Captain America: Brave New World – A Frustrating, Messy, and Uninteresting Review

Film Review: Captain America – Brave New World

*Captain America: Brave New World* struggles with inadequate plot and character development, failing to effectively introduce a new Captain America.
The film attempts to reconcile a fresh narrative with the legacy of Captain America but ultimately delivers a disappointing storyline.
Although seeking to present a grounded conflict, it fails to provide impactful action sequences and substantial character growth.

From the moment the Marvel Studios logo fades in, Captain America: Brave New World sets a distinctive tone, opting for a stark black-and-white aesthetic that departs from the usual spectacle. The introduction of President Thaddeus ‘Thunderbolt’ Ross, played by Harrison Ford, is backed by a score reminiscent of classic political dramas. Unfortunately, this promising start does not maintain its momentum throughout the film.

As a launchpad for the new Captain America, *Brave New World* disappoints. The film is marred by behind-the-scenes struggles that leave it feeling disjointed. While Anthony Mackie has delivered strong performances in past MCU films, leading a project such as this proves to be a daunting challenge for him. Advertised as a conspiracy thriller, it ultimately lacks the suspense and intrigue necessary to hold audience interest.

The plot centers on Sam Wilson’s official acceptance of the Captain America title, complete with a new partner, Joaquin Torres (portrayed by Danny Ramirez).An early montage aims to reintroduce audiences to Thaddeus Ross, echoing iconic sequences from *The Winter Soldier*.Regrettably, the action fails to live up to its predecessors, revealing the film’s central flaw: it struggles to create a fresh narrative while honoring the established Captain America legacy. Attempting to balance both objectives may have proven to be too ambitious.

The storyline unfolds as Ross grapples with the challenges of his presidency, characterized by the discovery of the pivotal element, adamantium, and his tumultuous past as a “Hulk-obsessed” soldier. Simultaneously, Sam explores what it truly means to embody the legacy of Captain America. While these personal stakes present intriguing conflicts, they fail to culminate in a meaningful conclusion. The narrative also introduces Tim Blake Nelson’s villainous Samuel Sterns, whose motivations remain muddled despite their implication in an elaborate scheme.

Supporting roles, such as Ruth Bat-Serpah (from Shira Haas) and Giancarlo Esposito’s Sidewinder, are underutilized. Their contributions feel superficial, with Ruth’s character especially dispensable to the overall plot. Although Esposito delivers a commendable performance, Sidewinder emerges as an almost tangential character, reduced to acting as an exposition device. The decision to excise earlier scenes featuring the Serpent Society raises questions about the narrative’s pacing and coherence.

The standout element of *Brave New World* is undoubtedly Carl Lumbly’s portrayal of Isaiah Bradley. Initially introduced in *The Falcon and the Winter Soldier*, Bradley’s narrative serves as a poignant commentary on the treatment of Black soldiers in U. S.history. While the previous series effectively developed his character’s arc, this film relies on him primarily as a plot catalyst. Lumbly, however, skillfully conveys Bradley’s rich and tragic history with limited screen time.

It is unfortunate that Bradley’s character depth remains largely unexplored in this installment. Despite being heralded as a film focused on a new Captain America and the implications of that role for Sam and those around him, *Brave New World* avoids confronting the complex questions it raises. The film flirts with these themes in its climax but undermines the gravity with unconvincing humor, a growing weakness in Marvel’s storytelling. Major revelations and unexpected turns are notably absent, leaving viewers with a predictable narrative that fails to deliver tension.

One aspect where *Brave New World* shines is its departure from the over-reliance on CGI that has plagued numerous recent Marvel features. Despite its shortcomings, the film attempts to showcase a more grounded conflict, diverging from exaggerated spectacle with relatable stakes. However, even sequences featuring aerial confrontations between Captain America and Falcon against military jets fall flat, lacking the emotional weight that should accompany such moments.

This sentiment extends to the climactic battle involving a hyper-powered Ross, where Sam miraculously withstands a barrage of catastrophic attacks. While one might attribute this to his Vibranium suit, even the original Captain America would find such a scenario implausibly challenging. Ultimately, this confrontation, which has been heavily spoiled in marketing efforts, feels unfulfilled—almost as if included merely to satisfy contractual obligations.

Fans of the franchise may have recently enjoyed the more widely praised *Deadpool & Wolverine*, but *Captain America: Brave New World* notably swings back toward mediocrity, falling short of the exhilarating narratives that have defined earlier films. As a first significant legacy title in some time, it should have reignited audience passion for the franchise; instead, it may only reinforce disenchantment with the MCU.

Captain America: Brave New World is set to hit theaters on February 14th.

Source & Images