Agatha All Along: Full Cast Breakdown of New and Returning Marvel Characters and the Fate of Every Witch

This article contains spoilers for Agatha All Along! Harnessing the cult appeal of Kathryn Hahn’s character, Marvel’s Agatha All Along not only reunites familiar faces from WandaVision but also ushers in new characters into the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). As the inaugural series in Marvel Studios’ Phase 4 on Disney+, WandaVision played a pivotal role in launching the Multiverse Saga. Its success has paved the way for spin-offs like Agatha All Along and Vision Quest, deepening the narrative surrounding Agatha and exploring the lore of witches within the MCU timeline.

While a follow-up season for WandaVision is not on the cards, the show’s narrative has extended into subsequent MCU films, particularly in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Other characters from WandaVision are slated to have significant arcs in upcoming MCU projects. Notably, Vision Quest is set to chart White Vision’s journey, while Agatha All Along delves into the repercussions of WandaVision for Agatha, focusing on Billy’s quest to locate his brother, Tommy. Below is an overview of the cast and characters of Agatha All Along.

Main Cast of Agatha All Along
Actor	Character	Character Arc
Kathryn Hahn	Agatha Harkness	Sacrifices herself for Billy and returns as a ghost
Joe Locke	Teen/Billy	Gains Wiccan powers and revives Tommy
Aubrey Plaza	Vidal River	Revealed as Death
Debra Jo Rupp	Sharon Davis	Dies on the Witches’ Road
Ali Ahn	Alice Wu-Gulliver	Dies on the Witches’ Road
Patti LuPone	Lilia Calderu	Dies on the Witches’ Road
Sasheer Zamata	Jennifer Kale	Regains her powers on the Witches’ Road

Kathryn Hahn as Agatha Harkness

Powers: Formerly Stealing Powers from Witches

Kathryn Hahn first appeared as Agatha Harkness in WandaVision, initially portrayed as an inquisitive neighbor of Wanda Maximoff and Vision. However, she later unveils her true identity as a formidable witch. In Agatha All Along, the aftermath of WandaVision finds her grappling with the consequences of Wanda’s magic. With assistance from Billy and Rio Vidal, Agatha gathers a new coven to navigate the Witches’ Road, intent on absorbing their magical abilities to restore her powers.

Agatha’s complex backstory is illuminated throughout the series, particularly how Aubrey Plaza’s character, Rio Vidal, also known as Death, took Agatha’s child away. Having spent her life manipulating and stealing from other witches, Agatha ultimately sacrifices herself to protect Billy from Death, returning to guide him in the search for Tommy as a ghost.

Joe Locke as Billy/Wiccan

Powers: Chaos Magic

In the series, Joe Locke starts out as a character shrouded in mystery, known only as “Teen.”He eventually uncovers his true identity as Billy Maximoff, one of Wanda’s children, who has resurrected into the body of William Kaplan. Throughout the storyline, it becomes clear that he possesses chaos magic abilities akin to those of his mother.

By the finale, both Billy and Agatha perceive that Billy is the architect behind the Witches’ Road, and his determination to find Tommy motivates their adventure. In a pivotal moment, he assists in restoring Tommy to life, leading to their pursuit of him as the credits roll.

Aubrey Plaza as Rio Vidal/Death

Powers: Green Magic

Initially, Aubrey Plaza’s character, Rio Vidal, is enigmatic, being a Green Witch with a complicated romantic history with Agatha. The surprising reveal late in the series is that she embodies Death—a significant character in Marvel comics, substantially altering the MCU landscape.

As her connection with Agatha unfolds, viewers learn about the profound choices that define their relationship, ultimately leading to a crucial moment where Agatha sacrifices herself to spare Billy from Death’s grasp.

Patti LuPone as Lilia Calderu

Powers: Divination

Lilia Calderu, depicted by Patti LuPone, is a 450-year-old witch adept in divination. Drawing from Marvel Comics, Lilia is known as the custodian of the Book of Cagliostro and plays a crucial role in forming Agatha’s new coven. She has prior knowledge of Billy’s fate, having cast protective spells to keep him shielded from danger.

With foresight that provides glimpses of future events, her arc culminates on the Witches’ Road, where she ultimately realizes her visions and sacrifices herself to aid the surviving witches on their path.

