Complete List of Recast Characters in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU)

Overview of Actor Recasting in the MCU

Several characters, including Fandral and Red Skull, were recast in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) due to actor availability and preference.
Following the untimely passing of William Hurt, Harrison Ford assumed the role of Thaddeus Ross.
Terrence Howard and Edward Norton were also replaced over creative disagreements with Marvel Studios.

The Marvel Cinematic Universe, renowned for its extensive film catalog, has largely maintained consistency with its cast over the years. Even lesser-known characters are often reprised by the original actors to enhance the continuity of the narrative, giving audiences the sense that the MCU is a vibrant, living universe.

However, challenges such as scheduling conflicts, personal decisions, and disputes do arise, leading to notable recasts from minor to significant characters within the franchise.

1. Fandral

Josh Dallas Could Not Return for Thor: The Dark World

Original Actor: Josh Dallas
Replaced By: Zachary Levi

Despite not having prominent roles in the Thor trilogy, Fandral surprised fans with a new face in Thor: The Dark World. Initially portrayed by Josh Dallas in the first film, the character was recast with Zachary Levi for the sequels due to Dallas’s scheduling conflicts arising from his commitments to Once Upon a Time.

Levi’s portrayal continued until Fandral’s demise in Thor: Ragnarok. After his time in the MCU, Levi transitioned to reprise another superhero role as Shazam in the DC Extended Universe.

2. Howard Stark

John Slattery Replaced Gerard Sanders as Howard Stark

Original Actor: Gerard Sanders
Replaced By: John Slattery

In 2011, technology for de-aging was still in its infancy, which led to Dominic Cooper being cast as a younger Howard Stark in Captain America: The First Avenger, instead of attempting to make John Slattery look younger. Interestingly, Sanders was the first actor to portray Howard Stark in Iron Man, appearing only in photographs.

There was no explicit explanation for Slattery’s casting in Iron Man 2, but he subsequently alternated the role with Cooper up to Avengers: Endgame.

3. Red Skull

Hugo Weaving’s Discontent with Red Skull Role

Original Actor: Hugo Weaving
Replaced By: Ross Marquand

While many actors cherish their roles within the MCU, Hugo Weaving, who portrayed Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger, reportedly disliked his character and the overall blockbuster film experience, opting not to reprise his role.

Fans were pleasantly surprised when Red Skull resurfaced in Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame. Though initially expected to be Weaving, the character was instead delivered through CGI, with Ross Marquand skillfully mimicking Weaving’s voice.

4. Thanos

A Different Thanos Before Josh Brolin’s Iconic Role

Original Actor: Damion Poitier
Replaced By: Josh Brolin

It’s nearly inconceivable to imagine any other actor inhabiting the role of Thanos following Josh Brolin’s performance. Debuting in the post-credits of The Avengers, Thanos was initially portrayed by Damion Poitier using practical effects.

Brolin’s subsequent portrayal brought depth and intensity, establishing Thanos as a formidable antagonist throughout the Infinity Saga.

5. Cassie Lang

Kathryn Newton Cast as Young Avengers’ Cassie Lang

Original Actor: Emma Fuhrmann
Replaced By: Kathryn Newton

With the five-year time skip between Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame, Cassie Lang evolved from a young girl to a teenager, who was briefly portrayed by Emma Fuhrmann.

When Cassie reappeared in Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, she was portrayed by Kathryn Newton, as the character was set to take on the superhero mantle of Stinger. Director Peyton Reed sought a recognizable face for future MCU roles in potential properties like Young Avengers.

6. Billy Maximoff

Billy’s Transformation Required a New Actor

Original Actor: Julian Hilliard
Replaced By: Joe Locke

The recasting of Billy Maximoff stems from narrative developments rather than actor unavailability. In WandaVision, Billy underwent a transformation when Wanda’s hex was dismantled, leading to his emergence in a new body, William Kaplan, as he gradually embraced his identity as the superhero Wiccan.

While Julian Hilliard portrayed the younger Billy, Joe Locke stepped into the role of William Kaplan, showcasing both characters through his impressive multifaceted performance.

7. James Rhodes/War Machine

Terrence Howard Exited, Opening the Door for Don Cheadle

Original Actor: Terrence Howard
Replaced By: Don Cheadle

In the inception of the MCU, Colonel James Rhodes made his first appearance, played by Terrence Howard. His character was set to evolve into the armored hero War Machine in future films.

However, after a reported pay dispute with Marvel Studios, Howard departed from the franchise, making way for Don Cheadle to take over the character from Iron Man 2 onwards. Cheadle’s rendition is often viewed as a more fitting representation for Rhodes.

Edward Norton Desired More Creative Influence Over the Hulk

Original Actor: Edward Norton
Replaced By: Mark Ruffalo

The portrayal of Hulk has undergone significant changes throughout the MCU due to various factors, including rights issues and actor recasting. Edward Norton skillfully brought Bruce Banner to life in The Incredible Hulk, displaying a strong commitment to the character.

However, his desire for greater creative control led to disagreements with Marvel Studios, which ultimately resulted in Mark Ruffalo taking over the role from The Avengers onward, where he provided a fresh and dynamic interpretation of the character.

9. Thaddeus Ross

Devastating Loss Welcomes Harrison Ford to the MCU

Original Actor: William Hurt
Replaced By: Harrison Ford

The MCU faced a sombre shift when the beloved William Hurt, who portrayed Thaddeus Ross since The Incredible Hulk, sadly passed away in 2022 after a brave battle with prostate cancer. His portrayal had resonated deeply with audiences, showcasing a nuanced rival to Bruce Banner over multiple projects.

In the aftermath of Hurt’s passing, Harrison Ford stepped into the shoes of Thaddeus Ross, making his debut in Captain America: Brave New World. Ford’s involvement has brought renewed excitement about the character’s journey ahead.

Source & Images