8 Strategies to Rescue Law & Order Season 24 from Struggles

Law & Order‘s 24th season has encountered a challenging start, prompting speculation on how it might reclaim its viewership after a noticeable decline in ratings. Originally canceled by NBC following 20 seasons, the series made a strong comeback over a decade later as part of a revamped Thursday lineup dedicated to the franchise. While the revival has featured some of the most standout episodes in the show’s history, it faced a significant loss with Sam Waterston’s departure after portraying Jack McCoy for over 400 episodes.

This season marks the first full installment without Waterston, and the sudden exit of Lieutenant Kate Dixon (Camryn Manheim) at the season’s onset has added to the uncertainty. New cast member Jessica Brady (Maura Tierney) has large shoes to fill, especially after the fall finale left audiences questioning her fate, following her admission of past police misconduct. These notable cast changes, coupled with various other factors, have contributed to an alarming 16% decrease in ratings compared to season 23, according to TVLine.

8 Enhance Nolan Price’s Storylines

Writing Issues Impact Character Appeal

Nolan Price (Hugh Dancy) is currently among the least favored district attorneys in the franchise’s history, a misfortune given that Dancy is remarkably talented and capable of transforming the character into a standout role with better material. While there have been improvements to his characterization since his arrival in season 21, he has yet to be fully developed beyond a generic prosecutor’s role.

In past episodes, Price’s narrative arc has revolved around winning seemingly impossible cases, often succeeding despite a lackluster courtroom presence. Season 23 took a notable step forward by placing him in a compelling role as a witness to a violent crime, adding depth to his character. To boost his appeal, the series should prioritize emotionally rich storylines that make him more than just a relentless pursuer of convictions. Furthermore, the introduction of more ambiguous case outcomes would help elevate the show’s tension and viewer investment.

7 Rebalance Cop and Lawyer Dynamics

Rushed Cop Narratives Need Adjustments

The unique appeal of Law & Order lies in its duality as both a police and legal drama. Unlike typical crime shows which conclude at an arrest, Law & Order delves into the intricate legal processes that follow. However, recent seasons have shown an imbalance, favoring legal proceedings while often rushing through police investigations.

The legal narratives are compelling, showcasing complex role conflicts, but too frequently, the policing side feels hurried, as if the writers are eager to delve into the courtroom drama. The show’s treatment of social issues, particularly concerning race and policing, could also benefit from more natural and nuanced dialogues rather than contrived conversations.

6 Introduce More Complex and Thought-Provoking Storylines

Less Obvious Resolutions for Greater Depth

One of the hallmarks that set Law & Order apart was its unflinching examination of the justice system’s shortcomings. The original series was known for its thought-provoking episodes, such as season 6’s “Aftershock,”which skillfully depicted the emotional fallout from a controversial execution.

Today, the current storytelling often lacks the depth of earlier seasons, making it too obvious which viewpoint the writers advocate. A more balanced approach, wherein various perspectives on contentious issues are explored fairly, could enhance audience engagement and restore the show’s former glory.

5 Allow Baxter and Brady to Occasionally Challenge Justice

Personalities Can Create Stronger Dramatic Tension

Brady and Baxter (Tony Goldwyn) portray characters firmly focused on achieving their objectives, often at odds with their teams. While Riley’s conflicts with Brady stem largely from personal grievances, Baxter’s contentious relationship with Price often revolves around trial strategies, overshadowing deeper organizational conflicts.

To align more closely with Law & Order’s narrative style, it would be beneficial to visualize moments where Baxter and Brady inhibit their team from securing justice in pursuit of broader agendas. Such conflicts would resonate with audiences, emphasizing ethical dilemmas in the criminal justice arena.

4 Explore Baxter’s Moral Ambivalence

Create a Distinct Identity from McCoy

Following Waterston’s departure, Baxter inherited the lofty expectations stemming from McCoy’s legacy. Initially presented as a distinct character with a commitment to justice, Baxter has not fully capitalized on this narrative. His development has often mirrored McCoy’s singular focus on winning cases.

A compelling finale in season 23 illustrated Baxter’s character effectively; he faced personal sacrifices for his political ambitions, but enhancements are still needed. More stories should highlight his willingness to make morally challenging decisions that can disappoint constituents, showcasing his evolution as a character committed to the greater good.

3 Leverage Nostalgia Through Familiar Faces

Crossovers Add Value and Excitement

This season’s second episode showcased a noteworthy crossover with Olivia Benson (Mariska Hargitay) from Law & Order: SVU, who showcased fresh tensions between law enforcement and legal representatives. The episode evoked the high-quality storytelling of earlier installments, involving multi-faceted conflicts and relatable character dilemmas.

The absence of original characters following Waterston’s exit diminishes nostalgia-driven interest, which is crucial for attracting longstanding fans. Utilizing guest appearances from iconic past characters can help rekindle this sentiment and bolster viewership.

2 Subtly Derive from Real-Life Cases

Avoid Divisive Representations

The hallmark of Law & Order has been its ability to draw inspiration from real events, a tradition that remains relevant today. However, it’s essential to approach these stories with subtlety, as overt parallels can alienate viewers who may not align with the depicted perspectives on sensitive subjects.

Instead of directly mirroring contemporary cases, episodes could benefit from integrating various real-life inspirations in a blended, non-obvious manner, thereby maintaining intrigue without detracting from the storytelling impact.

1 Streamline Cold Opens

Maintain Intrigue in Opening Sequences

One of the most critical changes Law & Order could implement lies within the structure of its cold opens. The original formula of succinctly introducing the victim before the credits established a gripping format. Unfortunately, modern adaptations have extended these sequences, leading to unnecessary exposition that dilutes the mystery surrounding the case.

Returning to shorter, punchy cold opens could invigorate viewer interest and hark back to the classic appeal of the show.

Source: TVLine

Source & Images