Chronological Analysis of Tobias & Almut’s Relationship in “We Live In Time”

Warning: Contains SPOILERS for We Live in Time.

We Live in Time masterfully examines the crucial junctures in the heartfelt relationship between Almut and Tobias. Portrayed by the talented Florence Pugh and Andrew Garfield, the narrative unfolds in a non-linear fashion, interweaving three significant timelines: the couple’s initial encounter, the birth of their daughter, and Almut’s courageous battle with cancer. This storytelling technique not only adds depth but also highlights the enduring impact of love and the inescapable grasp of time.

As the story progresses towards its poignant conclusion, Almut’s untimely death leaves Tobias and their daughter, Ella, grappling with grief. Despite the heavy undercurrent of sorrow, the film transcends mere sadness, offering a bitter-sweet reflection on the extraordinary influence two lives can have on one another. The non-chronological narrative serves a specific purpose, emphasizing the significance of these pivotal moments, even as time eludes both characters’ control.

A Fateful Collision

The Unlikely Encounter

Tobias (Andrew Garfield) in the hospital with injuries — Image via A24

In a seemingly fated turn of events, Tobias finds himself in a hotel room, struggling to finalize divorce papers when his pen runs out of ink. Dressed in a disheveled bathrobe, he ventures out in search of writing supplies but ends up being struck by a car. Upon waking in the hospital, he discovers Almut at his bedside, leading them to share a meal at a diner where she shares her aspirations of becoming an acclaimed chef and extends an invitation to her upcoming restaurant.

The Beginning of Their Love Story

Intimacy Blossoms

Fast forward a few weeks later, Tobias dines at Almut’s restaurant, where the lingering tension around a table set for two hints at his recent divorce. Their chemistry ignites immediately, leading them back to Almut’s apartment for an intimate night and the following day together, marking the passionate start of their relationship.

Navigating Parenthood Discussions

A Touchy Subject

As their bond deepens, Tobias realizes his growing feelings for Almut coincide with her aversion to having children. Concerned about future conflicts, he confronts her about this sensitive issue, which leads to tension as Almut feels he is prematurely raising such a significant topic. Despite some time apart, they reconcile, acknowledging their differing desires.

The Cancer Diagnosis

A Difficult Choice

Tobias comforts Almut in a doctor's office

Almut’s world shifts when she learns she has ovarian cancer. Faced with the daunting choice advised by her doctor, she considers a hysterectomy to halt the disease. However, the thought of having a child with Tobias complicates this decision, resulting in her opting for a treatment that preserves her fertility, albeit at the risk of recurrence.

The Birth of Ella

An Unconventional Delivery

After Almut’s initial recovery, the couple experiences joy as they finally conceive Ella. In a surprising twist of fate, Almut gives birth in the bathroom of a gas station due to heavy traffic, assisted by Tobias and kind-hearted staff, marking a memorable chapter in their lives.

Facing Recurrence

Choosing Quality of Life

Almut, visibly distressed, with a shaved head

Years into their partnership, Almut’s discomfort at work reveals the grim news of her cancer’s return. Consulting with a physician about treatment options, she ultimately decides against rigorous therapies in favor of spending her remaining time filled with meaningful experiences alongside Tobias and Ella.

Nurturing Her Culinary Passion

A Culinary Competition

Determined to pursue her culinary dreams, Almut secretly commits to competing in the prestigious Bocuse d’Or, believing it to be a vital opportunity. Balancing her health challenges, she recruits Jade from her restaurant to assist, but struggles intensify when she neglects to collect Ella from school, highlighting her intense dedication.

A Proposal Amidst Chaos

Love and Timing

Almut holds her daughter while getting shaved — Image via A24

Realizing their time together is fleeting, Tobias finally proposes to Almut, wanting to solidify their bond through marriage. However, as fate would have it, their wedding date conflicts with the Bocuse d’Or competition. Almut ultimately prioritizes the competition, aiming to leave a lasting legacy for her loved ones. Tobias, though hurt initially, understands and respects her wishes, canceling the wedding.

The Competition

A Final Triumph

Despite the underlying challenges, Almut dedicates herself to the Bocuse d’Or, igniting her competitive spirit reminiscent of her days as a figure skater. This opportunity grants her a sense of achievement and individual fulfillment amidst her fight against cancer. Ultimately, she returns to the ice rink, bidding farewell to Tobias and Ella, a poignant representation of her journey.

Navigating Grief Together

Healing and Moving Forward

Tobias and Almut playing with their child — Image via A24

While We Live in Time does not explicitly confirm Almut’s demise, her absence profoundly affects the remaining characters. Tobias, Ella, and a new dog—a symbol of continuity and comfort—endeavor to find solace in life after loss. The film concludes with a touching scene where Tobias teaches Ella how to make eggs, reminiscent of how Almut used to do it, weaving memories into their healing process.

Exploring Non-Linear Storytelling in Romantic Films

Non-linear narratives are a fascinating storytelling mechanism, and We Live in Time stands out in its romantic context. Other films such as Blue Valentine, (500) Days of Summer, The Time Traveler’s Wife, and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind have also utilized this technique. Each explores the complexities and nuances of love across various timelines, enhancing audience engagement by demonstrating how relationships evolve and, at times, dissolve over time.

These cinematic explorations showcase that, regardless of structure, romantic storytelling can profoundly resonate with viewers, exemplifying how love endures through both joyous and challenging circumstances.

Source & Images