The world of Gotham is a treasure trove of captivating character arcs, plot twists, and unexpected betrayals. Despite its rich storytelling, several significant DC plotlines were planned but ultimately never came to fruition on screen. The series offered fans a thrilling insight into James Gordon’s early experiences within the Gotham City Police Department while providing origin stories for numerous notable figures from the DC Universe. Yet, amidst its compelling narrative, numerous proposed storylines were scrapped, either before filming or within the production process itself.
Running for five seasons from 2014 to 2019, Gotham explored the roots of Batman’s legacy. Though the show garnered a loyal following, challenges arose that complicated its storytelling. The fifth season, initially planned for 22 episodes, was truncated to just 12, necessitating the swift resolution or exclusion of multiple plotlines. Apart from these logistical hurdles, creative choices and audience feedback influenced the decision to drop several story arcs, impacting the overall narrative fabric of the series.
10
Barbara Kean’s Transformation into Harley Quinn and Magpie
In The Comics, Barbara Isn’t A Villain At All
Throughout the show’s evolution, the creative team considered evolving Barbara Kean into two well-known DC characters: Harley Quinn and Magpie. This transformation aimed to mirror Barbara’s mental breakdown, reflecting Harley’s chaotic origins. Showrunner John Stephens ultimately dismissed this direction, determining that the series needed a unique interpretation of Harley. Barbara’s existing trajectory and dramatic focus provided sufficient narrative tension, rendering the planned transformations unnecessary.
Another concept for Barbara saw her becoming Magpie, a jewel thief obsessed with shiny items, fitting her extravagant character. However, even this idea fell by the wayside, as Stephens later labeled it as “a terrible idea.”Barbara’s narrative arc ultimately shifted toward her rise as a formidable crime boss, while the character of Magpie was introduced through another figure in the show, marking a significant deviation from initial plans.
9
The Untimely Death of Jerome Valeska
Jerome Valeska’s Role Evolved Beyond Initial Expectations
Cameron Monaghan’s portrayal of Jerome Valeska quickly captured audience admiration, positioning him as a significant player within Gotham’s exploration of the Joker’s origin. Interestingly, Jerome was initially intended to meet his end during the third season’s “Mad City: The Gentle Art of Making Enemies,”where his death by beheading would have symbolized the culmination of his chaotic existence.
However, as the series progressed, creators opted to deepen Jerome’s connection to the Joker lore, thereby extending his storyline and introducing his twin brother Jeremiah Valeska. This shift complicated the originally intended representation of Jerome as merely a catalyst for the Joker, restructuring their relationship and influence over the city.
8
James Gordon’s Possible Evolution into Another Character
Ben McKenzie Hints at a Dramatic Transformation
During the promotion of season 3, actor Ben McKenzie hinted at a possible storyline that would see James Gordon adopting an identity connected to another prominent DC character. This revelation suggested an intriguing twist in Gordon’s narrative arc, potentially transforming him into a vigilante or aligning him more closely with Batman’s ideology.
Such a direction could have explored Gordon’s darker persona, as he navigated the chaotic landscape of Gotham alongside Bruce Wayne. Unfortunately, this storyline was not pursued, keeping Gordon grounded as a steadfast moral authority without the intended evolution into a more complex character.
7
Ivy Pepper’s Potential Inclusion in the Gotham Sirens
Gotham Renamed Pamela Isley to Ivy Pepper for Their Poison Ivy
The Gotham Sirens—Catwoman, Poison Ivy, and Harley Quinn—have long been revered in DC lore. Showrunner Danny Cannon initially indicated that Ivy Pepper would join Barbara Kean, Tabitha Galavan, and Selina Kyle as part of Gotham’s interpretation of this iconic trio. This story arc aimed to explore the dynamics and strengths of these formidable female characters within Gotham’s criminal underworld.
However, various factors led to the abandonment of this concept. Ivy underwent substantial character changes, including rapid aging and recasting, complicating her potential integration into the Sirens narrative. The constraints of the shortened final season further stunted the opportunity to explore this ensemble, leaving Ivy’s connections to the group largely unexplored while maintaining a distance from other characters.
6
Tabitha Galavan Expands into the Tigress Persona
In The Comics, Tabitha Is Known As Tigress
Throughout her journey on Gotham, Tabitha Galavan’s narrative was closely linked to her brother Theo and later Barbara Kean. In the comics, Tabitha takes on the identity of Tigress, a fierce villain recognized for remarkable agility and combat skills. The show hinted at her potential transformation through her combat style and numerous tiger references, particularly with her use of a whip.
Had the series continued past its shortened fifth season, Tabitha’s journey may have fully embraced this Tigress persona while engaging in the significant No Man’s Land storyline. It would have marked her growth from supporting character to a primary player in the chaotic power dynamics of Gotham.
5
Penguin’s Intended Assassination of Ventriloquist
Ventriloquist Was Frequently Referred to As Mr. Penn In Gotham
A notable deleted plotline involved Penguin and the Ventriloquist, whose character was introduced toward the series’ conclusion. The original concept involved Penguin eliminating Ventriloquist following a betrayal. This drastic action would have highlighted Penguin’s ruthless nature, showcasing the severe consequences of double-crossing him.
Yet, actors Robin Lord Taylor (Penguin) and Andrew Sellon (Ventriloquist) advocated against this violent resolution, emphasizing the unique comedic and nuanced relationship they had crafted. They sought to preserve the complexity of their characters, allowing for a relationship defined by dark humor rather than straightforward betrayal and murder.
4
The Riddler’s Iconic Cane and Bowler Hat
Riddler Is Normally Adorned In His Famous Question Mark Cane And Bowler Hat
In the planned series finale, “The Beginning…,”the Riddler was set to finally acquire his iconic question mark cane, symbolizing his full transformation into the beloved villain fans recognize from the comics. A pivotal scene hinted at this evolution through a mysterious confrontation with a man in a hat, who supplied the cane and bowler.
However, in the reshaped sixth season, numerous Riddler-centric plotlines were streamlined significantly, and one such narrative envisioned him living in a library, exhibiting bizarre behavior and surrounded by tattooed riddles, was drastically minimized. This left much of Riddler’s character development underexplored, marking a missed opportunity to fully realize his potential within the series.
3
Clayface’s Return to Gotham
Clayface Had Previously Appeared In Gotham
Having exhibited shape-shifting abilities in earlier seasons, Clayface was slated to have a more prominent storyline in season 4, where his backstory and motivations would be fully explored. Co-creator Danny Cannon mentioned that this reintroduction aimed to deepen audiences’ understanding of one of Batman’s most nuanced adversaries.
Sadly, plans to bring Clayface back were ultimately shelved, largely due to the time constraints imposed by the abbreviated fifth season. Viewers missed out on a potentially rich narrative arc that could have provided additional horror and tragedy, similar to versions in animated adaptations like Batman: The Animated Series.
2
Bruce Wayne’s Infiltration of No Man’s Land
Bruce Wayne Was Set To Leap Into Action Before Becoming Batman
The climactic No Man’s Land storyline, pulled from the comics, served as a setting for Gotham’s final season. Initially, Bruce Wayne was scripted to play a more prominent role, engaging different factions within Gotham while experimenting with disguises. This storyline aimed to showcase Bruce’s growing intelligence and his strategic endeavors preceding his transformation into Batman.
The reshaping of Bruce’s character arc minimized significant developmental aspects, including essential collaboration with Alfred and Lucius Fox. While elements of his journey remained, the ambitious plan for his emergence as Batman was curtailed, narrowing the scope of the character’s evolution.
1
The Rift Between Mr. Freeze and Firefly
The Elemental Villains Teased A Confrontation
The conclusion of season 4 introduced a potential conflict between Mr. Freeze and Firefly, setting the stage for a compelling rivalry in the subsequent season. This narrative hinted at an explosive clash between Freeze’s chilling strategies and Firefly’s dynamic unpredictability, promising an engaging exploration of their conflicting interests.
Regrettably, neither character appeared in the final season. While their conflict was merely referenced in “Year Zero,”fans were left lingering on what could have been – a dynamic interaction between these elemental foes that would have intricately woven into the fabric of Gotham‘s already tumultuous landscape.
Related Articles:
First Look: Wes Anderson’s ‘The Phoenician Scheme’ Stuns at CinemaCon
4:46
‘Because I Knew You’: My Perspective After Watching ‘Wicked: For Good’ Footage
4:42
Cast of ‘Jurassic World: Rebirth’ Discusses Filming Challenges for Their New Dinosaur Adventure
23:47
Leave a Reply