2 Potential Ways Battlestar Galactica’s Cast Could Reappear in a Reboot & Why I’m Not a Fan of Either

The future of the Battlestar Galactica franchise is currently shrouded in uncertainty. Sam Esmail’s much-anticipated reimagining for Peacock was canceled before it could launch, leaving fans in limbo. Despite years of development, the series struggled to find a new home amidst ongoing interest from other streaming services. The franchise, particularly Ronald D. Moore’s 2004 series, enjoys a passionate cult following, yet the beloved cast from that iteration poses a considerable challenge for any potential reboot.

As a fan, I envision the return of the original cast. However, if the reboot is to take place within the same universe as the 2004 series, it raises the question of how these characters can realistically fit into the new narrative. I would strongly oppose any rewriting of their identities into either Cylons or divine beings solely to facilitate their return, as it undermines the rich character development established over the years. Instead, it might be more fitting for them to portray entirely new characters, similar to the major transformations seen when Moore adapted the original show.

The Return of Old Characters: Cylons or Angels?

A Fresh Start: Casting as New Characters

Before its confirmation of being “no longer in the works,”Sam Esmail’s Battlestar Galactica project hinted at a new direction that would keep the essence of the original while moving away from Moore’s narrative. Esmail, a fan of Moore’s work, sought permission to explore a fresh storyline, keeping in mind that his vision would not replicate the previous narrative.

This approach implies the potential for an original story set within the established universe of the 2004 series. The challenge will lie in earning the affection of both returning fans and new viewers with fresh characters that resonate. If the original cast were to return, it might necessitate them reappearing as Cylons or divine entities. While this could attract die-hard fans, it risks complicating the existing narrative’s integrity. A more respectful tribute would involve them embodying new roles, thus honoring their past contributions without confusing the storyline.

The Dilemma of Human Characters Returning as Cylons

The Impact of Hera’s Hybrid Legacy

The series finale, “Daybreak,” sparked mixed reactions among viewers, primarily due to its profound theme of the perpetual cycle of conflict between humans and Cylons. The narrative’s conclusion, highlighting that humanity’s future descended from Hera—who is both human and Cylon—crafted a complex tapestry where the lines between the two races blurred. While the finale offered a certain clarity, it fell into an ambiguous acceptance of human nature, intertwined with the intricate morality established throughout the series.

Reintroducing human characters as Cylons in a reboot would undoubtedly undermine their carefully constructed journeys and the significant revelations from previous seasons. The moral complexities depicted in their arcs, especially moments like Tigh’s prioritization of his military identity over his humanity, were vital to the show’s impact. To alter these roles now would likely frustrate fans and lessen the resonance of the series’ overarching themes.

The Controversy of Returning Characters as Angels

Navigating the Complexity of Divine Roles

One of the most polarizing aspects of Battlestar Galactica is its exploration of religious themes, which intensify throughout the narrative. The original series drew from significant Mormon influences, while Moore’s reboot presented these themes with greater complexity. The finale’s implication that Starbuck may embody an angelic figure remains controversial; while some viewers found this intriguing, it arguably functions better as a singular plot device rather than a recurring theme.

The ambiguity surrounding Starbuck’s role—particularly her mysterious resurrection and subsequent guiding of the fleet to Earth—has generated extensive debate. Whether her character was always intended to serve as a prophet figure or if this was a later decision remains uncertain. Introducing angelic characters in the reboot could lead to narrative pitfalls unless handled with caution. Ronald D. Moore himself acknowledged the challenges posed by the finale and the narrative inconsistencies that came from the writing process. A successful reboot must learn from these pitfalls and sidestep potential overuse of divine or supernatural elements, which could undermine the original series’ brilliance.

Sources: Variety, Collider

Source & Images