“Carrie Ann, You’re Replaced”: Dancing with the Stars Fans Celebrate Rosie Perez’s Role as Guest Judge

The latest episode of Dancing with the Stars season 33 premiered on Monday, October 7, 2024, showcasing a special guest judge, American actress Rosie Perez, during the Soul Train Night theme.

Rosie Perez’s guest appearance was well-received across social media, with many fans drawing comparisons to veteran judge Carrie Ann Inaba. One viewer expressed their excitement on X, stating:

“Rosie is a great judge. This may have been her audition, Carrie Ann, you’re being replaced!”

“The way Rosie, the guest judge, is giving more equitable scores than Carrie Ann is remarkable….can she take over?”another fan noted.

“Carrie Ann, watch out—Rosie Perez could be coming for your position,”one tweet mentioned.

Fans of season 33 were particularly impressed with Rosie Perez’s ability to provide “constructive critiques”:

“Rosie gave Brooks some real, constructive feedback and advised her not to lean solely on her looks,”one user highlighted.

“The feedback from Rosie, a guest judge, seems more accurate than what a judge with two decades of experience is giving,”a viewer commented.

“Rosie Perez is the best guest judge we’ve ever had; she should definitely replace Carrie Ann,”another tweet declared.

Supporters of Dancing with the Stars season 33 voiced that:

“Given her background as a Soul Train dancer and Fly Girls choreographer, Rosie Perez absolutely belongs on that judging panel tonight,”a fan remarked.

“She’s still got that stiffness, but she is a fantastic judge,”another viewer pointed out.

Highlights from Dancing with the Stars Season 33 Episode 3

In the third episode of Dancing with the Stars season 33, themed Soul Train Night, guest judge Rosie Perez sought out the “boogie”dancing style, emphasizing the essence of a true Soul Train dancer.

The episode kicked off with Phaedra Parks and her partner Val Chmerkovskiy, who danced the Quickstep to Aretha Franklin’s “Think.”While judges noted her performance, Derek pointed out some issues with her arms and footwork. Bruno suggested a need for better frame opening, and Carrie Ann remarked that Phaedra’s foot got stuck at one moment.

Phaedra ended up with a score of 30 out of 40, closely followed by Ilona Maher and Alen Bersten, who performed the Foxtrot to LaBelle’s “Lady Marmalade,”also scoring 30 out of 40.

Next, Eric Roberts and Britt Stewart took the floor with their Foxtrot to Al Green’s “Let’s Stay Together,”earning a score of 24 out of 40, which Rosie applauded given Roberts’ injury.

Stephen Nedoroscik and Rylee Arnold had a Quickstep set to Stevie Wonder’s “Superstition.”Rosie noted some stiffness and slight timing issues but complimented him on his cuteness. They scored 30 out of 40.

Brooks Nader and Gleb Savchenko’s Rumba to “S*xual Healing”garnered mixed critiques. Though all judges praised their performance, Rosie suggested Brooks express herself more fully. Their total was 28 out of 40.

The Bachelor’s Joey Graziadei and Jenna Johnson performed a lively Jive to “Shout”by the Isley Brothers. Rosie admired his appeal and said he had the boogie spirit, resulting in a score of 34 out of 40.

Dwight Howard and Danielle Karagach followed with a Cha Cha to “Let’s Groove,”though judges noted improvement was needed, scoring them 23 out of 40.

Danny Amendola and Witney Carson wowed with a Foxtrot to “Dancing Machine,”securing a score of 30 out of 40. Similarly, Reginald Veljohnson and Emma Slater performed the Foxtrot to “I Can See Clearly Now,”culminating in a score of 21 out of 40. Jenn Tran and Sasha Farber presented a Viennese Waltz to “Fallin’”by Alicia Keys, receiving 31 out of 40.

Finally, Chandler Kinney and Brandon Armstrong showcased their Cha Cha to “It’s Tricky,”achieving a high score of 36 out of 40.

Throughout the episode, fans expressed their appreciation for Rosie Perez’s insightful critiques. The next episode of DWTS season 33 is set to air on Tuesday, October 8, 2024.

Source