Cruel Intentions Remake Addresses Key Issues from the 1999 Film

As audiences tune in to the new series on Prime Video, a question arises: do we really need another take on Cruel Intentions? My initial feelings were mixed, considering the legacy of the 1999 cult classic starring Sarah Michelle Gellar, Ryan Phillippe, and Reese Witherspoon. However, after watching the first season, I can pinpoint at least one notable merit of the series.

The central theme of this series revolves around redressing a significant flaw of the original film. In the 1999 version, Kathryn Merteuil serves as a quintessential villain—her demise celebrated by all. But does this characterization really do justice? The show prompts us to reevaluate: was Kathryn a true villain, or merely a woman betrayed? This new adaptation introduces Caroline Merteuil, played by Sarah Catherine Hook, providing a nuanced view that garners sympathy for a traditionally maligned character.

Kathryn Merteuil: A Character Beyond Villainy

Ryan Phillippe, Sarah Michelle Gellar, and Reese Witherspoon in 'Cruel Intentions'

Cruel Intentions narrates the story of step-siblings Kathryn Merteuil and Sebastian Valmont, affluent youths who engage in a morally dubious bet surrounding their principal’s daughter, Annette Hargrove. The film culminates in tragedy when Sebastian dies, yet his story arc—involving love and redemption—overshadows the darker elements of his character, which include emotional manipulation and morally ambiguous choices.

Kathryn’s character receives quite the blow during the film’s climax, witnessing her public exposure as the real orchestrator behind the manipulations, while Sebastian’s transgressions go largely unpunished. Initially interpreted as poetic justice, today we recognize that Kathryn’s actions, while egregious, stem from a greater societal injustice. Gender bias plays a deep role in shaping her behaviors—where men like Sebastian are lauded for their sexual exploits, women are vilified and shamed for similar behaviors.

Intelligent and unapologetically sexually liberated, Kathryn resents the double standards imposed upon her. Her desperate measures to fit into society’s mold of female purity are ironically what lead her to rebellion. Moments of vulnerability, such as her relationship with Court Reynolds, reveal the harsh reality of her rejection; she finds herself constantly abandoned for being too assertive and sexually confident.

In a standout monologue, Kathryn guiltily expresses her discontent with societal obligations, embodying the struggle that many women face in a patriarchal society that diminishes their worth based on conformity to restrictive norms.

How the New Series Humanizes Kathryn Merteuil

A young man leans into a woman and holds her chin — (Prime Video)

The series “Cruel Intentions,”now set in a Greek college context, may falter in some areas but deserves accolades for providing a richer backstory for Caroline Merteuil. She embodies many of Kathryn’s qualities—the allure of sexual tension, dominant social status, and a façade of being the quintessential supportive friend.

However, this adaptation dives deeper into the origin of her cruelty. Caroline’s propensity for manipulation and impulsive behaviors is contextualized by her struggles with substance use and the need for control born out of neglectful parenting. This portrayal creates a complex character whose malicious actions are rooted in a quest for power in a dysfunctional family dynamic.

Claudia Merteuil, played by Claire Forlani, epitomizes the toxic influence of Caroline’s mother, who values power over affection. The tension between Caroline and her mother—highlighted in several episodes—intensifies as Claudia showers her stepson Lucien with attention while often neglecting Caroline’s achievements.

Two women stand beside each other, looking at a third person — (Prime Video)

While Caroline demonstrates remarkable capabilities that position her as an heir to her family’s legacy, Lucien appears to succeed through charm and connections alone. This dynamic underscores the societal pressure on women to constantly validate their worth while granting men a level of freedom and leniency.

The series artfully illustrates Caroline’s internal struggle through compelling performances. Cracks in her persona expose a deep-seated need for validation, revealing her loneliness and the façade she upholds. Her bond with Lucien, fraught with complications, mirrors her desire for valid connections, further complicating her emotional landscape.

Looking ahead, it remains uncertain how Caroline’s journey will unfold across multiple seasons. The expansion from a tight 97-minute film narrative offers potential for deeper exploration of her character’s challenges and growth. As the show progresses, viewers may find themselves grappling with complex feelings of pity and empathy toward Caroline, ultimately crafting a bittersweet narrative that resonates with the nuances of human experience.

Learn More & Images