In the realm of gaming, nostalgia often clouds our judgment, particularly concerning some immensely popular titles. This is especially true for JRPGs, where epic narratives and engaging gameplay can mask underlying flaws that players might overlook. As a devoted fan of this genre, I’ve delved into its best offerings, though I must concede that certain games have garnered more acclaim than they might warrant based on their actual merits.
This article will explore a selection of renowned JRPGs that, while enjoyable, may be considered overrated when evaluated against their ratings and reception. Let’s examine these titles closely.
10 Octopath Traveler 2
No Sense of Pacing
While Octopath Traveler 2 offers several enhancements over its predecessor, it ultimately falters in one critical aspect: pacing. Players often find their narrative momentum interrupted as they transition from one of the eight character storylines to another, abruptly forcing a switch before fully engaging with the previous arc. This structural decision disrupts immersion, creating a disjointed experience that detracts from the overall interest in each character’s journey.
9 Bravely Default
Can’t Hold a Candle to the Classics
Emerging during a period when JRPGs seemed stagnant, Bravely Default ignited a spark of nostalgia for many fans, serving as a response to the divisive Final Fantasy XIII saga. Developed by Silicon Studio, this title features a combat system that creatively integrates risk and reward mechanics. However, it suffers from shallow character development and repetitive gameplay, particularly the infamous requirement to replay Chapter 5 multiple times, which cripples its pacing and engagement. In addition, the awkwardly presented fan service raises uncomfortable questions about character portrayal and appropriateness.
8 Metaphor: ReFantasy
Struggles to Make You Care
Despite appearing on many Game of the Year lists, Metaphor: ReFantazio left me questioning the reasoning behind its praise. While it boasts impressive combat mechanics and an eye-catching visual style, the central narrative fails to resonate. The story’s stakes, revolving around a power struggle for kingship, lack depth, and character development feels contrived. Each character often embodies generic archetypes, impeding player connection. Lengthy exposition takes precedence over engaging storytelling, unnecessarily extending the game’s duration without meaningful payoff.
7 Tales of Arise
We Thought You Were the Chosen One
Offering a refreshing take on JRPGs, Tales of Arise initially dazzled fans and critics alike, garnering multiple awards. However, the excessive padding and repetitive combat mar the experience. The game introduces an intriguing narrative about societal oppression but quickly descends into convoluted plot developments, straying far from its grounded beginnings. Prolonged battles with overexposed enemies do not enhance enjoyment, and the 20-hour wait before players can fully engage with the story reveals a flaw in pacing rather than a triumph in storytelling.
6 Person 5
High School Is Boring
Persona 5 is often heralded as a masterpiece; however, its lengthy introduction severely hampers enjoyment. While the game shines visually and becomes compelling after the first significant investment of time, many players may feel discouraged by the monotonous tasks preceding the more thrilling aspects of gameplay. The social simulation elements overshadow the RPG experience, and while the game does eventually explore engaging themes, the foundations frequently trip over outdated mechanical executions that detract from its overall legacy.
5 Final Fantasy 7: Rebirth
Unfocused
In many respects, Final Fantasy 7: Rebirth advances the narrative initiated in its predecessor. Yet, the overly frequent mini-games disrupt the story’s flow, leading to an imbalance between immersive storytelling and distracting gameplay mechanics. Key narrative moments are interrupted by incongruous carnival activities, detracting from the gravity of the experience. The interpretation of iconic locations, especially those demanding emotional weight, suffers due to misplaced focus on less relevant gameplay elements.
4 Legend of Heroes: Trails of Cold Steel 3
Legend of Exposition and Bad Dungeons
Often celebrated within the Legend of Heroes franchise, Trails of Cold Steel 3 is rife with exposition that burdens the player with lengthy dialogues devoid of substance. The immense reliance on previous game knowledge does more to alienate potential new players, and the uninspired dungeon designs — a series of uncreative corridors filled with uninspired foes — contribute to a uninspiring gameplay experience. Despite its acclaim, the title confounds with its tendency to overestimate its narrative depth.
3 Xenoblade Chronicles 2
The Game That Won’t Get Out of the Way
Praised as a pinnacle within its series, Xenoblade Chronicles 2 struggles with gameplay pacing. The combat system evolves frustratingly slowly, hindered by convoluted tutorials that may deter players early on. The randomized gacha mechanics for acquiring Blades contribute to a grind-heavy playstyle that, while designed to encourage investment, becomes tedious. Moreover, character designs often veer into absurdity, presenting an imbalance that can undermine engagement with otherwise well-crafted systems.
2 Suikoden II
It Doesn’t Hold Up
Often revered as a classic, Suikoden II struggles under the weight of its own reputation when compared to the landmark titles of its era. Released in 1998, it appeared dated even at launch, showcasing simplistic combat and uninspired level design alongside less compelling storytelling elements. While the sheer number of recruitable characters is a notable feature, the overall depth and complexity do not reach the heights of contemporaries, rendering it less memorable in the long run.
1 Final Fantasy 12
Your Participation Is Optional
A distinct entry in the Final Fantasy series, Final Fantasy 12’s approach to gameplay polarizes fans. The Gambit system reduces the player’s active role during combat, which many may find disengaging. While the game presents an expansive world and intricate designs, the lack of a focused narrative voice deprives players of a central emotional anchor, often making it difficult to fully invest in the central characters and their journey.
The discussion about these beloved, yet possibly overrated, JRPGs reflects the ongoing evolution and standard of the genre, inviting both fans and newcomers to reassess what they seek in their gaming experiences.
Leave a Reply