Batman Thinks One Justice League Hero Is More Extreme Than He Is

Warning: contains spoilers for Challengers of the Unknown #2!

Batman vs. Mister Terrific: A Tactical Comparison

In the realm of the DC Universe, Batman is renowned for his strategic use of fear and intimidation, but there’s one hero who surpasses him in his unorthodox methods: Mister Terrific. In the recently released Challengers of the Unknown #2, Batman openly admits to his ally June Robbins that he struggles to comprehend the tactics employed by this fellow Justice League member. This revelation underscores a growing concern over the extremities of both heroes’ methodologies.

Written by Christopher Cantwell, who concurrently pens Star Trek: Defiant for IDW, this issue portrays Mister Terrific as he investigates the Challengers of the Unknown, suspecting their involvement in Darkseid’s recent demise. Keeping them in the dark about his plans, Mister Terrific has taken to quarantining the Challengers, hinting at strategic maneuvers that even Batman finds baffling.

Five panels of Batman finding Mister Terrific's tactics confusing

Mister Terrific: Legacy and Background

The character of Mister Terrific has a rich history within the DC Comics canon. The current iteration, Michael Holt, honors the legacy of Terry Sloane, the Golden Age’s original Mister Terrific. Sloane was an influential figure in the Justice Society and met his end during a confrontation with the Spirit King in 1979. Years later, Holt, devastated by personal loss, was saved from despair by the intervention of the Spectre, who introduced him to Sloane’s legacy. Holt subsequently embraced the Mister Terrific mantle.

Created by John Ostrander and Tom Mandrake, Holt stands out as an exemplar of superhero intellect combined with physical ability. He boasts an impressive portfolio of 14 doctorates across multiple scientific disciplines. As a successful businessman and the founder of TerrificTech, he frequently collaborates with other heroes, serving as a consultant on complex cases and securing his place as a fan favorite since his debut in 1997’s The Spectre #54.

Mister Terrific’s exceptional intelligence often shapes his strategies in the field. Operating as the CEO of his tech enterprise, he employs notable heroes like Wally West, aka The Flash. However, their dynamic sometimes highlights Holt’s high expectations and formidable competence, leading to tension between the two heroes. This confidence, while occasionally interpreted as arrogance, has earned widespread respect in the superhero community—except for Batman.

The Paradox of Extremes: Batman and Mister Terrific

While both Batman and Mister Terrific exhibit extreme methods, the ethics of their approaches warrant scrutiny.Batman’s extensive use of child sidekicks raises significant moral questions, as seen in his recruiting practices of the numerous Robins throughout his career. His fears of inadequacy in the face of overwhelming threats, notably from Superman, have led him to devise numerous contingency plans aimed at neutralizing other heroes. Unfortunately, these elaborate schemes have not always yielded positive outcomes, often resulting in unintended chaos.

Given Batman’s own history with extreme tactics, his criticism of Mister Terrific can appear hypocritical. Despite his intelligence, Holt maintains a strategy devoid of the paranoia that characterizes Batman’s approach. Instead of seeing his knowledge as a potential threat, Holt utilizes his information to support the Justice League, contrasting sharply with Batman’s secretive and defensive mindset.

Batman’s Critique: Compliment or Condemnation?

Batman’s acknowledgment of his difficulties in understanding Mister Terrific’s strategies could imply a disdain for Holt’s methods. The narrative includes hard-hitting journal entries from Mister Terrific that indicate a worrying obsession with the events unraveling on the Watchtower, which may validate Batman’s reservations. With the Challengers of the Unknown expressing frustration over Mister Terrific’s opaque strategies, it raises suspicions about the true extent of his insight.

Conversely, it’s plausible that Batman’s remarks could carry an unintentional compliment. Batman, known for his tactical genius, may find himself at a loss against Mister Terrific’s unconventional methods. If Holt is indeed outsmarting even the Dark Knight, it places him in a unique position that could offer tactical advantages in potential confrontations.

Don’t miss the chance to explore these gripping storylines; Challengers of the Unknown #2 is now available from DC Comics!

Source & Images