4 WWE stars who can join The Judgment Day after WrestleMania 40 – Newly turned star, long-time rival, and more

Ever since its formation in 2022 under the leadership of Edge, the Judgment Day has been a dominant force in WWE. Edge wasted no time in bringing in Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley to join his faction. However, the addition of Finn Balor caused tension within the group, leading to Priest, Balor, and Ripley eventually ousting Edge and taking over the faction. The Judgment Day has since continued to make waves in the wrestling world.

Currently, there are five members in the group. Finn Balor, Damian Priest, and Rhea Ripley are still part of the stable, while Dominik Mysterio joined in late 2022 and was later followed by JD McDonagh in 2023.

Despite already achieving great success as a team, the faction continues to strive for improvement. Finn Balor and Damian Priest hold the Undisputed RAW and SmackDown Tag Team Championships, while Priest also possesses the Money in The Bank briefcase and Rhea Ripley holds the Women’s World Championship. However, they are determined to find ways to further enhance their performance.

The most effective means of enhancing The Judgment Day is for it to continue expanding. In this article, we will explore a few possible candidates who could potentially join the cunning stable after WrestleMania. This group could potentially include a newly converted star, a recent returnee, or even an emerging wrestler from NXT. Who will be the next addition to this group after WrestleMania?

Among the options for potential additions to The Judgment Day after WrestleMania 40 are four notable WWE superstars.

#4. A Potential Reconciliation Between Liv Morgan and Rhea Ripley

Liv Morgan is a thriving and well-liked WWE athlete. She previously won the Women’s Money in The Bank and successfully used the briefcase to claim the SmackDown Women’s Championship. The Miracle Kid cashed in on Ronda Rousey to secure the highly coveted title.

Morgan has been involved with The Judgment Day for quite some time. Even before Finn Balor became a member, she worked alongside The Prince and AJ Styles to combat the faction. Her grievances were primarily directed towards Rhea, whom she continues to hold a strong animosity towards to this day.

Despite facing challenges in their time together in WWE, a large portion of the fanbase is hopeful for a reunion. Liv and Brutality may have the opportunity to reunite if Morgan were to switch to a villainous role and align herself with The Judgment Day. Considering Liv’s previous inability to defeat Rhea, she could potentially resort to the saying, “if you can’t beat them, join them.”

#3. Andrade has hinted at joining the group

Despite his young age, Andrade is already considered one of the most exceptional talents in the world. His style is a perfect blend of grace and strength, allowing him to seamlessly transition between lucha and power moves. As a former WWE United States and NXT Champion, Andrade has proven his ability to hold prestigious titles throughout his career.

The skilled entertainer was absent from the company for a significant amount of time, during which he mainly worked in Mexico and for All Elite Wrestling. He made a comeback in the 2024 Men’s Royal Rumble Match and subsequently joined WWE RAW. Since joining the red brand, he has been spotted alongside Dominik Mysterio on multiple occasions.

It has been speculated that Andrade may be the next member to join the group, making him a likely candidate for membership. If he does indeed join, this would be a significant moment on the RAW following WrestleMania. With the support of Judgment Day, Andrade would have the opportunity to pursue championship success.

#2. Candice LeRae’s Surprising Heel Turn on WWE Programming

Despite being an incredibly skilled performer, Candice LeRae has often been overlooked in the wrestling world. She has dedicated years to her craft, but it wasn’t until recently that she gained recognition on a larger scale. During her time in NXT, she held the Women’s NXT Tag Team Championship, but has yet to achieve the same success on the main roster.

Recently, The Poison Pixie has been exhibiting a previously unseen side of her personality, resulting in her achieving mainstream recognition. Despite her previous lack of television appearances and losses during her time on the WWE main roster, LeRae’s transformation into a heel has been propelling The Poison Pixie to consistent victories on Monday Night RAW.

A photo of Rhea Ripley and Candice LeRae posing together has recently surfaced on social media. This has sparked speculation among fans about the possibility of the two joining forces on television. With Candice’s recent turn to a villainous character, it is not far-fetched to imagine her aligning with the cunning faction. This alliance could potentially propel her to greater heights in her career.

#1. The Professional Relationship between Lyra Valkyria and Rhea Ripley

Lyra Valkyria, an exceptional performer, is currently under contract with WWE NXT. While she initially joined the company through NXT UK, she has rapidly climbed the ladder in the developmental brand, captivating fans worldwide.

The NXT Women’s Champion is the Irish star who was able to defeat Becky Lynch, the very same Lynch who is currently challenging Rhea Ripley for the Women’s World Championship at WWE WrestleMania 40.

It is worth noting that Lyra and Rhea have encountered each other on multiple occasions. They have engaged in a physical confrontation and even demonstrated a mutual admiration. Although their interactions have become more intense, it is likely that their respect for each other still exists. In the event that it does, Rhea may potentially invite Lyra to join The Judgment Day faction. Adding another member to the group would be beneficial for the entire stable.