Consumers Reject AI-Generated Content as Marketers Embrace AI in Content Creation

Recent research indicates that marketers are investing significantly in AI-generated content, despite evident signs of consumer fatigue. This comes from a comprehensive report by Billion Dollar Boy, as summarized by EMarketer.

Highlights from the Billion Dollar Boy Report on AI Content

Marketers Increasing AI Investments

A substantial 79% of marketers have increased their AI investments in the last year.
Looking ahead, 77% plan to allocate more budget towards AI-driven advertising rather than traditional content creator strategies.
Nearly 75% anticipate that AI will serve as a growth engine for ad spending by 2026, rather than merely a method for cutting costs.
Despite the growth potential, 81% of marketers see AI-based strategies as offering improved cost controls.
The majority, at 73%, believe that AI-generated content outshines that produced solely by humans.

Consumer Resistance to AI-Generated Content

The Dangers of AI Slop text over futuristic digital eye background.

Initially, 60% of consumers expressed enthusiasm for AI-generated content in 2023.
Currently, that number has plummeted to just 26%, as many consumers react negatively to what is termed “AI slop”—uninspired, repetitive content that is often unlabeled.

Shifting Perspectives: The Potential for Improvement

Despite declining excitement surrounding AI-generated content, 38% of consumers still believe that these strategies can enhance quality. Additionally, 41% appreciate the improvements in diversity and representation that AI can bring to the advertising space.

Younger audiences, particularly those aged 25 to 34, demonstrate a greater acceptance of AI-driven marketing, with 40% preferring this form of content.

YouTube has been at the forefront of this trend with its ‘edit with AI’ feature, enabling creators to enhance their productivity. However, a drawback has emerged—a phenomenon dubbed ‘slop fatigue, ’ wherein users encounter an overwhelming amount of low-effort, homogenized content that diminishes authenticity and trust.

Recent analyses highlight troubling examples, such as viewers becoming disengaged while consuming poorly produced AI-generated videos on historical events, which can lead to the unintended absorption of inaccurate information through subliminal messaging.

Conclusion: Finding the Right Balance

The key takeaway for marketers and content creators is clear: AI should be leveraged to complement original work, rather than replacing it as a primary content creation tool. Failing to do so may exacerbate consumer disinterest in this innovative technology.

Source & Images