Chris Evans 2011 Interview Reveals Hypocrisy Behind Anthony Mackie’s Recent Captain America Backlash

The conversation surrounding Captain America has taken a new turn following recent comments made by Anthony Mackie, which have faced considerable backlash. To put this into perspective, it’s essential to reflect on the character’s essence and the legacy that Mackie is now inheriting. He will step into the role with the upcoming film Captain America: Brave New World, set to release on February 14, where he portrays Sam Wilson, the new Captain America. This transition was initially initiated over five years ago in Avengers: Endgame, but Mackie’s journey of accepting this immense responsibility was explored in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier.

Throughout the series, Wilson wrestled with what it meant to take up the mantle of Captain America, ultimately realizing that Steve Rogers had chosen him for a reason. Even amidst challenges, like the troubling tenure of John Walker as Captain America, this journey clarified the importance of the mantle and emphasized why only a select few are truly capable of wielding it. I believe that Mackie’s portrayal will encapsulate this sentiment beautifully in Captain America: Brave New World, further validated by his poignant remarks regarding the character.

Understanding Anthony Mackie’s Captain America Comments

Mixed Reactions: Fans Respond to Mackie’s Comments

On January 27, 2025, during an event, Mackie discussed the significance of embodying Captain America. He described this experience as akin to fulfilling a childhood dream, a sentiment many Marvel actors share. More importantly, he articulated that the essence of Captain America transcends the geographical connotations associated with the title. Here is a glimpse of his quote:

“For me, Captain America represents a lot of different things and I don’t think the term ‘America’ should be one of those representations. It’s about a man who keeps his word, who has honor, dignity and integrity. Someone who is trustworthy and dependable.”

Despite Mackie’s thoughtful commentary, his views received mixed reactions online. Some fans accused him of harboring negative sentiments towards America, while others expressed concern that his comments might hurt the film’s financial prospects, outright rejecting the idea of Mackie as the new Captain America. This backlash prompted Mackie to clarify his position on Instagram, emphasizing his pride in being American and his deep respect for those who serve. He remarked:

“Let me be clear about this, I’m a proud American and taking on the shield of a hero like CAP is the honor of a lifetime. I have the utmost respect for those who serve and have served our country. CAP has universal characteristics that people all over the world can relate to.”

The Historical Context of Captain America

Chris Evans’ Views on Captain America from 2011

Chris Evans in Captain America: The First Avenger

Interestingly, this backlash comes in the wake of similar sentiments expressed by Chris Evans, who portrayed the original Captain America. During promotional discussions for Captain America: The First Avenger in 2011, Evans argued against the notion of Captain America being a simplistic embodiment of American patriotism. He humorously suggested that the character might be better titled “Captain Good, ”dismissing the idea that a flag-waving narrative defined him. Evans noted:

“Ha, well, to me, I’m not trying to get too lost in the American side of it. This isn’t a flag waving movie… I think that everyone could agree that Nazis were bad, and he, Cap, just so happens to wear the red, white and blue.”

Evans’ comments, while not explicitly saying that Captain America’s identity shouldn’t be tied to America, imply that the character’s core values and heroism exist beyond national identity. This perspective emphasizes the evolution of Captain America’s characterization, which began amid World War II as a rallying symbol against tyranny.

Captain America’s Core Values and Criticism

Values that Extend Beyond Nationality

While Captain America is undeniably a product of political contexts, his essence is rooted in values such as altruism, justice, and steadfastness against tyranny—ideals that surpass mere national identity. This moral framework resonates with what Mackie articulated and encapsulates why Steve Rogers deemed him a worthy successor.

Moreover, Captain America’s character has often depicted moments of dissent against authority — a reflection of the very values he embodies. Instances in the comics and the MCU illustrate Cap standing against decisions by the government, reinforcing the idea that true patriotism aligns with the principles of freedom and justice, rather than blind allegiance.

Hypocrisy in the Backlash Against Mackie

Disparities in Criticism of Evans and Mackie

Captain America poster featuring Evans and Mackie — Custom Image by Lewis Glazebrook

It is striking to observe the disparity in the level of backlash directed towards Anthony Mackie compared to Chris Evans for making similar statements. While I acknowledge the emotional investment fans have in Steve Rogers, the negative response to Mackie appears disproportionate, and, in some cases, may stem from racial biases.

In The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, Wilson expressed the weight of the role he was stepping into, acknowledging the scrutiny he would face. The essence of Captain America’s legacy is not confined to his nationality but to the values he represents. Mackie’s portrayal promises to reflect the same qualities that endeared audiences to Captain America from the start.

Ultimately, chastising Mackie for articulating what makes Captain America’s story universal, while letting Evans’ remarks slip by with minimal scrutiny, raises questions regarding the motivations behind these criticisms. Suggesting that Sam Wilson lacks the qualities essential to Captain America is, frankly, disingenuous.