Clint Eastwood’s Breakout Film: A Theft from a Classic Samurai Epic

The iconic film A Fistful of Dollars is often credited with catapulting Clint Eastwood into stardom, yet it bears a striking resemblance to the earlier samurai film, Yojimbo. Prior to this landmark film, Eastwood had made a name for himself through notable television performances in shows such as Rawhide and had also taken on various supporting roles in cinema. However, his portrayal in A Fistful of Dollars marked his inaugural leading role in a feature film, which ultimately became a defining moment in his career. This film not only introduced audiences around the world to the genre known as the Spaghetti Western but also revitalized it, paving the way for classic films in this style.

Before Eastwood’s breakthrough in 1964, the celebrated director Akira Kurosawa had already achieved immense success with Yojimbo, released in 1961. The storylines of both films revolve around a nameless antihero, and strikingly similar plotlines led to a lawsuit initiated by Toho, the production company behind Yojimbo, against Sergio Leone, the director of A Fistful of Dollars. Despite the similarities, both films stand out as remarkable contributions to cinema, demonstrating how parallel narratives can lead to unique and compelling storytelling.

Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars Share Core Themes

Mirrored Plots and Protagonists in Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars

Both Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars exhibit numerous narrative and conceptual parallels, which were significant enough to prompt a legal challenge. The protagonists in both films are misfits navigating a lawless town—a theme that shines in the storytelling. In Kurosawa’s tale, the wandering ronin known as Kuwabatake Sanjuro uncovers the chaos within a fractured Yakuza clan, while Eastwood’s enigmatic Man With No Name finds himself embroiled in a rivalry between two criminal families. The protagonists manipulate the tensions at play, leveraging trickery to monetize the conflict.

Yet, amidst their cunning, each character displays a flicker of humanity when they assist a captive woman and her family to evade one gang’s grasp, all while feigning loyalty. Captured for this act, their ultimate rescue by a local coffin maker they had befriended underscores a deeper narrative. In the end, the nameless hero does not linger to bask in victory but instead moves on to new adventures, hinting at the cyclical nature of such conflicts. Although the contexts differ—one a Western and the other a samurai epic—both films’ similarities are pronounced enough to draw legal scrutiny.

Yojimbo’s Legal Victory Over A Fistful of Dollars

“I Have Just Had the Chance to See Your Film. It Is a Very Fine Film, But It Is My Film.”

Akira Kurosawa’s ambition has long circled themes of corruption and societal turmoil in post-WWII Japan, with Yojimbo presenting a stark exploration of the evils people commit for wealth and power. Upon its release, the film achieved unprecedented success in Japan, and Akira Kurosawa News reports its lasting international impact, notably on the 1964 Italian Western A Fistful of Dollars. However, Kurosawa was aware that Leone had effectively remade his film without obtaining permission.

The successful legal action resulted in a settlement where Kurosawa and Toho received 15% of A Fistful of Dollars’ profits, which turned out to be a financially beneficial arrangement. Kurosawa conveyed his thoughts in a letter to Leone: “I have just had the chance to see your film. It is a very fine film, but it is my film. Since Japan is a signatory of the Berne Convention on international copyright, you must pay me.” Despite arguing that other influences inspired Leone’s story, he opted for an out-of-court settlement. This settlement allowed Kurosawa to reap substantial financial rewards from his work’s reinterpretation.

Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars Sparked Franchise Growth

The Nameless Ronin and the Man With No Name: A Legacy of Returns

The Man With No Name in A Fistful of Dollars

The massive successes of both Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars catalyzed additional films revolving around their respective leads, proving that a narrative can resonate across different interpretations. The success of Yojimbo birthed a direct sequel in Sanjuro (1962), which chronicles the journey of the now-renowned ronin as he aids a group of samurai in their quest to safeguard their local lord. At the same time, A Fistful of Dollars spurred a series of sequels featuring the iconic Man With No Name, solidifying Eastwood’s rise as a cinematic powerhouse through films like For a Few Dollars More and The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.

The influence of Yojimbo did not stop with Leone’s work; it inspired an array of films across genres, including the spaghetti Western Django, samurai classics like Incident at Blood Pass, and even the fantasy epic The Warrior and the Sorceress, alongside gangster films such as Last Man Standing.

Both characters became cultural icons within their respective genres, leaving a mark that extends well into contemporary cinema. The artistic legacy of Yojimbo shaped the western genre significantly, with references to its themes appearing in works as varied as Star Wars and Saturday Night Live. Meanwhile, the emergence of the Man With No Name heralded a wave of Spaghetti Westerns that breathed new life into the genre. Although their stories are quite similar, the historical resonance of both Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars during the transformative cultural landscape of the 1960s underscores their vital place in cinematic history.

Comparing Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars: Which Emerges Victorious?

A Fistful of Dollars Elevated Eastwood’s Career, While Yojimbo Endures as a Timeless Classic

Both Yojimbo and A Fistful of Dollars are undeniably remarkable films that contribute to the film canon. They each craft unique perspectives on the anti-hero archetype, skillfully showcasing characters that retain their menacing presence while revealing underlying moral dimensions. The respective settings enrich the storytelling; both films delve into corruption through the lenses of their respective directors emerging from post-war contexts. The vivid depictions of violence—whether through gunfights or sword duels—lacked the refined choreography seen in later works, which only adds to their impactful realism. This rawness in violence exemplifies the cynical worlds both narratives inhabit.

Watch here

Nonetheless, Yojimbo benefits profoundly from Kurosawa’s cinematic artistry, which imbues the film with a refined equilibrium of tragedy and humor. Toshiro Mifune’s portrayal of Sanjuro is layered with a cynical bravado that masks the underlying heroism. Furthermore, the prevalent themes of corruption manifest more acutely in Yojimbo, immersed in a harshly cynical setting. The comparison often boils down to personal taste—whether one prefers the Western genre’s ruggedness or the nuanced storytelling of samurai films. While A Fistful of Dollars marked a promising beginning for Eastwood’s illustrious career, Yojimbo remains a quintessential film of its genre, consistently celebrated for its artistic excellence.

For those interested in exploring this cinematic treasure, Yojimbo / Sanjuro: Two Samurai Films by Akira Kurosawa is now available through the Criterion Collection.

Source: Akira Kurosawa News

Source & Images