In the ever-evolving landscape of video games, certain genres emerge, captivating audiences with their distinct appeal. Roguelikes gained prominence through standout titles like Hades, while the world of farming simulations owes much to the pioneering spirit of developers like Eric Barone. However, few genres have maintained their popularity as robustly as the Soulslike category. Thanks to the creative genius of Hidetaka Miyazaki and FromSoftware, gamers have access to an impressive array of titles that fall under the “Soulsborne” umbrella.
Like any genre, the Soulslike category has its share of hits and misses. Some games, despite a lackluster reception from critics, are deserving of a second glance. This article aims to shine a light on those hidden gems within the realm of Soulslikes—titles that may not have received high praise but offer a rewarding experience nonetheless.
Defining Poor Reviews
For our selection process, we’ve established a clear definition of a “poorly reviewed”Soulslike: we focus on titles with an average score of 75% or lower on OpenCritic, while strictly adhering to their defined Soulslike category. With this criterion set, let’s delve into our curated list.
10. Enotria: The Last Song
Theater of War
Step into the enchanting realm of Enotria: The Last Song, where the echoes of a bard inspire players to grapple with formidable challenges. Set against stunning landscapes inspired by Italian folklore, the game captivates with its visual artistry.
While players revel in beautiful vistas of sun-drenched fields, they must also navigate a perilous world filled with larger-than-life adversaries. The strategic use of masks to adapt builds and the intricate art of parrying are crucial for conquering intense boss battles. Despite some performance issues and inconsistent combat mechanics, this title remains a hidden gem worth exploring for dedicated Souls enthusiasts.
9. Outward
Exploration Awaits
Often labeled as ‘Dark Souls for Couples’, Outward may resemble a fantasy RPG similar to The Elder Scrolls, yet it incorporates several elements that resonate with the Soulslike genre. This cooperative venture is ideal for players who appreciate methodical combat where each action counts.
The game’s vast, mysterious world invites players to carefully plan and strategize, presenting a formidable challenge that can send unprepared adventurers back to square one in an instant. If adventure is what you seek, gathering a partner and embarking on this journey can bring forth a rich experience.
8. Loot River
Puzzle Souls
Stepping away from traditional formats, Loot River surprises with its top-down perspective, offering a unique blend of Soulslike gameplay and strategic puzzle mechanics. Players manipulate a landscape of shifting platforms to outwit enemies while retaining their tactical edge.
This game emphasizes cerebral gameplay over the high-speed reactionary combat typical of the genre. For those ready to rethink their approach to Soulslike mechanics, Loot River promises an engaging and thoughtful experience.
7. SteelRising
French Revolution in a New Light
While Lies of P has set a high bar for machine-themed Soulslikes, SteelRising presents a compelling alternative. Crafted by the innovative team behind Greedfall, this game immerses players in an alternate history of the French Revolution.
Despite occasional quirks like uneven animations and level designs, the game shines with its engaging storytelling and dynamic combat. For newcomers curious about the genre, this title serves as a welcoming entry point.
6. Death’s Gambit
Existential Challenges
With its updated version ‘Afterlife’, Death’s Gambit has undergone a noticeable transformation since its initial release. While some may criticize its earlier version, I believe it provided a unique experience filled with potential for growth.
The combat system, while demanding, offers an avenue for satisfying mastery. True fans of punishing gameplay will appreciate its homage to classic Souls mechanics, even if certain elements felt underdeveloped. Ultimately, this game is one that merits a second chance.
5. Thymesia
Combat Dynamics Reimagined
With a bold departure from the norm, the developers behind Thymesia took risks that paid off. Despite a narrative that lacks depth and a gameplay duration that falls short compared to its peers, the combat mechanics present an engaging challenge.
The unique double HP system encourages aggressive gameplay, compelling players to remain on the attack rather than lurk in the shadows. If you’re seeking a different take on the Soulslike formula, this title may prove satisfying.
4. Lords of the Fallen (2023)
Dual World Dynamics
The original Lords of the Fallen left much to be desired, but the 2023 reboot has ambitious design elements that should not be overlooked. The innovative dual-world mechanic adds depth, allowing players to shift between the living realm and the Umbral world, unveiling new challenges and secrets.
This iteration also features versatile combat mechanics and compelling cooperative play options. While it is not without its flaws, this title offers a fresh, engaging experience for Soulslike fans.
3. The Surge
Attempting to carve out the Sci-Fi Soulslike niche has proven challenging for many, but The Surge stands out as one of the strongest candidates. Although its sequel surpassed it in quality, the original laid the groundwork with innovative combat mechanics and a unique upgrade system.
There are areas for improvement, particularly in narrative and level design, yet the core mechanics remain enjoyable and engaging. With a willingness to overlook some initial shortcomings, The Surge demonstrates the potential of the genre.
2. The Last Faith
Gothic Horror Redefined
Many are baffled by the unremarkable status of The Last Faith within the Soulslike community, as it offers an impressive 2D experience reminiscent of classics like Bloodborne and Castlevania. With its atmospheric gothic horror aesthetic and challenging combat, it beckons players to master its intricate mechanics.
Though some may argue that the most rewarding abilities are locked until later in the game, the overall experience is captivating enough to warrant persistence. This title could very well be the standout 2D Soulslike of your gaming library.
1. Code Vein
A Unique Experience
Despite its mixed reception, Code Vein deserves more recognition for its distinct blend of anime storytelling, dynamic combat mechanics, and JRPG elements. This genre mash-up may alienate purists, yet within it lies an enriching experience, particularly when played in co-op mode.
While it may not align perfectly with traditional Soulslike values, those willing to embrace its unique flavor will find their efforts richly rewarded.
Leave a Reply