Backlash Erupts Online Over Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi’s Casting in Wuthering Heights: “This is So Embarrassing”

The recent announcement that Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi will lead in a new adaptation of Wuthering Heights has sparked a lively debate online. Helmed by Oscar-winner Emerald Fennell, renowned for her work on Promising Young Woman, this adaptation features Robbie as Catherine Earnshaw and Elordi as Heathcliff. However, fans of the classic novel are expressing significant displeasure.

The main contention arises from the casting of Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff. Traditionally described as dark-skinned and potentially of gypsy or Afro-descendant lineage in Emily Brontë’s text, some critics argue that casting directors have missed the mark by not choosing an actor who can authentically represent the character’s heritage.

An X user voiced their frustration about the casting, remarking:

“This is so embarrassing.”

A fan reacts to Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi's casting in Wuthering Heights (Image via X/@millicentgames) — A fan reacts to Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi’s casting in *Wuthering Heights* (Image via X/@millicentgames)

While Jacob Elordi has gained recognition for his roles in Euphoria and Priscilla, some critics argue that his prior roles do not resonate with Heathcliff’s complex and brooding personality. Similarly, Margot Robbie’s selection as Catherine has generated mixed feedback, with some questioning her capability to portray the intense and emotional character from Brontë’s narrative.

As this adaptation begins to take form, Fennell’s vision has already found itself at the center of controversy, raising doubts about its fidelity to the characters’ original essence.

Other social media users quickly shared their opinions on the casting of Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi:

“Did anyone actually read the book before deciding this?”commented one user.

“I’m starting to think their priority is to attract viewers. Margot and Jacob will definitely pull in a crowd.”wrote another user.

“Right, I’m not the biggest fan of Wuthering Heights, but this casting is terrible,”commented one netizen.

Some users expressed their frustration toward Emerald Fennell for the casting choices, stating:

“Oh, I’m sure Emerald had to read the book at her very posh school and also at Oxford. She is nothing but a very privileged person who thinks white is the default and pretty is prioritized above all else.”One user expressed their opinion.

“Obviously, Emerald didn’t…”added another.

Further criticism included:

“Can we stop casting the same actors for every project? Margot is talented, but she doesn’t have that period drama look or fit the character’s age range, and Jacob is not like the character described. This is pretty disappointing,”commented one user.

“Heathcliff wasn’t white. It’s absolutely clear in the book that he’s not white.”noted another X user.

About Wuthering Heights and the Latest Production Details

Wuthering Heights is a historical novel penned by Emily Brontë, published in 1847 under the pseudonym Ellis Bell. Set against the stormy backdrop of West Yorkshire, the story details the lives of the Earnshaw and Linton families through the rise and fall of Heathcliff, a foster child.

This classic literature piece is rich in Gothic and Romantic elements, weaving a tale of passion, revenge, and oppression. Although it is celebrated as a masterpiece of British literature, Wuthering Heights faced criticism for its graphic violence, cruelty, and its challenge to Victorian norms regarding class, morality, and religion.

Throughout history, the novel has inspired myriad interpretations, including musical works like “Wuthering Heights”by Kate Bush, as well as various film and stage adaptations. The latest version of Wuthering Heights, featuring Jacob Elordi and Margot Robbie, is currently in pre-production, with filming expected to commence in 2025.

Source