8 Filmmakers Considered for The Godfather Before Francis Ford Coppola’s Direction

The journey of creating The Godfather is one marked by the notable directors who were approached prior to Francis Ford Coppola taking the helm. Initially reluctant, Coppola viewed Mario Puzo’s novel as lacking the depth required for a meaningful adaptation. After reconsideration, he discovered the rich thematic elements embedded within the story, recognizing it not just as a gangster film but as a poignant family drama that resonated with his own experiences as part of an Italian-American family.

This fresh perspective is what elevated The Godfather to its legendary status, allowing it to transcend the crime genre and appeal universally to audiences. Despite his eventual success, Coppola faced significant opposition, as at least eight other filmmakers were initially offered the direction seat, many citing scheduling conflicts or discomfort with the violent content of the story. Had any of these directors accepted, the film’s legacy could have been remarkably different.

8 Sergio Leone

Iconic shot from Once Upon a Time in America of characters walking with the Manhattan Bridge behind them.

Sergio Leone was Paramount’s initial choice for directing The Godfather, driven by a desire for authenticity after the studio’s previous mafia film, The Brotherhood, was deemed a failure due to its non-Italian cast and crew (source: New York Times).Leone, celebrated for his masterpieces in the spaghetti western genre, opted out to focus on his own project, Once Upon a Time in America, which aimed to invert the Hollywood gangster narrative. Sadly, this film would not release until 1984, twelve years post-The Godfather.

7 Peter Bogdanovich

Actress Tatum O'Neil as Addie Loggins in Paper Moon.

Next on the list was Peter Bogdanovich, whose disinterest was even greater than Leone’s (source: The Guardian).He dismissed the film without grasping its significance, being averse to the mafia theme. Had he directed, Bogdanovich envisioned a very different The Godfather, hinting at casting Edward G. Robinson as Don Vito Corleone.

During this period, Bogdanovich was enjoying a surge in his career following the acclaim of his films, including Targets and The Last Picture Show, which garnered Oscar nods. Instead of pursuing The Godfather, he produced the classic comedies What’s Up, Doc? and Paper Moon, which are now cherished films of the 1970s.

6 Peter Yates

Following Leone and Bogdanovich, Peter Yates received an offer before it reached Coppola (source: CBS News).Best known for the iconic film Bullitt, Yates likely would have injected a more action-oriented perspective into The Godfather. His stylistic choices would have turned key moments into sensationalized spectacles, contrasting Coppola’s subtle and grounded portrayal of violence.

5 Otto Preminger

Otto Preminger also declined the opportunity to direct The Godfather. A prominent figure in Hollywood, particularly in the film noir genre, Preminger’s illustrious career included impactful works like Laura (1944).Had he shown interest, Preminger might have challenged the film’s themes through eloquent storytelling, given his history of tackling societal taboos, from drug addiction in The Man with the Golden Arm to themes of sexual violence.

4 Richard Brooks

Burt Lancaster in the desert in The Professionals

Richard Brooks was yet another name floated for directing The Godfather. Known for his compelling character-driven narratives, Brooks had a diverse career ranging from penning the film noir classic The Killers to directing In Cold Blood. Brooks might have delivered a profound exploration of the rich characters behind the mob’s façade, akin to Coppola’s ultimate vision, ensuring the film still resonated profoundly with audiences.

3 Franklin J. Schaffner

George C. Scott doing a salute in Patton

Another notable director who turned down the project was Franklin J. Schaffner. With a filmography that spans diverse genres, he was at the helm of critical successes such as Planet of the Apes and Patton. However, it’s conceivable that his approach could have rendered The Godfather slower paced, removing some of the urgency and intensity that Coppola masterfully crafted in his film.

2 Costa-Gavras

Greek-French filmmaker Costa-Gavras was also approached but opted not to direct The Godfather. Best known for the politically charged thriller Z, which earned him significant acclaim, Costa-Gavras would likely have emphasized the political undercurrents present in the film, offering a very different lens on organized crime than Coppola did, focusing on capitalism and corruption rather than the familial ties that underpin the original story.

1 Arthur Penn

The titular characters in Bonnie and Clyde

Lastly, Arthur Penn, a key figure in the New Hollywood movement known for Bonnie and Clyde, was also a potential candidate for directing The Godfather. His ability to delicately portray complex characters redefined heroism in film and may have lent itself well to a sympathetic interpretation of the Corleone family. His unique vision might have paved the way for an intriguing exploration of morality, drawing parallels between the figures in The Godfather and the sympathetic outlaws of his earlier work.

This glimpse into the alternative directing paths for The Godfather not only highlights the film’s legacy but also emphasizes how each director’s unique style could have shaped an entirely different cinematic landscape.Sources include The Guardian and CBS News.

Source & Images