Comparing Review Scores of Monster Hunter Wilds with Other Monster Hunter Games

Comparing Review Scores of Monster Hunter Wilds with Other Monster Hunter Games

Set to be one of the most noteworthy launches of 2025, Monster Hunter Wilds marks a significant return for Capcom, especially for home console gamers. While the franchise has seen a steady stream of content recently, it has been some time since a dedicated console version was released. The last major installment, Monster Hunter Rise, debuted in 2021 exclusively for the Nintendo Switch, leaving fans eager for a multi-platform successor.Monster Hunter Wilds serves as a true successor to the acclaimed Monster Hunter: World from 2018, fulfilling this long-awaited demand.

Initial reviews for Monster Hunter Wilds have been overwhelmingly positive, with reports surfacing just days prior to its release. Currently, the game boasts an impressive 89/100 Top Critic Average on OpenCritic, complemented by a notable 95% Critics Recommend rating. On Metacritic, the PlayStation 5 version achieves a commendable 90/100 Metascore, positioning Monster Hunter Wilds as the highest-rated game of 2025 thus far. It stands slightly ahead of Warhorse Studios’ Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2, showcasing its critical acclaim, although it still falls short of being the pinnacle of the Monster Hunter franchise.

Is Monster Hunter Wilds the Peak of the Series?

Monster Hunter Wilds - Big Meat
Monster Hunter Wilds - Stick
Monster Hunter Wilds - Creature Battle
Monster Hunter Wilds - Hunter and Mount
Monster Hunter Wilds - Beta Revealed

The Evolution of the Monster Hunter Series

As Capcom’s long-standing franchise, the Monster Hunter series has successfully captivated audiences for over two decades. The series consists of 17 titles, not including expansions and remakes, most of which are offshoots of the mainline games. Although it gained traction in Japan, early entries struggled to establish a foothold in Western markets, primarily due to mixed reviews. For instance, the original Monster Hunter (2004) garnered a disappointing 68/100 on Metacritic, while Monster Hunter Freedom 2 managed a slightly better 72/100.

The turning point for the franchise occurred with the release of Monster Hunter 3 in 2009, which achieved a respectable 84/100 rating from Western reviewers. Following this, Monster Hunter 4 was initially unavailable in the West; however, its enhanced edition, Monster Hunter 4: Ultimate, received global acclaim upon its 2015 release, achieving a commendable 86/100. Even spinoffs, such as Monster Hunter Generations, held high ratings, further demonstrating the franchise’s upward trajectory.

Comprehensive Review Scores for Monster Hunter Games

Game Title Release Year Metacritic Rating OpenCritic Rating OpenCritic % of Critics Recommend Notes
Monster Hunter 2004 68/100 N/A N/A
Monster Hunter G 2005 N/A N/A N/A Japan-only release
Monster Hunter Freedom 2005 71/100 N/A N/A Enhanced PSP port
Monster Hunter 2 2006 N/A N/A N/A Famitsu score: 37/40, Japan-only
Monster Hunter Frontier Online 2007 N/A N/A N/A Japan-only MMO, now defunct
Monster Hunter Freedom 2 2007 72/100 N/A N/A Based on Monster Hunter 2
Monster Hunter Freedom Unite 2008 81/100 N/A N/A Expanded edition
Monster Hunter 3 2009 84/100 N/A N/A
Monster Hunter Diary: Poka Poka Airou Village 2010 N/A N/A N/A Japan-only release
Monster Hunter Portable 3rd 2010 N/A N/A N/A Famitsu score: 39/40, Japan-only
Monster Hunter Dynamic Hunting 2011 69/100 N/A N/A Delisted mobile game
Monster Hunter 3: Ultimate 2011 82/100 N/A N/A Upgraded edition
Monster Hunter 4 2013 N/A N/A N/A Famitsu score: 38/40, Japan-only
Monster Hunter Frontier G 2013 N/A N/A N/A Japan-only update
Monster Hunter 4: Ultimate 2014 86/100 86/100 95% Expanded edition
Monster Hunter Explore 2015 N/A N/A N/A Delisted mobile game
Monster Hunter Generations 2015 85/100 85/100 95%
Monster Hunter Stories 2016 79/100 79/100 68%
Monster Hunter Frontier Z 2016 N/A N/A N/A Renamed Frontier Online, Japan-only
Monster Hunter Generations: Ultimate 2017 80/100 78/100 69% Expanded edition
Monster Hunter: World 2018 90/100 90/100 96%
Monster Hunter World: Iceborne 2019 89/100 90/100 96% Expansion pack
Monster Hunter Rise 2021 88/100 88/100 96%
Monster Hunter Stories 2: Wings of Ruin 2021 81/100 81/100 85%
Monster Hunter Rise: Sunbreak 2022 86/100 86/100 93% Expansion pack
Monster Hunter Now 2023 73/100 N/A N/A Mobile game
Monster Hunter Wilds 2025 90/100 89/100 95%

Why Monster Hunter World Still Reigns Supreme

While titles like Monster Hunter 4 and Monster Hunter Generations showcased the franchise’s growing popularity, it was Monster Hunter: World that truly propelled the series into the global spotlight. Released in January 2018 on the PS4 and Xbox One, this game shattered records with its outstanding 90/100 Top Critic Average and a remarkable 96% Critics Recommend score on OpenCritic, alongside a solid Metacritic average of 90/100. Its expansion, Monster Hunter World: Iceborne, trailed closely behind, achieving similar accolades except for a slightly lower Metacritic score of 89/100.

Currently, Monster Hunter: World maintains its status as the most critically acclaimed title in the series, even as Monster Hunter Wilds competes closely in this regard. Although both games share identical Metacritic scores, Wilds falls short by one point on OpenCritic in both Top Critic Average and Critics Recommend categories. In summary, while Monster Hunter Wilds may not yet claim the title of the best entry according to critics, it is undoubtedly poised to be a contender in Game of the Year discussions as 2025 unfolds.

Source & Images

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *