Japanese Role-Playing Games (JRPGs) often embody a familiar structure, a trend that dates back to the classic Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest titles. Typically, players assume the role of an underdog hero, assembling a diverse team of characters to embark on an epic quest that culminates in climactic confrontations with godlike figures.
This well-established formula has produced countless memorable gaming experiences, but it’s important to recognize that not all titles achieve the recognition they deserve. Some games may be dismissed as ‘bad’ even when they offer engaging experiences that merit a second look.
This article aims to illuminate several JRPGs that, despite receiving mediocre reviews, harbor hidden depths and engaging gameplay worth exploring. We’ve curated this list based on titles classified as JRPGs on Opencritic and Metacritic that have garnered an aggregate score of 75% or lower, many of which are even lower.
10 Card-En-Ciel
A Creative Card-Builder
Among the titles featured in this roundup, Card En Ciel stands out as one that, while receiving favorable reviews, truly deserved more acclaim.
This visually stunning game merges JRPG elements with traditional card-building mechanics, crafting an experience that is both tactical and incredibly enjoyable. Players will find themselves immersed in a narrative reminiscent of Sword Art Online, accompanied by gripping visuals, an energetic soundtrack, and exhilarating boss battles.
While some criticism points to the game’s brevity, its strengths lie in its remarkable replayability and addictive nature. This cleverly designed card builder is a hidden treasure in the JRPG landscape, even if it has flown under the radar of mainstream critics.
9 Atelier Firis: The Alchemist and the Mysterious Journey
Crafting on the Clock
Reflecting on the evolution of the Atelier series, Atelier Firis marked a significant shift towards an open-world format, though it faced some initial growing pains.
This entry introduced features such as limited item duplication and cumbersome party member management, partnered with a comparatively weaker battle system. However, the most significant backlash stemmed from the inclusion of time constraints, which conflicted with the game’s otherwise relaxed open-world design.
Despite these challenges, Atelier Firis boasts one of the franchise’s most compelling narratives, a charming world to roam, and the signature alchemy gameplay fans have come to love. The unique time parameters add an intriguing layer to exploration, making it an underrated gem that fans of the series should not overlook.
8 Lightning Returns: Final Fantasy XIII
Lightning’s Redemption
Although Final Fantasy XIII received mixed reactions, many view Lightning Returns as a standout sequel that successfully addresses its predecessor’s shortcomings.
While FFXIII was critiqued for its lack of depth in gameplay, Lightning Returns invigorates the experience with a more strategic battle system and a dynamic open world filled with activities. This installment also provides character development for Lightning, enhancing her storied existence while streamlining previous narratives.
Despite its troubled lineage, Lightning Returns shines as a unique and worthy addition to the franchise, making it the only installment of the FFXIII trilogy truly worth experiencing.
7 Pokemon Ranger
Walk The Walk
The Pokemon franchise is no stranger to quirky spinoffs, with varying levels of success. Among these, Pokemon Ranger often finds itself unfairly categorized as a “bad game” for its unique gameplay mechanics.
This title leveraged the Nintendo DS’s touch controls effectively, introducing a straightforward yet engaging approach to capturing and shielding wild Pokemon. While the repetitive looping mechanic could take a toll on the console’s touchscreen, the immersive experience made it a worthwhile adventure.
Despite its apparent gimmicks, Pokemon Ranger remains an enjoyable game that is certainly worth revisiting, especially for fans looking to dust off their old DS.
6 Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure
Cult favorite Rhapsody: A Musical Adventure might not have won over critics upon its initial release, but it holds a special place in the hearts of many JRPG enthusiasts.
This whimsical title features a delightful narrative and simplified RPG mechanics, making it an excellent entry point for newcomers to the genre. Its vibrant soundtrack is both catchy and engaging, ensuring players will hum along while navigating its charming world.
While some may find the repetitive gameplay unappealing, the standout moments and lighthearted storytelling support a fun and nostalgic experience. Perfect for casual gamers or those seeking a more accessible RPG.
5 The Last Remnant
An Xbox 360 Relic
During the Xbox 360’s era, several intriguing JRPGs slipped through the cracks, notably The Last Remnant, which failed to garner widespread recognition despite its potential.
While the narrative’s execution and character depth might leave something to be desired, the game features engaging gameplay that is reminiscent of the SaGa series, making it a hidden treasure worth revisiting on your Xbox 360.
4 Beyond The Beyond
Give to God
Some JRPGs commit to complex systems that alienate many casual gamers, leading to harsh critiques.Beyond the Beyond is a quintessential example of such a game.
3 Lost Sphear
One for the Setsuna Fans
When titles aim to emulate classics like Chrono Trigger, bias often colors opinions.Lost Sphear fell victim to this perception, being dismissed as mere nostalgia bait.
Nevertheless, this game brings a satisfying experience with a retro aesthetic, enjoyable combat, and an engaging soundtrack, akin to its divisive predecessor, I Am Setsuna. While its narrative may disappoint some, the overall experience merits consideration and discussion.
2 Kingdom Hearts 3: ReMind
Fixing a Flawed End-Game
Including a DLC expansion on this list may seem unconventional, but Kingdom Hearts 3: ReMind deserves recognition for enhancing an otherwise lackluster endgame experience.
While the main game fell short in several areas, particularly in combat depth, ReMind introduces engaging boss gauntlets and detailed narrative moments, transforming the overall experience. The DLC may not have met fan expectations for story expansion or additional content, yet its quality and improvement on the original game are undeniable.
1 The Legend of Dragoon
A True PSX Gem
The neglect of The Legend of Dragoon in discussions of the PSX’s finest JRPGs is baffling, as it offers an experience that matches the era’s greatest titles.
With spectacular pre-rendered backgrounds, full voice acting, and an impressive soundtrack, this game captivates players from the start. The cast of characters is engaging, and while its battle system may require some adjustment, it ultimately rewards players with entertaining combat.
While the storyline may feel familiar, and its timing mechanics can be finicky, these shortcomings do not overshadow the overall brilliance and immersive qualities of the game. A remaster with quality-of-life enhancements could further elevate its legacy, reclaiming it in contemporary discourse. Initially released in 1999, this title remains a captivating experience for players today.
Leave a Reply ▼