American Primeval’s Success Can’t Match Netflix’s Challenge to Taylor Sheridan’s Dominance in Western TV Shows

Note: This article may contain minor spoilers for American Primeval.

American Primeval: Netflix’s Latest Western Sensation

While not Netflix’s inaugural Western, American Primeval has quickly risen to prominence, demonstrating its potential to captivate audiences. Just weeks post-release, the series continues to secure a spot in the platform’s top 10 globally. Merging real-life historical events with fictional narratives, it offers a gripping portrayal of the Wild West, marked by intense emotions and stark realities.

A Tale of Survival Amid Conflict

The storyline of American Primeval revolves around a mother and her son navigating perilous terrain while caught in the tumultuous backdrop of the Utah War. With suspense building throughout, the series culminates in an unexpected finale that leaves viewers eager for more. Despite a plethora of Westerns now available on Netflix, none have achieved the widespread acclaim of Taylor Sheridan’s acclaimed Yellowstone franchise.

Comparison with Taylor Sheridan’s Western Empire

The Challenge of Competing with a Franchise

Even though American Primeval has carved its niche, it faces a formidable challenge in competing with the extensive collection of Westerns curated by Taylor Sheridan for Paramount+.With over ten shows and films including the wildly successful Yellowstone and its prequels, Sheridan has set the bar high. The franchise’s overwhelming success has highlighted the enduring appeal of the Western genre, making it difficult for Netflix’s singular hit to keep pace.

Show	Status/Air Dates
Yellowstone	2018-2024
1883	2021
1923	2022-2025
The Madison	Filming, likely to air late 2025
1944	Prequel announced
6666	A Yellowstone spinoff

Aside from the core Yellowstone franchise, Sheridan is also affiliated with exciting new projects such as Landman and the 2023 series Lawmen: Bass Reeves. Sheridan’s prolific output and undeniable success have positioned him as a leading figure in modern Western storytelling, creating a substantial gap between Netflix’s offerings and his own.

Future Prospects for American Primeval

Could New Seasons or Spin-offs Be on the Horizon?

While no official announcements have been made, viewers are already speculating about the potential for a follow-up season of American Primeval. Given the show’s initial success, it seems logical for Netflix to consider greenlighting a continuation. However, the fate of many key characters makes a direct sequel challenging, as significant figures have perished, leaving only a few survivors like Sara, Devin, and others with predetermined storylines.

One intriguing prospect is a prequel centered on Taylor Kitsch’s character, Isaac Reed. Peter Berg, the series creator, has indicated that he would be interested in exploring Reed’s backstory if the series were to continue. A focus on Reed’s character could leverage existing viewer enthusiasm and provide a pathway for further development of the American Primeval narrative.

The Strategic Move for Netflix: Creating Its Own Western Franchise

Building a Western Franchise Could Yield Success for Netflix

In light of Yellowstone‘s runaway success, it may be a savvy strategy for Netflix to carve its own niche in the Western genre. The astonishing appeal of shows like Yellowstone highlights the timeless allure of Western narratives, particularly among a demographic that enjoys “Dad TV.”Encouraged by the achievements of platforms like Prime Video with hits such as Reacher, Netflix could benefit from a deeper investment in this genre, focusing not only on Western themes but also on the emotional relatability of its characters.

Ultimately, while American Primeval provides an engaging account of the grit and challenge of life in the 1850s, it may lack the familial dynamics that have contributed to the enduring success of Yellowstone. For Netflix to thrive in the Western genre, it may need to pivot its approach or introduce fresh ideas that resonate more deeply with audiences seeking both thrilling action and intricate character development.

Source & Images