

David Fincher Eyeing New ‘Squid Game’ Series As Next Project At Netflix – The Dish https://t.co/AFGSRkjP80

— Deadline (@DEADLINE) October 28, 2024

This proposed spin-off would signify Netflix’s inaugural scripted effort to broaden the reach of the beloved South Korean series. Previously, the platform has ventured into unscripted territory with the contentious reality show Squid Game: The Challenge, which reimagined the disturbing competitions from the original show. In a December 2024 interview with The Wrap, creator Hwang Dong-hyuk acknowledged the spin-off and commented on its potential significance.

I know Netflix has a plan. They are not going to throw this idea away… Maybe I’ll be in one of those projects as an advisor or co-creator. Who knows? But Season 3 is not going to be the end of the Squid Game universe.

David Fincher’s Squid Game Spin-Off Might Just Work

Fans Wanted Mindhunter Instead Of A Remake

The announcement of the spin-off was met with a mixed reception online. Many fans expressed concerns that an English-language version might stray from the essence of the original, diminishing its impact. Others wished that instead of pioneering a spin-off, Netflix would opt to revive Fincher’s acclaimed series Mindhunter, which was sadly canceled before its third season was realized.

Mingle Game Song “Round and Round” Lyric Video | Squid Game: Season 2 | Netflix (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SbAKYgfYET8)

Despite the controversial nature of the spin-off, it may serve as a beneficial move for all involved. While Season 2 of Squid Game garnered positive reviews, it struggled to capture the groundbreaking essence of the inaugural season. As anticipation builds for Season 3, which bears the burden of either enhancing or degrading the show’s legacy, the global popularity of the Squid Game franchise ensures Netflix will likely continue its expansion efforts. Having a director of Fincher’s caliber onboard presents a substantial opportunity for the franchise.

Can David Fincher Elevate Squid Game?

His 1997 Film The Game Has Similar Themes

With Fincher’s innovative storytelling style, viewers can expect this potential spin-off to diverge remarkably from the original Korean series. While the initial Squid Game was acclaimed for its shock and spectacle, Fincher could infuse character-driven storytelling. This evolution could elevate the franchise beyond just a sensational hit into a revered work, possibly adding to its six Primetime Emmys.

The Game: What Happened to David Fincher’s Most Underrated Movie? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvrn8WE4Lmw)

Who wouldn’t be intrigued by a psychologically charged take on Squid Game from Fincher? Notably, his film The Game (1997), featuring Michael Douglas, explores similar high-stakes scenarios in a tense atmosphere, where participants unknowingly engage in life-altering situations.

Squid Game Can Bring Back The Old Fincher

His Netflix Legacy Hints At A Strong Project

Far from losing his touch, David Fincher has consistently delivered critically-acclaimed work, including the Oscar-winning Mank and the intense thriller The Killer. His last significant mainstream success, however, dates back to Gone Girl (2014) and The Social Network (2010).A project of Squid Game‘s scale could be pivotal for Fincher to regain his prominence in the cinematic landscape.

David Fincher on Directing The Killer | Behind the Scenes | Netflix (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PyI5_ghkcoI)

Fincher’s past collaborations with Netflix have proven fruitful; his involvement often leads to highly praised projects. He was instrumental in establishing Netflix’s stronghold in original content with House of Cards. Despite the short run of Mindhunter, it remains a standout offering on the service, and he also contributed as an executive producer for Love, Death + Robots.

Can Fincher’s Squid Game Avoid the Remake Trap?

If It Fails, Both Netflix And The Director Could Suffer

Nevertheless, there are considerable concerns surrounding this new endeavor. Fincher’s attempts to adapt international films into English have had mixed results. For example, his version of The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo was criticized for lacking the authenticity and spirit of the original Swedish film, which some perceive as more faithful to the source material. Consequently, the upcoming Squid Game spin-off risks losing its unique cultural essence in translation.

Additionally, Hwang Dong-hyuk originally envisioned Squid Game as a one-season series. The expansion into subsequent seasons was challenging, even for its creator. Therefore, the proposed spin-off carries the weight of high expectations and the risk of narrative dilution, which could jeopardize not only Netflix’s investment but also Fincher’s reputation—potentially tarnishing the legacy of Squid Game itself.

Source & Images