Bank Increases Tesla Price Target to $500 with 120x P/E Ratio Due to “Nebulous” Business Factors

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The author does not hold any positions in the stocks discussed.

Piper Sandler Doubles Down on Tesla: New Target Set at $500

In a significant update, investment bank Piper Sandler has raised its price target for Tesla stocks by an impressive 59%, setting it at $500. This announcement comes with cautionary notes about the potential challenges Tesla may encounter in the first half of the year, yet the bank firmly reiterates its stance that Tesla remains its top recommendation for long-term investment, classified as a ‘Buy and Hold’ opportunity.

Tesla’s performance outlook entering 2025 has been mixed, particularly following a tough landscape in 2024. The electric vehicle (EV) sector faced significant headwinds due to rising interest rates and inflation, adversely affecting Tesla’s stock until after the November elections. Post-election, however, the company witnessed a remarkable resurgence with its stock climbing nearly 100% over subsequent months.

Market Reaction: Pre-Market Gains for Tesla

Following Piper Sandler’s optimistic report, Tesla shares saw a 2% increase in pre-market trading. The price target adjustment from $315 to $500 comes after the bank analyzed a comprehensive set of data related to Tesla’s operations and market conditions. While acknowledging the difficulties faced by Tesla throughout 2024, the firm believes that the advent of artificial intelligence (AI) can significantly enhance Tesla’s future valuation.

Analysts at Piper Sandler suggest that investors are beginning to recognize Tesla’s potential in practical applications of AI, particularly in its assisted driving platform known as Full Self-Driving (FSD). The immense data and computational capabilities that Tesla possesses are crucial factors in its valuation prospects.

Autonomous Ridesharing: An Emerging Valuation Factor

The growing interest in autonomous ridesharing, often referred to as ‘robotaxis,’ contributes to Tesla’s enhancing stock attractiveness. However, the anticipation from last year’s autonomy day fell short when no definitive roadmap was presented for potential ridesharing services, leading to stock price fluctuations.

Despite Piper Sandler’s favorable view on Tesla’s AI advancements, they caution that the broader narrative about long-term growth may falter if the company fails to meet short-term financial projections. For instance, Tesla shares experienced a 6% decline on the first trading day of the year after reports indicated that 2024 vehicle deliveries had slightly decreased compared to the previous year, with deliveries totaling 1.79 million, falling short of estimates.

The Road Ahead: Leadership Insights and Valuation Adjustments

In light of uncertainty surrounding near-term forecasts, Piper Sandler highlights that Tesla’s future valuation will increasingly rely on emerging innovations like the Optimus line of humanoid robots and neural-net-training-as-a-service. Although these initiatives currently lack clear revenue streams, they are essential for the company’s long-term strategy. This ambiguity around potential income has led Piper Sandler to adopt a price-to-earnings (P/E) valuation model for Tesla.

The bank’s $500 share price target is calculated using a P/E multiple of 120 times the expected fiscal year 2026 earnings per share. Analysts believe that investors will have a clearer understanding of Tesla’s operational trajectory in a year’s time, particularly regarding new product launches and developments in AI technology.

Our $500 price target is based on 120x FY26E EPS, which is in the top-half of TSLA’s historical trading range. By one year from now, investors should have greater clarity regarding new product cadence; this should allow them to focus on other, more exciting topics (e.g., rising FSD efficacy and the implications for Tesla’s AI ambitions).

Source & Images