10 Unmatched Buffy Episodes That the Reboot Will Struggle to Surpass

More than two decades after the beloved series Buffy The Vampire Slayer concluded, it remains a cultural phenomenon. Nevertheless, with Hulu preparing to launch a revival, there are concerns whether it can measure up to the iconic original. While the revival is still in early stages, it is evident that this new version must create its own identity rather than simply attempting to replicate the charm of the 1997 classic. Sarah Michelle Gellar, who famously portrayed Buffy, has expressed optimism that this reboot might be the refreshing revival fans have been longing for (source: The Hollywood Reporter).

As buzz surrounding the revival intensifies, it’s an opportune moment to reminisce about the episodes that solidified Buffy The Vampire Slayer as a standout series. Striving to outdo or clone any of these particular episodes could lead the revival to rely too heavily on nostalgia. Ideally, the series is anticipated to focus on a new generation of Slayers, positioning itself as an evolution rather than a mere reboot. These landmark episodes will serve as critical benchmarks, embodying the storytelling and emotional depth that made the original series so impactful.

10 Innocence

Season 2, Episode 14

Season 2 truly marked a defining moment for Buffy The Vampire Slayer, as the writing began to delve deeper into the themes central to the show. The episode “Innocence”captures Buffy’s pivotal emotional journey following her romantic encounter with Angel (David Boreanaz), which results in Angel losing his soul and transforming into Angelus. This heart-wrenching narrative illustrates the profound impact of first love, amplified by Buffy’s heavy burden as the Chosen One.

This episode not only alters the trajectory of Buffy’s character but reshapes her future relationships throughout the series. Gellar masterfully portrays the depth of Buffy’s despair as she grapples with the painful reality that someone she loved with all her heart has become her adversary. This episode’s intensity is a cornerstone for Buffy’s character development.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Innocence	9.2/10

9 Chosen

Season 7, Episode 22

Buffy The Vampire Slayer - Chosen Finale

While not considered the absolute finest episode, the series finale “Chosen”presents a poignant and satisfying conclusion for Buffy. Although it features significant loss and sacrifice, it heartens viewers by showcasing Buffy overcoming immense challenges and embracing the possibility of a more ordinary life post-battle. With the continuity seen in the comics post-series, it will be interesting to see how the reboot addresses this aspect.

“Chosen”serves as a perfect counterpoint to “The Gift, ”the almost finale that marked the end of season 5. Having already experienced death twice, Buffy’s final journey would have been underwhelming if concluded with a third sacrifice. Instead, “Chosen”highlights the universal potential for heroism, revealing that all individuals can possess a spark of greatness, and Buffy’s mission was to empower others.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Chosen	9.3/10

8 Tabula Rasa

Season 6, Episode 8

The sixth season of Buffy The Vampire Slayer delves into darker themes, yet “Tabula Rasa”offers a much-needed reprieve filled with humor. While providing comic relief is crucial, this episode transcends mere entertainment by allowing characters to voice their unfiltered thoughts and feelings devoid of their past burdens following the spell’s effects.

As soon as the spell dissolves, the crushing weight of lies and betrayals throughout the season falls heavily upon the characters.“Tabula Rasa”exemplifies the remarkable duality of season 6 by skillfully intertwining lightheartedness with heavy subject matter, illustrating why this season is often underrated. The originality found in such episodes will be difficult to replicate in the revival.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Tabula Rasa	9.1/10

7 Graduation Day Parts 1 & 2

Season 3, Episodes 21 & 22

While Buffy is widely recognized as one of the finest supernatural teen dramas, the series’ transition from high school to adulthood reaches a crescendo with the explosive conclusion of season 3. The show gives Sunnydale High an unforgettable send-off, culminating in its destruction—a fitting closure for Buffy’s high school tenure.

In the lead-up to this climactic moment, “Graduation Day: Part 1″foreshadows the tragic end of Buffy and Faith’s (Eliza Dushku) tumultuous relationship. Season 3 embodies a significant shift in the series’ narrative focus. If the revival allows for similar growth as the original, it can glean valuable insights from this pivotal conclusion without directly mimicking it.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Graduation Day: Part 1	8.9/10
Graduation Day: Part 2	9.1/10

6 The Wish

Season 3, Episode 9

Episodes of Buffy that focus on characters other than Buffy herself risk losing the series’ essence, yet “The Wish”skillfully navigates this challenge. This alternate universe episode introduces Anya (Emma Caulfield) as the demon Anyanka, who grants Cordelia’s (Charisma Carpenter) desire for a reality where Buffy never arrived in Sunnydale. This stark alteration serves as a reminder of Buffy’s critical contribution to the town and its safety.

