US Court Dismisses Class Action Lawsuit Against Apple Over iCloud Storage
The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco has officially dismissed a potential class action lawsuit targeting Apple. The lawsuit alleged that Apple made “deceptive representations“regarding its iCloud data storage offerings. This ruling bolsters Apple’s legal standing amidst various consumer complaints.
The Basis of the Lawsuit
The case stemmed from a complaint by an Apple user, Lisa Bodenburg, who had purchased a 200GB iCloud+ storage plan. Bodenburg claimed that she received less storage than what was promised. Specifically, she anticipated that her 200GB plan would supplement the complimentary 5GB of storage Apple provides to all users, resulting in a total of 205GB. Instead, she believed she was only granted 200GB of storage.
Court Rulings and Justifications
This issue was previously examined and dismissed by a U. S.District Court in May 2024. The 9th Circuit upheld this decision with a unanimous 3-0 ruling. The appellate court determined that a “reasonable consumer“would not interpret Apple’s statements about its storage plans misleadingly. The court highlighted that the iCloud Storage Agreement clearly states that all users receive 5GB of free storage and that additional storage must be purchased through one of the iCloud+ plans.
The court noted:
Apple’s statements are “not false and deceptive merely because [they] may be ‘unreasonably misunderstood by an insignificant and unrepresentative segment’” of consumers.
Comparative Legal Precedents
The ruling referenced similar cases that had been dismissed due to unreasonable consumer assumptions. For instance, a lawsuit against Diet Dr Pepper claimed it should assist with weight loss, while another case against Fresh, Inc.argued that the design of its lip balm left 25% of the product unusable. These examples underscore the court’s position on absurd consumer expectations.
Apple’s Ongoing Legal Landscape
Apple is no stranger to legal challenges, having previously faced controversy surrounding Batterygate and issues with MacBook keyboards. The company is currently grappling with a class-action lawsuit alleging misleading advertising related to Apple Intelligence. These ongoing legal battles demonstrate the complex relationship between consumer expectations and product marketing.
For more information, visit the detailed analysis by Neowin.
Leave a Reply