2025 One Chicago Crossover: How Overused Tropes Diminished the Story Quality

Warning! SPOILERS ahead for the 2025 One Chicago crossover, “In the Trenches.”

Overview of the 2025 One Chicago Crossover: “In the Trenches”

The 2025 One Chicago crossover, titled “In the Trenches, ”unfortunately diminishes its dramatic impact through an over-reliance on familiar tropes. True to the franchise’s tradition, this episode kicks off with a dramatic emergency call to Firehouse 51, culminating in a catastrophic gas explosion that appears to be intentionally orchestrated. As rescue workers grapple with the aftermath, they call upon their colleagues in the medical and law enforcement fields for support.

High-Stakes Situations and Character Encounters

The chaos of the explosion not only creates a series of harrowing situations but also places characters in emotional jeopardy.Mouch (Christian Stolte) and Platt (Amy Morton) find themselves in particularly profound predicaments. In a gripping moment, Chicago PD’s Ruzek (John Patrick Flueger) and Chicago Fire’s Kidd (Miranda Rae Mayo) work desperately to free a group trapped in a collapsed subway station, intensifying the narrative with urgency and tension characteristic of the One Chicago universe.

A Dive into Character Trials

Life-Threatening Circumstances for Platt, Ruzek, and Kidd

Caitlin Lenox, Trudy Platt, Mitch Ripley, and Randall Mouch McHolland in the 2025 One Chicago Crossover

This crossover shines a spotlight on three couples facing dire situations, leaving their partners feeling helpless. Platt’s scenario escalates as she confronts a suspect at the gas explosion site, only to be ambushed and shot, resulting in dire injuries causing her to bleed out and necessitating urgent medical attention at Chicago Med’s Gaffney Medical Center.

Meanwhile, Ruzek and Kidd find themselves locked in a train, cut off from external assistance due to the collapse above. Ruzek reassures Burgess (Marina Squerciati) that he will be fine, avoiding any final farewells for their daughter, Makayla (Ramona Edith Williams).Despite their dire circumstances, he successfully relays Kidd’s message to Severide (Taylor Kinney), emphasizing the importance of prioritizing relationships amidst chaos. However, with oxygen running low, tension escalates as Burgess and Severide grapple with the potential loss of their loved ones.

Critique of the Crossover’s Approach

Excessive Drama: A Double-Edged Sword

Amid declining viewership for Chicago Fire in its thirteenth season, the attempt to create a gripping episode featuring life-or-death stakes was commendable. However, introducing multiple intense storylines for three characters felt excessive.Focusing exclusively on Platt and Mouch’s narrative would have rendered “In the Trenches”significantly more impactful instead of diluting the tension with unnecessary additional threats to Ruzek and Kidd.

Considering Ruzek’s confirmed wedding to Burgess, the suggestion of his potential demise lacked credibility. A poignant portrayal of Severide and Burgess’s concern for their partners would have sufficed, fostering a more profound emotional resonance without overextending the dramatic stakes. This narrative strategy could have allowed for a heartfelt exchange between the couples, reinforcing their commitment to each other amid crisis.

Overall, while the concept bore promise, “In the Trenches”ultimately fell victim to the common trope of partner peril, overshadowing what could have been a richly developed storyline about the relationship between Platt and Mouch.

Source & Images