Witnessing Willow (Alyson Hannigan) and Xander (Nicholas Brendan) transformed into soulless vampires and a version of Buffy devoid of friendship is particularly heart-wrenching. The episode showcases brutal dynamics of betrayal and violence, ultimately resetting reality but leaving viewers with a profound understanding of the alternate world.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
The Wish	9.1/10

5 Becoming Parts 1 & 2

Season 2, Episodes 21 & 22

The two-part finale “Becoming”delivers one of the series’ most powerful climaxes, showcasing Buffy’s struggle against Angelus. In this pivotal moment, she faces the heartbreaking reality of killing Angel, only to be met with the knowledge that he has been restored to his soul just moments before his fateful end. The brutal emotional toll of this episode on the teenage Slayer is immense, following a series of devastating losses.

While both parts are indispensable to season 2’s resolution, “Becoming: Part 2″stands out as a remarkable example of storytelling. It challenges the belief that Buffy can effortlessly juggle her responsibilities with her personal life, underscoring the high stakes that accompany her role as the Slayer.

By willingly letting go of her love and familial ties, Buffy proves that her destiny outweighs her personal desires, embodying the idea of ultimate sacrifice.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Becoming: Part 1	9/10
Becoming: Part 2	9.5/10

4 Hush

Season 4, Episode 10

If there’s one episode that encapsulates the creativity and tension of Buffy The Vampire Slayer, it is “Hush.”In this chilling episode, Buffy and her allies wake up to discover they can no longer speak, leading the narrative to unfold like a silent film where communication takes on innovative forms. The episode becomes even more terrifying with the menacing presence of The Gentlemen, who effectively embody the show’s theme of voicelessness.

In logical structural fashion, the episode’s stripped-down dialogue compels characters to reveal their authentic selves in ways that verbal communication often obscures, enhancing both interpersonal dynamics and emotional depth.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Hush	9.7/10

3 Once More, With Feeling

Season 6, Episode 7

Buffy and Spike in Once More With Feeling

Buffy and Spike - Once More With Feeling

The groundbreaking “Once More, With Feeling”set the standard for musical episodes in television. While many shows have attempted to replicate its brilliance, Buffy’s enchanting take stands unmatched. Despite its supernatural premise, the episode embraces an unexpected format that seamlessly integrates with the overarching narrative. The songs do not serve mere entertainment; rather, they compel characters to confront unexpressed feelings, ultimately unlocking profound emotional truths.

In the context of this episode, Buffy grapples with the trauma of having been in heaven and the daunting challenges of returning to a chaotic reality. With so many shows unable to replicate the magic of this format, the forthcoming reboot should carefully avoid similar musical endeavors, as none could capture the essence of this cherished original.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
Once More, With Feeling	9.7/10

2 The Gift

Season 5, Episode 22

The climactic season 5 finale, “The Gift, ”was originally conceived as a potential series close, marking a poignant culmination of Buffy’s narrative. This episode resonates deeply with themes of sacrifice and purpose, especially after the introduction of Dawn (Michelle Trachtenberg) and the shift in Buffy’s protective instincts from the world to her sister.

Buffy’s struggle encompasses profound existential questions about her identity as a Slayer, and the emotional toll death has taken on her. Ultimately, through her selfless act of sacrifice, Buffy demonstrates her ultimate heroism in putting her loved ones above her own life, rendering “The Gift” one of the show’s most defining moments.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
The Gift	9.5/10

1 The Body

Season 5, Episode 16

Among the most impactful episodes in the Buffy canon is “The Body.”This episode marks a pivotal moment in Buffy’s transition to adulthood as she grapples with the loss of her mother, Joyce (Kristine Sutherland).Notably, the episode stands out due to its unconventional format, lacking background music, a stylistic choice that accentuates the raw emotional weight of the narrative.

In “The Body, ”viewers witness every character uniquely process their grief, embodying poignant and authentic representations of loss that transcend genre boundaries. This unique execution enhances the series’ emotional depth and elevates its impact, creating a lasting resonance long after its conclusion. As the next chapter in the Buffy universe unfolds, it will be essential for the narrative to reflect on themes of death and loss, drawing inspiration from the profound emotional resonance demonstrated in “The Body.”Only original Buffy The Vampire Slayer could lend such gravity to this essential narrative.

Episode Title	IMDB Score
The Body	9.7/10

Source & Images