In the realm of gaming, imitation often serves as the sincerest form of flattery. Throughout the years, numerous instances have arisen where games have drawn inspiration from their predecessors. While some of these imitations fall flat, others rise to the occasion, surpassing their inspirations by crafting a richer and more engaging experience.
The elements that can be borrowed include everything from game mechanics and aesthetics to the overall atmosphere. We’ve all encountered games that evoke a sense of familiarity, prompting a moment of recognition, often leading to discussions about their influences. When executed well, these game imitators not only succeed in borrowing elements but also enhance and elevate them, resulting in a superior gaming experience.
In this article, we will explore a selection of games that have effectively outperformed their inspirations, showcasing how creativity and innovation can transform the industry.
10 Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon
A Scrolls-Like That Says “Bethesda, Hold My Beer”
Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon draws clear inspiration from the Elder Scrolls saga, mirroring aspects like starting in a prison cell and constructing an immersive world. However, it distinguishes itself with RPG mechanics and quest design that significantly outperform its predecessors, especially when considering the rich narrative and side quests that entice exploration without the need for navigation aids.
Its combat system is notably superior, paired with intriguing writing that recalls the spirit of classic titles such as Baldur’s Gate 3, yet offered with a unique Arthurian flair. With a proper budget akin to that of an Elder Scrolls game, the potential for this developer is boundless.
9 Lies of P
The Best Souls Game
Lies of P has emerged as a standout entry in the souls-like genre, offering an experience that rivals even the most iconic titles. At first glance, it mimics the aesthetic and gameplay mechanics of Bloodborne, but as players delve deeper, they find a distinct world brimming with creativity and narrative depth that redefines the traditional formula.
The combat system allows for extensive customization, featuring a plethora of unique weapons and skills. Moreover, the innovative retelling of the Pinocchio saga in this dark, twisted context adds a layer of intrigue that sets it apart from its influences. With exceptional boss battles and rich side quests, Lies of P delivers everything one could desire from a souls-like adventure, and then some.
8 Pillars of Eternity
Bringing the CRPG Back
Pillars of Eternity pays homage to classic CRPGs such as Baldur’s Gate 1 and 2, yet it forges its own identity with a fantastical setting that feels refreshingly original. Released in 2015, it revitalized the genre during a time dominated by open-world RPGs, offering gameplay that felt both nostalgic and innovative.
The intricacies of its party system, rich narrative details, and philosophical themes echo the beloved elements of its predecessors while introducing modern game design sensibilities. Its sequel has built upon this strong foundation, further solidifying its legacy.
7 Fortnite
A Stolen Idea, A Cultural Moment Born
Fortnite has risen to become one of the most recognized names in gaming history, permeating popular culture through media references and collaborations. Though its foundation shares common ground with games like Player Unknown’s Battlegrounds, Epic Games managed to create a unique experience that captivated millions.
Its gameplay innovations—particularly the building mechanic—coupled with a vibrant, approachable art style differentiated it from its entropic predecessor. As a result, Fortnite transitioned into a multifaceted platform for social interaction and entertainment, securing its position at the forefront of the gaming industry.
6 Bioshock
From the Depths of Space to the Bottom of the Ocean
Bioshock stands as a cornerstone of video game design, yet its lineage can be traced directly back to System Shock. Initially, Ken Levine’s experience on System Shock 2 paved the way for a reimagining that took place in an underwater dystopia rather than in space.
Key themes of control, obedience, and the transformation of utopian ideals into dystopian nightmares enriched this title, resulting in overwhelming success and a renaissance of interest in the System Shock franchise.
5 Sleeping Dogs
Grand Theft Action
Sleeping Dogs, while somewhat affiliated with the True Crime series, stands apart as it draws notably from the Grand Theft Auto (GTA) franchise. This game offers a compelling narrative coupled with engaging gameplay, reminiscent of crime cinematic masterpieces such as The Departed.
One of the standout features is its melee combat, which utilizes mechanics found in the Arkham series and delivers memorable gameplay moments. With incredible environments and action sequences, Sleeping Dogs offers a gritty take on the open-world genre that, in many aspects, eclipses its more famous counterparts.
4 Splinter Cell
Move Over, Solid Snake
Although this may invoke debate, many argue that Splinter Cell surpasses its well-known counterpart, Metal Gear Solid. The game approached stealth with a seriousness that led to profound changes in gameplay dynamics and expectations.
Players found themselves immersed in realistic espionage missions, demanding precision and discretion rather than cartoonish antics. The gadgetry and lighting effects utilized in Splinter Cell have yet to be matched, providing an intense atmosphere requiring strategic thinking and skillful execution.
3 Unicorn Overlord
Inspired By The Past
Unicorn Overlord effectively revives the strategic depth of the Ogre Battle series while enhancing it with advanced gameplay options. Although it draws from the classics, its gorgeous art style and intricate mechanics breathe new life into a beloved genre.
The game encourages customization and provides varied combat strategies, granting players unique experiences. This revival is a testament to its ability to honor the past while paving the way for innovation in future titles.
2 Bayonetta
The Action Standard
Bayonetta emerged from the shadows of Devil May Cry, taking inspiration from the classic action game but exceeding all expectations. The director’s signature style is apparent, but Bayonetta amplifies it with an exhilarating combat system and charismatic character design.
Its unique mechanics, such as the “Witch Time” feature and seamless integration of humor with high-stakes action, have set a new benchmark in the genre. Bayonetta’s impact has established it as an unforgettable icon in the gaming landscape.
1 Call of Duty
No Honor Here
Call of Duty did not initially dominate the military shooter landscape; that title belonged to Medal of Honor. The latter set high standards with its immersive narrative and depiction of historical events. However, in 2003, Call of Duty entered the scene, reshaping the genre by adopting a more cinematic approach to warfare.
The evolution that followed, most notably with Call of Duty: Modern Warfare, established a new standard in military shooters, overshadowing its predecessor and ultimately redefining expectations for subsequent titles for nearly two decades.
Leave a Reply