3 possible directions for Cody Rhodes if he doesn’t finish his story at WWE WrestleMania XL

At WrestleMania XL, Cody Rhodes will face the biggest challenge of his career as he competes for the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship against Roman Reigns. This highly anticipated match marks The American Nightmare’s second opportunity to “finish his story”against The Tribal Chief, following his controversial loss at WrestleMania 39.

For many, The Grandson of a Plumber’s chance to claim the title that Dusty Rhodes famously missed out on at Madison Square Garden over 40 years ago is now or never. However, if he fails to complete the story in Philadelphia, what will happen if The American Nightmare falls short for the second year in a row?

These are three potential paths for Cody Rhodes in the event that he is unable to defeat Roman Reigns at WWE WrestleMania XL.

#3. The potential for a shocking heel turn by Cody Rhodes at WrestleMania XL

Since making his return to WWE, Cody Rhodes’ primary focus has been on achieving the one goal his father never accomplished – winning the title. This intense determination has propelled him to two back-to-back Royal Rumble victories, three main events at WrestleMania, and immense triumph as the company’s leading good guy. However, what occurs when his ultimate career aspiration seems to slip away from his grasp?

Drew McIntyre, just like the ultimate babyface, has the ability to transform from a heroic Superman to a ruthless Homelander in pursuit of his goal. This captivating direction has been showcased every week, allowing for The American Nightmare to deliver his greatest performances.

The examples of Hollywood Hulk Hogan, The Rock, and Roman Reigns himself, serve as evidence of how a heel turn can greatly benefit a wrestler’s career.

#2. Cody Rhodes puts his career on the line for a chance at the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship

In recent weeks, there have been indications that WrestleMania XL may mark Cody Rhodes’ final opportunity to challenge Roman Reigns for the Undisputed WWE Universal Title. Due to Reigns’ reign as champion, Rhodes may be restricted from pursuing this highly sought-after prize for the next four years.

For Rhodes to earn a third chance at the championship, The Tribal Chief would require highly significant stakes. A stipulation of Career Vs. Title could entice him, offering him the opportunity to finally defeat his nemesis. It would be especially fitting if this opportunity arose at Madison Square Garden, allowing him to vanquish his greatest rival at the site of his father’s biggest defeat.

This scenario would mark the moment when The American Nightmare successfully defeats The Head of The Table, creating a significant full-circle moment in WWE’s history. Additionally, it would pave the way for The Needle Mover to surpass Hulk Hogan’s 1474-day championship reign, which is reportedly a part of the company’s future plans.

#1. Potential Feud: Cody Rhodes vs The Rock

Some members of the WWE Universe have expressed their dissatisfaction with the buildup to the rematch between Cody Rhodes and Roman Reigns, noting that it resembles more of a feud between Rhodes and The Rock. This is understandable, as The American Nightmare has had more intense interactions and verbal sparring with The Final Boss compared to The Tribal Chief. Many supporters believe that the RAW superstar and The Great One should have a singles rivalry in the future.

If Rhodes were to lose at WrestleMania XL, his momentum could potentially be saved by a feud with The Brahma Bull. This rivalry could escalate and lead to a climactic showdown at SummerSlam, followed by The American Nightmare’s pursuit of a final opportunity against Reigns. If the beloved fan-favorite were to defeat the Tribal Chief, it would open up the possibility for the latter to have a non-title dream match with The People’s Champion at WrestleMania 41.