10 Poorly Rated Cozy Games That Are Surprisingly Enjoyable

Cozy games, with their charming aesthetics and gentle gameplay, might seem unlikely targets for harsh critiques from gaming reviewers. However, as an experienced critic who has encountered both delightful and lackluster iterations of the cozy genre, I can attest that some titles are indeed deserving of their negative reviews. Yet, it’s also clear that some wonderful gems slip through the cracks and receive undeserved bad ratings.

For the purpose of this discussion, we are specifically focusing on independent (indie) games that have garnered an aggregate score of 75 or lower on Opencritic. The aim is to shed light on those cozy titles that have been unfairly criticized but hold much to offer the gaming community. Below, you’ll find a curated list of such games that deserve a second chance.

10 Storm Boy

A Brief Yet Impactful Journey

This title may ignite debate among players who typically favor shorter games, often played to quickly achieve trophies and accomplishments. However, after diving into Storm Boy for that exact reason, I was pleasantly surprised by the powerful emotions packed into this brief experience—lasting just over an hour.

While the gameplay consists of straightforward mini-games, they effectively complement the game’s poignant narrative. Based on strong source material, this bargain-bin title shines much brighter than its reviews suggest.

9 Little Orpheus

Produced by The Chinese Room, a studio known for quality, Little Orpheus’ lukewarm reception baffled me. Having played it myself, I quickly realized that the critics missed the mark.

Unlike many side-scrolling platformers like INSIDE or Little Nightmares, Little Orpheus aims to tell an engaging story, one that is surreal and well-paced, set against stunning biomes and enjoyable platforming mechanics. Critics pointed to the game’s simplistic puzzles and quirky narrative elements as shortcomings, but this doesn’t diminish the charm of this visually captivating game.

8 Graveyard Keeper

A Darker Twisted Take on Farming Simulators

Despite the eerie ambiance of Graveyard Keeper, I find it confounding that the cozy gaming community did not embrace it wholeheartedly. This game serves as a perfect Halloween companion to beloved titles like Stardew Valley and Coral Island.

Though the gameplay leans towards the grim, it maintains the essential crafting and resource management mechanics typical of cozy games, coupled with quirky characters.

Critics expressed concern over the time investment required for crafting and progression, but games like Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 demonstrate that patience often yields rewarding gameplay experiences. Graveyard Keeper, despite its grind, offers the same level of enjoyment found in similar titles.

7 Drake Hollow

An Entertaining Gateway into Survival Games

If you enjoyed the indie sensation Palworld, you’ll likely find joy in Drake Hollow. Although it has some imperfections, it shouldn’t be penalized with the low review scores it received.

This cozy survival title allows players to explore various environments, tame adorable creatures called Drakes, and gather resources to enhance your camp. It features distinctive Drakes with unique characteristics, a well-integrated resource management system, and an undeniable charm represented in its visuals.

Admittedly, combat leaves room for improvement, but it’s infrequent enough that it won’t deter you from enjoying the overall experience. Considered a perfect introductory title for newcomers to the survival-crafting genre, Drake Hollow certainly has more to offer than critics bestowed upon it.

6 Mineko’s Night Market

A Feline-Focused Adventure

While Mineko’s Night Market faced criticism upon launch due to numerous bugs, it has since stabilized, allowing players to appreciate its countless strengths. Rich with a distinct art style and centered around cats, the game boasts an addictive gameplay loop that encourages exploration and quest completion, culminating in delightful market visits.

This cozy title requires patience, as it takes time to fully appreciate its charms. However, those willing to invest effort into connecting with the characters and mastering the crafting system will undoubtedly discover joy within this kitty-centric indie experience.

5 Overland

A Unique Apocalypse Experience

At first glance, Overland—a post-apocalyptic survival game—might seem an odd fit for the cozy category, yet I assure you it’s more aligned than you might think.

This turn-based roguelike combines an engaging road trip survival format with intricate tactical mechanics. Players are faced with challenging decisions, enhancing each playthrough with thoughtful choices while navigating the dangers of a broken world.

Although its overall narrative is minimal, the gameplay itself is enough to keep players engaged. It polishes the roguelike formula in a way that doesn’t necessitate high-stakes excitement to be enjoyable. Buckle up and take a trip into this distinctive survival experience.

4 Turnip Boy Commits Tax Evasion

A Hilarious Adventure

It’s easy to dismiss Turnip Boy as merely a quirky mascot in a simplistic Zelda clone. In reality, this title has much more going for it than that reductionist view suggests.

Unfolding as a top-down adventure, Turnip Boy offers laugh-out-loud humor and whimsical storytelling. Whether you’re embracing your inner rogue to avoid taxes or joining a criminal conspiracy, the game provides ample opportunities to engage in mischief.

Combat mechanics may not break new ground, but the game excels with one of the best endless gauntlet modes found in indie gaming. While its sequel may surpass it, the first installment remains an enjoyable experience filled with comedic gold.

3 Yooka-Laylee

Living Up to a Legacy

Spiritual successors often grapple with heavy expectations set by their predecessors. Yooka-Laylee faced backlash primarily because it was not Banjo-Kazooie.

However, despite not reaching the iconic heights of RARE’s classic, Yooka-Laylee still offers a quality experience with engaging platforming and open-world levels teeming with collectibles.

The game’s DLC enhances the experience further, presenting challenging yet rewarding platforming segments. While its non-linear approach may come off as confusing to casual players, those who embrace its charm will find a rewarding adventure.

2 The Beginner’s Guide

A Thought-Provoking Narrative

Given the acclaim surrounding The Stanley Parable, it is often perplexing that The Beginner’s Guide receives comparatively less appreciation. This title, created by the same visionary, offers a more nuanced narrative that explores themes of game development and its impacts on creators.

Though it diverges into more self-reflective territory, it captivates through a beautifully composed experience that delves into the complexities of artistic expression. The lack of comical relief does not detract from its importance and depth, marking it as an overlooked gem deserving of recognition.

1 Octodad: Dadliest Catch

Hilarious Chaos Awaits

This title straddles the line between moderate reviews and those that were less favorable, yet it remains a worthy inclusion on this list.

In the era of intentionally awkward controls illuminated by titles like Surgeon Simulator and I Am Bread, Octodad stands as a unique triumph. It combines humorous narratives with mission-based gameplay, all enriched by amusingly clunky controls that add to the hilarity of routine tasks.

Often dismissed as a gimmick, Octodad deserves recognition for balancing humor and enjoyable gameplay, arguably positioning it as a standout entry in its genre.

Source & Images