‘A Simple Card Would Have Been Enough’: Mother’s Graduation Gift Ignites Reddit Controversy Over Daughter-in-Law Neglect

Reddit continues to be a treasure trove of family dramas and ethical dilemmas, captivating readers with its rich narratives. A recent entry in the “Am I the A**hole?” series features a 55-year-old mother navigating the complexities of favoritism after gifting her son a graduation present while disregarding her daughter-in-law, who also achieved the same academic milestone.

The Situation Unfolded

AITA for only getting a college graduation gift for my 28M son and not my DIL 28F? by u/SetLongjumping5521 in AmItheAsshole

To provide context, the Original Poster (OP), who identifies as a “proud single mom,”shared her experience of raising her son alone while celebrating his educational accomplishments. With a desire to recognize his hard work, she decided to present him with a cash gift. While this may appear commendable, it turns out that her son’s wife—who also graduated—was completely overlooked. No card, no flowers, nor even a simple congratulatory gesture was offered to her.

OP justifies her actions by assuming that her daughter-in-law’s parents would take care of any gifts. This reasoning, however, comes across as misguided. The daughter-in-law expressed her feelings of exclusion through a courteous yet direct text message, indicating that she did not expect an equal cash gift but did anticipate some form of acknowledgment for her significant achievement. OP remained steadfast, asserting that there was no obligation to recognize her daughter-in-law’s graduation.

A Self-Centered Perspective?

The OP’s initial framing of her narrative—highlighting her struggles as a single mother—while indeed valid, raises questions about the motives behind her decisions. Raising children is undoubtedly challenging, and OP deserves recognition for her dedication. However, this celebration of her son should not eclipse the accomplishments of his spouse.

What is perplexing is the OP’s apparent inability to extend basic courtesy to the other graduate. While the focus was meant to be on her son’s success, it inadvertently shifted to her personal narrative. The dismissive attitude towards her daughter-in-law’s feelings evokes what many may perceive as “monster-in-law”energy. Notably, the daughter-in-law requested so little—a simple card or even a modest flower bouquet could have sufficed, yet OP opted for silence.

Understanding Family Dynamics

The comments surrounding this incident prominently feature discussions about the true essence of “family.”The daughter-in-law’s feelings of exclusion hinted at a desire for recognition and affirmation within the family structure. OP seemed to create a delineation between “my son” and “my son’s wife,” which is an unhealthy approach to familial relationships.

When individuals marry into a family, it is essential to welcome them wholeheartedly. Celebrating milestones isn’t merely a formality; it represents acknowledgment and support for their hard work. By neglecting her daughter-in-law, OP inadvertently conveyed the opposite sentiment, which, regardless of intent, could lead to further emotional detachment.

A Call for Reconciliation

In sum, OP’s actions certainly merit scrutiny, as her behavior reflects poorly on her understanding of familial inclusivity. However, it is not too late for her to mend fences. A heartfelt apology to her daughter-in-law could pave the way for healing. Perhaps she should consider a delayed gesture of kindness—a bouquet or a small gift could serve as a reconciliation gesture.

Ultimately, kindness is not a limited resource. It is possible to celebrate her son’s achievements while also honoring his wife’s contributions without diminishing either’s significance. If this incident is truly an isolated case, hopefully, OP will seize the opportunity to foster a more inclusive and loving family dynamic moving forward.

Source & Images