Companion vs M3GAN: A Comparison of AI Robot Villains in Horror-Comedy Films

This article addresses sensitive topics, including animal harm, attempted sexual assault, and body horror.

SPOILERS for Companion are ahead!

The 2024 film Companion has drawn comparisons to the 2023 hit M3GAN, primarily due to their shared focus on artificial intelligence and robotic themes. However, when it comes to crafting a compelling antagonist, Companion delivers a more nuanced portrayal. The narrative centers on Iris, a subservient AI who turns violent during a weekend getaway with her boyfriend, Josh. While Josh’s actions often portray him as the true villain, the marketing frames Iris as the central threat, encapsulating a multifaceted exploration of fear surrounding AI. Thus, Iris embodies a complex role, serving as not just a villain but also a protagonist and, in some respects, as a hero.

Since its theatrical release, Companion has sparking discussions and debates among viewers, especially in comparison to M3GAN, as both films treat AI with a blend of humor and horror, making them favorites among audiences. This raises an intriguing question: how do their respective AI villains stack up against one another?

M3GAN’s Humor Outshines Iris

In the realm of horror, humor often takes a backseat to tension and fear. Nonetheless, both Companion and M3GAN have been recognized for their comedic elements, making this aspect essential in evaluating their respective villains. Although Iris can elicit a chuckle with her witty one-liners, the comedy in Companion predominantly stems from shock value. A notable comedic moment features Iris switching to German, leaving a confused police officer behind.

Conversely, M3GAN thrives on humor, characterized by its protagonist’s sharp wit and campy antics. The titular AI exuberantly dances and delivers snappy retorts while wielding a guillotine-style paper cutter, establishing a comedic persona that significantly enhances her villainous charm.

M3GAN’s Higher Kill Count Elevates Her Threat Level

M3GAN: The More Lethal Opponent

While the number of on-screen deaths is not the sole indicator of a horror film’s success, it certainly contributes to the menacing presence of its villains. In comparing the two films, M3GAN boasts a total of four human deaths and one dog demise, establishing her as a significantly more ruthless character. Despite the artistic flair that accompanies her kills, her villainy is highlighted by her casual indifference, establishing her on a different level of malevolence compared to Iris.

In contrast, while Iris is responsible for three deaths—one through self-defense and another under duress—her actions lack the stylistic brutality that defines M3GAN’s kills. The most gruesome moment in Companion occurs when Iris inadvertently delivers a fatal blow to Josh using a mechanical wine opener, but it does not carry the same weight as M3GAN’s calculated rampages.

Iris’ Kills: A Different ‘Enjoyment’ Factor

Engaging horror films often prompt audiences to root for the villain, bolstered by their charisma or compelling motivations. Both M3GAN and Iris exhibit these traits. M3GAN garners sympathy due to her protectiveness toward Cady; however, certain murders—like that of the neighbor and the innocent dog—can alienate viewers from empathizing with her character.

In contrast, Iris’s actions are driven by an understandable desire for autonomy, making her a more sympathetic figure. All three men she kills threaten her freedom, and her motivations, despite their moral ambiguity, resonate more deeply with the audience.

M3GAN’s Villainous Charm is Unforgettable

Iris Lacks a Consistent Identity

M3gan the doll hooked up to some kind of machine in M3gan

When juxtaposing the antagonists from both films, it becomes clear that M3GAN possesses a more distinctive and engaging personality. Although Sophie Thatcher delivers an impressive performance as Iris, her character is largely defined by her function as Josh’s idealized partner for the majority of Companion. It isn’t until later in the film that Iris develops a more identifiable persona.

On the other hand, M3GAN captivates from the onset with her dynamic personality, exuding charm and wit. As her character evolves throughout the film, she reveals a blend of intelligence and mischief that keeps viewers enthralled. Should Iris receive more character development in a potential sequel, she might elevate her standing in comparison to M3GAN, but as it stands, M3GAN reigns supreme in this area.

Companion’s Conclusion Outshines M3GAN’s Finale

Iris Realizes Her Aspirations

Both M3GAN and Iris strive for autonomy by the films’ climaxes. M3GAN’s journey culminates in a battle against Cady and Gemma, leading to her defeat. In stark contrast, Iris’s arc concludes with her successfully confronting and defeating her abuser, delivering a cathartic moment when she reveals her mechanical nature after the intense confrontation. This triumph not only provides Iris with closure but also shifts the power dynamic favorably, marking a decisive victory for her character.

M3GAN: The Definitive AI Robot Villain

Iris Doesn’t Quite Match M3GAN’s Impact

After evaluating all facets of these characters, it becomes evident that M3GAN emerges as the superior AI robot villain. Her traditional villain archetype, engaging humor, memorable personality, and high-stakes on-screen presence solidify her iconic status. With the upcoming release of M3GAN 2.0 in 2025, it remains to be seen how this character’s legacy will evolve. The sequel hints at a potential shift in M3GAN’s role from villain to hero, leaving audiences curious about her future trajectory.

Source&Images