Sasheer Zamata as Jennifer Kale

Powers: Potions

In her role, Sasheer Zamata portrays Jennifer Kale, a significant figure in Marvel lore known for her ties to mystical entities like Man-Thing and Ghost Rider. Her character is a potion master, contributing notably in moments of trial within the coven. Notably, her magical abilities were bound by Agatha in the 1920s, rendering her powerless until their journey on the Witches’ Road.

At the conclusion of the series, she regains her abilities, completing her journey and stepping away from the trials of the Witches’ Road, marking a significant moment in her character progression.

Ali Ahn as Alice Wu-Gulliver

Powers: Protection Magic

Ali Ahn takes on the role of Alice Wu-Gulliver, the daughter of the renowned witch Lorna Wu and a practitioner of protective magic. Initially disillusioned by witchcraft due to her mother’s death on the Witches’ Road, Alice’s latent potential unfolds as she embarks on the trials. Throughout their journey, she demonstrates her skills, ultimately participating in spells that help free her from burdensome curses.

In a tragic twist, Alice tries to rescue Agatha during a critical moment but ends up sacrificing her own life in the process, further emphasizing the high stakes faced by the coven.

Debra Jo Rupp as Sharon Davis AKA Mrs. Hart

Powers: None

Debra Jo Rupp reprises her role from WandaVision, originally playing Sharon Davis, also known as Mrs. Hart. As a resident caught within the Hex conjured by the Scarlet Witch, her character reemerges unaware as a member of Agatha’s coven. Despite her past ties, Sharon becomes the first casualty faced by Agatha’s group during their perilous journey on the Witches’ Road.

Supporting Characters & Returning Faces from WandaVision

Westview’s Troubled Residents Reemerge in the MCU

Emma Caulfield Ford as Sarah Proctor AKA Dottie: Known for her role as Anya in Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Caulfield returns as Dottie, previously identified as Sarah Proctor, a Westview resident entrapped by the Hex.

David A Payton as John Collins AKA Herb: Previously known as Herb in WandaVision, he reappears as John Collins, retaining a role in the unfolding plot.

Asif Ali as Abilash Tandon AKA Norm: Actor Asif Ali, renowned for diverse roles, returns as Norm, the friendly neighbor amidst the twists of Westview.

David Lengel as Harold Proctor AKA Phil: Lengel portrays the husband of Dottie, entwined in the narratives that solidify the bonds of the Westview residents.

Amos Glick as Dennis: Familiar from WandaVision as a mailman, Glick’s character, Dennis, adds warmth and light to the community vibe.

Brian Brightman as Sheriff Miller: Briefly seen in WandaVision, Brightman’s Sheriff Miller character exemplifies the authority figures amidst the chaos.

Kate Forbes as Evanora Harkness: Forbes’ portrayal of Agatha’s mother returns, enriching the storyline with her historic role as a powerful witch.

Maria Dizzia as William’s mother: Known for her performances in hit series like Orange is the New Black, Dizzia takes on the role of William Kaplan’s mother.

Paul Adelstein as William’s father: He portrays William’s father, further intertwining the family narrative within the larger witchcraft saga.

Miles Gutierrez-Riley as William’s boyfriend: A notable new actor, Gutierrez-Riley joins the cast as William’s boyfriend, adding contemporary drama.

Okwui Okpokwasili as Vertigo: As one of the Salem Seven, Okpokwasili’s casting brings depth and diversity to the ensemble, spotlighting her acclaimed artistry.

Speculations on Season 2 of Agatha All Along

Wiccan joining the fight in Agatha All Along

As of now, the fate of a second season for Agatha All Along remains uncertain, with no formal announcements regarding its renewal. However, the conclusion of season one left various plot threads ripe for exploration, particularly the potential return of Wanda Maximoff.

A key narrative direction that a potential second season could explore is Billy teaming up with ghost Agatha to seek out Tommy, thereby engaging deeply with the Young Avengers storyline. This quest is integral, tying back to Billy’s motivation for traversing the Witches’ Road.

Moreover, there lies the possibility of Agatha confronting her mortality and resolution about reuniting with her son, which would provide a heartfelt and fitting conclusion to her character arc in a future season.

Source & Images