Benedict Cumberbatch Provides Sherlock Season 5 Update That Leaves Fans Feeling Hopeless

Benedict Cumberbatch has laid down a significant condition for reprising his role as Sherlock Holmes, casting further doubt on the prospects of Sherlock season 5. As a devoted fan who eagerly awaited each new season and thoughtfully considered the show’s evolution past season 2, I always hoped for more. However, with each passing year, the likelihood of a season 5 has diminished. Besides the logistical challenges of reuniting the esteemed cast, the finale of season 4 did not provide a satisfactory conclusion, leaving much to be desired.

The initial seasons of Sherlock were indeed remarkable, but momentum waned as the series progressed. Season 3 struggled to redefine the show’s identity after Sherlock’s dramatic comeback, failing to explain the details behind his supposed demise adequately. Both the standalone special “The Abominable Bride”and season 4 received a lukewarm response compared to the show’s earlier acclaim. The series finale particularly disappointed many long-time fans. Nonetheless, I’m heartened by Cumberbatch’s willingness to consider revisiting the character under the right circumstances.

Cumberbatch’s Conditions for Sherlock Season 5 Appear Unlikely

Season 5 Would Need to Exceed Previous Releases

Benedict Cumberbatch as Sherlock in season 3 teaser

In an interview with Variety, Cumberbatch outlined what it would take to bring him back to the role of Sherlock Holmes. While he initially humorously suggested hefty financial compensation, he clarified that any new material would need to be “better than it ever was.”The celebrated actor emphasized his desire to surprise both himself and the audience, recalling a previous engagement where he acknowledged the fans’ affinity for Sherlock.

Season	Rotten Tomatoes Score
Sherlock Season 1	93%
Sherlock Season 2	94%
Sherlock Season 3	91%
The Abominable Bride	62%
Sherlock Season 4	54%

Cumberbatch further noted that any new outing would need to represent a “superlative version”of the series’ previous successes. While it is reassuring to hear that he is committed to maintaining high standards, I harbor reservations about whether a fifth season could truly match the brilliance of the show’s initial installments. The decline in quality observed during seasons 3 and 4 raises a pertinent question: can the series recapture the essence of the early episodes?

The Absence of Sherlock Season 5 Isn’t Necessarily Detrimental

Preserving Sherlock’s Legacy

Despite ending on a somewhat underwhelming note, Sherlock continues to hold a remarkable legacy. The series played a vital role in reviving interest in Sherlock Holmes throughout the 2010s, alongside the likes of the Robert Downey Jr.films and CBS’s Elementary. The stellar first two seasons established such a high bar that subsequent attempts to continue the saga were bound to disappoint. The series became entangled in its own success, with an increasing need for greater twists and complexity leading to its critiques.

The pressure to escalate narratives ultimately diluted the essence that made the show captivating initially. Reimagining the magic captured in the early episodes could yield great results, but it may also risk another lackluster outcome, potentially repeating the missteps seen in season 4. As much as I would love to see Cumberbatch and Freeman together again, it may be wise to leave the series in its current state, preserving its esteemed reputation.

Hope for Sherlock Season 5 Still Lingers

Prospects for a New Season Might Not Be Over

Benedict Cumberbatch's Sherlock smiles while he and John are running in Sherlock series — Custom image by Fariba Rezwan

There remains a glimmer of hope, as neither the cast nor the creative minds behind Sherlock have categorically dismissed the idea of season 5 or a potential revival. Co-creator Steven Moffat recently expressed to SFX that the absence of a new season seems “madness, ”highlighting Sherlock Holmes’s timeless relevance and the enduring fan interest.

We would happily do it again and I hope someday that we do. It seems perverse not to. You make enough shows in your lifetime that no one gives a flying one about, so it’s nice to have one that people are passionate about. It’s almost presumptuous, almost arrogant, not to do it again. But there are no hard plans, none at all.

The Sherlock series has not shied away from adapting some of Arthur Conan Doyle’s most renowned stories, creatively weaving in original tales along the way. While a new season could potentially revisit these approaches, a TV movie format might prove more viable, especially considering the busy schedules of Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman since the series’ conclusion.

For fans of the detective series, the wait for new content continues, but the legacy of Sherlock serves as a delightful reminder of its significant impact on contemporary adaptations. Keep an eye out for any updates regarding a potential new chapter in Sherlock’s intriguing narrative universe.

Source: Variety, SFX

Source & Images