Bungie Resolves Copyright Lawsuit Regarding Destiny 2 Red War Campaign

Bungie Settles Legal Dispute Over Destiny 2 Copyright Claims

In a significant development, Bungie has resolved a legal dispute with author Matthew Kelsey Martineau, who previously claimed that the studio had used elements from his work in crafting the narrative for the Red War campaign and the Red Legion in Destiny 2. Martineau’s allegations stemmed from content he published on WordPress between 2013 and 2014.

Martineau initiated the lawsuit against Bungie last year, alleging copyright infringement. At first glance, it might have appeared to be a straightforward case for Bungie to dismiss. In their motion to dismiss the case, Bungie contended that Martineau failed to effectively demonstrate that the company copied elements deemed original from his work, claiming that the complaint did not establish factual copying and that the referenced works were not substantially similar under legal standards.

However, the case took a turn when Judge Susie Morgan opted not to dismiss the lawsuit. The crux of the issue was Bungie’s inability to provide direct evidence from the Destiny 2 Red War campaign, as that specific content had been vaulted. With it no longer accessible to the public and incompatible with the updated framework of Destiny 2, this posed a significant challenge for the studio.

In an attempt to substantiate their defense, Bungie relied on archived gameplay footage and Destinypedia content. Judge Morgan, however, ruled against the use of such material, stating, “While Plaintiff does reference Destiny 2 in his complaint, he does not reference the YouTube videos containing Destiny 2 game footage, the Destinypedia pages, or the Tyson declaration.”

As a result of the dismissal failure, the case progressed into an extended discovery phase, providing Martineau with the opportunity to bolster his claims. Ultimately, as reported by The Game Post, Bungie and Martineau reached a settlement.

A court filing indicated that “a settlement conference was conducted before the undersigned Magistrate Judge; negotiations were successful and resulted in the settlement of all claims.”The Court acknowledged the efforts of both parties in arriving at this amicable resolution.

While the details of the settlement, including any financial compensation for Martineau, remain undisclosed, the court has classified the case as resolved—provided that both parties adhere to the settlement terms over the subsequent 60 days. This window allows either side to reopen the case if necessary.

This resolution may provide Bungie with some relief as it navigates ongoing challenges, including the reported poor sales performance of Destiny 2.

Source & Images